3 ms·
The issue is the camera being used to violate your privacy. A hardware switch that lets you physically disable the camera, or a a lens cover that stops it seein
by onion2k 10y ago
The issue is the camera being used to violate your privacy. A hardware switch that lets you physically disable the camera, or a a lens cover that stops it seeing anything, stops the possibility of that happening completely. You'd obviously need a second system in order to stop an attacker using your microphone.
All a light does is inform you that the camera is active. That is not a defence. It doesn't tell you that you've been hacked because an attacker might not access the camera (a mic and data are still accessible), and the camera light might activate if you haven't been hacked (eg any piece of software that you're using might result in the camera activating regardless of whether you want it to or not) which would lead to many false positives and as a consequence people would ignore the light.
A light is only information, and any amount of information won't stop an attack. Information is only available after you've been attacked, so you haven't stopped or mitigated the problem. A hardware solution that stops people accessing the camera mitigates the result of an attack before it happens. That's why it's much better. You just have to remember that blocking the camera only stops attacks that use the camera. You still need to be diligent about other attack surfaces.
- Houshalter 10y agoI really don't understand this reasoning at all. If you just block the camera you won't know that your computer is being hacked. The piece of tape isn't going to stop the hacker from doing much. Knowing my computer is hacked is far more important than stopping the attackers from seeing me. If you have a false positive that is also very concerning and should be dealt with. At the very least I can put a piece of tape over the camera after the light turns on, if I believe it's a false positive.
- onion2k 10y agoAt the very least I can put a piece of tape over the camera after the light turns on At which point it's already too late - the hacker has had access to your camera for some period of time, until you notice the light. If you're interested in stopping people seeing you then you've failed. Putting a hardware block on the camera (eg tape) before you're hacked means that the hacker won't ever get access to your camera to see you. The hardware block is about stopping people accessing your camera. It has no effect on anything else. Regardless of what you do with your camera you still have to defend against other ways you can be hacked.
- Houshalter 10y ago>At which point it's already too late - the hacker has had access to your camera for some period of time, until you notice the light. Yeah for like 10 seconds. Who cares? The problem with webcams is they can spy on you for days and weeks on end, and record your sensitive conversations.
- tantalor 10y agoRecording conversations has nothing to do with the camera. You might be thinking of the microphone. Should we put a little LED on that too?
- Houshalter 10y agoYes of course. It should be connected to both. You can't put a piece of tape over a microphone.
- tantalor 10y agoBut the microphone is always on if you enable voice activation, e.g., "Okay Google", "Hey Siri", "Hey Cortana". That recognition is handled in software, so no "hacker proof" hardware indicator can distinguish between the use cases. "Hey Siri" works on desktop devices: https://9to5mac.com/2016/07/15/how-to-enable-hands-free-hey-siri-voice-activation-on-macos-sierra/ https://9to5mac.com/2016/07/15/how-to-enable-hands-free-hey-... "Okay Google" was removed from desktop: http://www.theverge.com/2015/10/16/9553051/ok-google-removed-from-chrome-46-desktop http://www.theverge.com/2015/10/16/9553051/ok-google-removed...
- Houshalter 10y agoYes, and I have my own issues with unprompted voice activation for that exact reason. I think that having the mic light always on when you enable voice activation, would go a long way to showing consumers the risks of it. It makes it visually obvious that you are being recorded.