3 ms·
genetic factors are responsible for 60-80% of the variance in IQ That is untrue, and is known to be untrue by the leading researchers on human behavioral genet
by tokenadult 17y ago
genetic factors are responsible for 60-80% of the variance in IQ
That is untrue, and is known to be untrue by the leading researchers on human behavioral genetics.
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1177649 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1177649
The current view by the researchers most familiar with the data is that broad heritability figures report, for a given sample, simply that monozygotic twins tend to be more similar than dizygotic twins, and close relatives tend to be more similar (across a HUGE range of human behavioral traits) than more distant relatives. But the pre-Mendelian methodology of compiling broad heritability figures FAILS as a prediction of how subject one trait or another is to environmental influences. It is well known that some traits with very high heritability (physical stature is the classic example) are nonetheless very subject to variance in differing environments. No one should take one heritability figure or another as a statement about how much or how little a trait can vary if the environment is manipulated experimentally. Any good, current genetics textbook mentions this.
- theoneill 17y agoSo what percentage of the variance do they account for?
- tokenadult 17y agoWhat exactly do you mean by your question? I'm not sure what you mean, but I'm happy to respond further if I can make sure to understand correctly what you are asking about.
- theoneill 17y agoYou say it's false that genetic factors account for 60-80% of variance in IQ. What is the current consensus about the actual number? 50%? 10%?