4 ms·
I never understood how the public decided that "autopilot" means a fully autonomous system. I grudgingly admit that some people think this way, but how did it h
by mikeash 10y ago
I never understood how the public decided that "autopilot" means a fully autonomous system. I grudgingly admit that some people think this way, but how did it happen?
- maxxxxx 10y agoTo me it clearly means that the system is autonomous while the autopilot is on. What else should it mean?
- the8472 10y agoPilots aren't allowed to leave the cockpit just because the plane is on autopilot.
- alistairSH 10y agoYet, there are documented cases where the pilots have had enough faith in the system to take a nap or play around on their laptops.
- maxxxxx 10y agoThey certainly don't have to be ready to intervene within a fraction of a second as you have to do with Tesla.
- mikeash 10y agoReal-world autopilots cover a wide range of pilot aids, down to something as simple as a gyroscope mechanically connected to the rudder in order to automatically hold heading. Most are more capable than that, but typical autopilot features would involve holding heading, altitude (or rate of climb/descent), and speed, or navigating towards a particular point. Fully autonomous autopilots are extremely rare, and I'm not aware of any commercial system where the pilot is allowed to ignore the airplane while the system is engaged. So, again, how did you get this idea?
- throwaway729 10y ago> So, again, how did you get this idea? Because, as JonnieCache pointed out, the colloquial definition of Auto Pilot is more informed by entertainment than by the aerospace industry. What's more baffling is why anyone would assume that the average person knows what "auto pilot" means in an aerospace setting. I mean, why in the world would that be common knowledge? In fact, I've seen enough bone-headed assertions about collision avoidance capabilities of modern aircraft that I'm pretty certain even people who think they know what auto pilot means, actually don't. FWIW you can test this by finding people outside of the tech echo chamber who don't know what a Tesla is and asking them to describe the capabilities of a car with an Auto Pilot.
- mikeash 10y agoYou're not answering the question, you're just repeating the basis of it. I accept that people think it means it's autonomous. Stop repeating that as if it were new to me. What I want to know is why people think that. "Because everybody thinks that, if you'd bother to ask them" is not an answer to that question.
- throwaway729 10y ago> What I want to know is why people think that Re-read the first sentence of my post. Perhaps you could answer my question: why would you assume someone with no knowledge of the aerospace industry would understand what the term auto pilot means in that context? Why would anyone assume the TCAS specification has a greater effect on public perception than the latest comic book movie?
- mikeash 10y agoDo you have examples of this misconception being propagated by entertainment? I'm having trouble thinking of any, but that might just be my low level of knowledge. I'm not going to answer your question because you're trying to make me defend a position I'm not taking here.
- 10y ago
- JonnieCache 10y agoBecause every use they've ever seen of that phrase up until now has been in sci-fi shows, where the autopilot is an AI that flies the ship while you go back to the lounge to play 3d chess and drink dry ice cocktails? In a world where you're constantly bombarded with press releases about self driving cars and how theyre just around the corner, its not exactly unexpected to think that an autopilot system will pilot your car automatically, especially when tesla is so heavily associated with silicon valley. It may have a real use in planes or boats but approximately noone is familiar with that.
- masklinn 10y agoThere's also the part where the sky doesn't have many obstacles, so once you engage the autopilot you can probably go and take a piss, an alarm will go off if something's weird and the copilot will have more than enough time to get their bearings, if only because you're 30kft up not 5ft away from the obstacle.
- Buttons840 10y ago"autopilot" "autonomous" Why is it so surprising that people think the prefix "auto-" means automatic or autonomous.
- mikeash 10y agoIt does mean automatic. Automatic does not mean "no human intervention or supervision" though. And it's surprising because "autopilot" has been a real-world technology for about a century and that real-world technology almost never allows pilots to leave the plane unsupervised.
- alistairSH 10y agoA non-pilot probably has very little clue how an actual airline autopilot works. Nor would I expect them to.
- mikeash 10y agoI wouldn't either, but I would expect either knowing that or not knowing how it works at all, not "knowing" that they're fully autonomous. But I'm probably expecting too much.
- Buttons840 10y agoI typed "define automatic" into Google and got "working by itself with little or no direct human control".
- RodericDay 10y agoEvery time I hear this "defense" it reeks of disingenuous fanboyism. People invoke factoids about how autopilot for airplane pilots works (they have training!) as if it was common knowledge. Let's be clear here: Very few people know anything about airplane cockpits. When people read "autopilot" they think "automatic pilot" ie: the thing drives itself, similar to "auto login" login you in without a click. Marketing knows this, we all know this, let's not pretend it was an innocent mistake.
- mikeash 10y agoIt's great that you think I'm being disingenuous. I'm not even defending it here. I'm just asking a legitimate question: how did people end up with this impression? I seriously do not understand it. "Automatic" does not imply "requires zero supervision."
- pjc50 10y agoPeople got the impression from films where the autopilot is a plot device: a character turns it on and then leaves the controls to go further the plot of the film. Also, http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/autopilot http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/autopilot "a device that steers a ship, aircraft, or spacecraft in place of a person" In place of. Not under the constant supervision of.
- mikeash 10y agoI don't see how that definition conflicts with real autopilots. The autopilot does the steering instead of the human. The human supervises. On a ship, for example, the helmsman is steering, but the officer of the deck is in charge.
- pjc50 10y agoIt doesn't necessarily conflict, but for someone who has no experience of real autopilots (ie most people), the assumption would be that it can do the job of driving the car so they don't have to.
- blackguardx 10y agoLook at how the word was formed. It came from Automatic - "(of a device or process) working by itself with little or no direct human control" and Pilot - "a person who operates the flying controls of an aircraft" In the 50s or 60s or whenever they were first introduced, it was incredibly novel to have some portion of aircraft control handled by a machine. To go from partial machine control to fully machine control seems like a natural evolution and I think the name speaks for that evolution. I think it is fair that most consumers think that "autopilot" implies fully autonomous driving. No one calls cruise control an autopilot when in fact it is a crude form of one.
- mikeash 10y ago"Little or no direct human control" is pretty far from "zero human supervision" so the etymological argument doesn't really do it for me. Lots of cars have "automatic transmissions" but nobody gets upset when it fails to shift into reverse on its own based on contextual clues.
- electic 10y agoA big part of this is movies. When they show auto-pilot in the movies, people get up and just leave. There are countless times I have seen this play out in the movies and people think cars with the same name should behave the same way.
- DavidWanjiru 10y agoIs "auto" in autopilot short for automatic or automobile? It's just occurred to me it could be either if you want to be strict or pedantic. I automatically assume it's short for automatic pilot, which most people would assume means "it drives - pilots - itself," and that may be reason people assume the technology is more like a chauffeur. But if by autopilot Tesla mean automobile pilot (I admittedly don't think that's the case), then the meaning would probably change.
- mikeash 10y agoIt does drive itself, with human supervision. Just like the automatic transmission shifts gears by itself but still needs human input.
- UnoriginalGuy 10y agoThat's a strange example. An automatic transmission needs no human input at all. You put it in D, and leave it in D, until you stop driving most of the time. Did you mean manual transmissions?
- mikeash 10y agoIt's pretty common that you need to shift it to R. Nobody leaves it in D while backing out of a parking spot and then complains that the automatic transmission didn't do its job when they collide with the wall in front of them.
- icebraining 10y agoSure, when you want to indicate a different intention, you need to interact with it, but you don't need to keep watching over it in case it suddenly switches to R.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]