2 ms·
"Strong disagree. Apple's implementation of background services looks more like a vindication of the defenders." But it's not. And you can disagree, but you a
by jasonlotito 17y ago
"Strong disagree. Apple's implementation of background services looks more like a vindication of the defenders."
But it's not. And you can disagree, but you are wrong. The defenders I'm referring to were supporting not having multitasking; or, better said, were touting lack of multitasking as a feature. Their were other defenders who were for multitasking, but against doing it poorly. I'm referring to the former, not the later.
- tptacek 17y agoI'm sorry but I don't agree with you that I'm wrong. The lack of jailbreak/Android-style multitasking is still a feature. The fact that they took the time to implement it as carefully-designed background services means I don't have to deal with process killers and don't lose my battery to moronic apps that busypoll on GPS. Or, as they said: "In multitasking, if you see a task manager, they blew it. Users shouldn’t have to ever, ever, ever think about that stuff."
- jasonlotito 17y ago"The lack of jailbreak/Android-style multitasking is still a feature." "The lack of multitasking is still a feature." You added qualifications for a reason. Because they say completely different things. You seem to want to suggest I'm arguing against the first. I'm not. I'm arguing against the second.
- tptacek 17y agoYou are getting tangled up because there are two features we are talking about here. The first feature is an app ecosystem that doesn't require me to babysit processes. The second feature is the ability to do things in the background (or, more precisely, do things with more than one application at a time). I don't care what you call them, but that the iPhone has always had the first feature, and talking it up isn't crazy. I don't think that it makes up for not having the second feature, but I still recognize it as something that makes my iPhone experience better.
- jasonlotito 17y agoThe problem is, you equated multitasking to being done one way, and no other way. Other people did this. No multitasking was a feature. It cannot work. It's bad. I equate it to the result, not the implementation. I don't care how it gets done, as long as it gets done without ruining the rest of the experience. Not too long ago, we were reading iPad reviews disregarding the lack of multitasking as unneeded. Comments would fill up with mac-addicts defending the lack of multitasking suggesting things like "How can you see two windows on an iPhone" and other crazy things like that. People questioning the needed for multitasking, as well as suggesting that no multitasking was a feature, not a missing feature. So now everyone is looking at Apple's MT and saying "WoW! It's so amazing!" and the rest of us are saying "It's MT done for the iPhone, okay." It's what we've been asking for, and what so many people were saying to us "It's bad" or "It will hurt the experience" or "MT on the iPhone is a waste." Maybe you weren't one of those people, but I had enough respond to me saying these very things. And it's just nice to know that Apple, in the end, agreed with me and people like me.