6 ms·
What I don't understand is why there's such a double standard between children and adults when it comes to this sort of behavior. If someone attacks me as an a
by mikeash 10y ago
What I don't understand is why there's such a double standard between children and adults when it comes to this sort of behavior.
If someone attacks me as an adult, I have every right to defend myself. The police will be called, and if it's possible to identify the perpetrator and prove beyond a reasonable doubt that they attacked me, they will go to jail. If the police aren't able to find the attacker or prove that they did it, then I'm allowed to take countermeasures such as avoiding the area, carrying some sort of defensive measures (pepper spray, or even just a gun), or having someone escort me.
Do the same thing to a child, and there's often minimal punishment, the victim and perpetrator are not separated from each other in the long term, and the victim is strongly encouraged not to fight back.
Can you imagine telling a victim of a mugging (or worse) to "just ignore them" the next time it happens?
We create these Lord of the Flies type situations for children, then basically tell them that problems shouldn't be happening, if they are then we won't help, but the children shouldn't do anything about them either. And then we are shocked, shocked, when children suddenly go all psycho on their tormentors.
If a business had a constant known problem with physical violence among its employees and patrons, they'd be forced to reform or shut down, and people would go to prison. Schools should be the same. It's the responsibility of the people in charge to keep the students safe, both from outside threats and from each other. If they can't do that, then they need to be replaced by people who can.
Until and unless that ever happens, then students' best option will be to retaliate.
- jacobr 10y ago> Can you imagine telling a victim of a mugging (or worse) to "just ignore them" the next time it happens? Isn't this standard advice, to just give them your money and avoid escalating the situation?
- mikeash 10y agoYes, but they'll also make efforts to find and imprison the mugger, suggest being prepared for physical violence in case it ends up being necessary next time, and other such things beyond that.
- noxToken 10y agoIt's a slightly different situation. A mugger probably has the advantage of a weapon. Even if you have one as well, their weapon is already prepped for use, so trying to defend yourself against an already brandished weapon is not advisable. Children in schools likely do not have weapons. It's hand-to-hand fighting with only weapons of opportunity (e.g. heavy books) available, and the provoking child likely isn't ready to use a weapon of opportunity. Granted I'm not inherently saying that a victim should always deck a bully in the face. If that were the case, however, I'd say that child v bully has the advantage over the mugger v victim.
- mikeash 10y agoThat's an excellent point. When people tell you that you should comply with a mugger, that's because there's a serious threat of being killed, and compliance offers the best chance of surviving the encounter.
- rabboRubble 10y agoYes for mugging, but not if you are dealing with a would be rapist. Don't fight back, have your account of the event questioned and doubted... https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/grade-point/wp/2015/06/23/why-many-rape-victims-dont-fight-or-yell/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/grade-point/wp/2015/06/2...
- vkou 10y agoFight back against a rapist, maybe get seriously injured or killed. It's damned-if-you-do, damned-if-you-don't.
- rabboRubble 10y agoYeah, there was a news article in the last couple of weeks about that very thing. Apparently the Baltimore PD have been marking rape reports as unsubstantiated because, at least in one case, the woman didn't fight back under verbal threat. There is something funky with the law either in MD or in Baltimore (don't remember which) that requires the rapist to actually do violence (apparently the unwanted penis isn't enough) for the rape to be counted as a certain type of sexual assault. So all the would be rapist has to say "if you fight back, I'll kill you", the victim believes the rapist and doesn't fight back, and bingo-bango under the law, the rape is unsubstantiated. In at least one case, a serial rapist rapist walked free because he had no prior history of sexual crimes. Because prior reports were unsubstantiated since the prior victims didn't fight back. Tried to find this article without joy. One of the bajillion I come across via RSS.
- wyager 10y agoIn some social groups. Rural Texan society would probably advocate shooting a mugger. I suspect the Texan approach is better for society as a whole.
- Singletoned 10y agoDo you mean that it is better for society that Texans get shot, or that we should all be shooting muggers?
- logfromblammo 10y agoIt would be better if all muggers were afraid of the possibility of being shot by their chosen victims. While some fraction would then escalate to rendering their victims unable to shoot prior to approaching, I think a greater fraction would simply choose a less confrontational way to acquire spending money. Those who did not change tactics would eventually get shot. If the prey people change tactics, so will the predator people. Shooting the muggers tends to produce a wilier, more dangerous, harder-to-shoot breed of mugger. There will be fewer of them, but instead of waving their knife in your face, they will bash the back of your head with a rock. While you are out, they will photograph everything in your wallet before putting it right back in your pocket, and take just your phone and gun. Then if you don't report all your cards as stolen, someone buys your details from a darkweb site, does a little social engineering, and cleans out your accounts.
- wyager 10y agoMugging isn't a profitable enough business to inspire the kind of organization you're imagining.
- logfromblammo 10y agoIf I ever damaged my prefrontal cortex to the point where I could incorporate muggings into my personal revenue stream, I would definitely... be a fence for the people that I would advise to perform muggings in that way. Maybe I could also write an app for victims to do self-service muggings, or on-demand muggings--partially automate the process, to improve the mugging experience. See, the real problem with robbing people one at a time is the labor factor. One mugger can rob--what?--maybe two or three people a day without getting caught? I don't even know. There just aren't enough career criminals out there to serve the whole market. If you could somehow automate the process of stealing just a little bit of money from a lot of people, all at once, all the time, that would totally disrupt... ...the banking industry.~ [cue rimshot] Thank you. I'll be here every open mic night.
- squeaky-clean 10y ago> Isn't this standard advice, to just give them your money and avoid escalating the situation? Yeah, and I think it's the best advice for a one-off incident like a mugger or running into bullies in the park. Just worry about your own safety, get out of there as soon as you possibly can, and don't return. A mugger isn't the best comparison. But what if the mugger is there every day at 6pm when you're getting out of the office? Do you just keep buying a new wallet and giving it to them every day? What if the mugger works for the same company as you, and sits 50 feet from you, and every time you walk by them to go to the bathroom they make that exaggerated knuckle-cracking gesture while staring your down and mouthing "six o'clock". Getting bullied in the playground is one thing. It sucks. You can't go back to that park without being beaten up. But if the bully is in your school then your parents, teachers, government all mandate that you see that bully 5 days out of the week.
- Joeboy 10y agoWe have that double standard because physical assaults in schools are normal, and physical assaults in workplaces are unusual. Same kind of reason tobacco is legal and MDMA isn't.
- mikeash 10y agoI would argue that it's the other way around: the difference is there because of the double standard.
- munificent 10y agoNo, the difference is there because kids are different from adults. Their brains are different, their level of responsibility is different, they are different kinds of people. Humans are naturally physical animals. Get some toddlers together, and (in addition to lots of other nice behavior like sharing and talking), they will push, grab, hit, etc. each other. We're primates and we do primate-y things. As we get older, we learn the mores of our culture and learn to not physically interact with people in this way, but that process takes a lot of time. Kids haven't completed it yet (some adults never do). In the meantime, we have to provide an environment that handles the fact that they are behaviorally different from respectable, trustworthy adults. Above, you say "We create these Lord of the Flies type situations for children", but the whole point of Lord of the Flies is that savagery is how children naturally act when taken outside of the strictures of society. A Lord of Flies situation doesn't have to be manufactured by adults—it's what you get if you don't work hard to prevent it.
- mikeash 10y agoI would argue that the point of Lord of the Flies is that savagery is how people naturally act when taken outside society. The fact that it's natural means nothing. It's natural for small groups of humans to make war on their neighbors, to kill their men, rape their women, and enslave their children. But we don't put up with that kind of thing now, for the most part. I agree with your last sentence, but my question is: why aren't they working hard to prevent it? Of course children have to learn this stuff, it's clearly not innate, but if they're going through their school years being bullied then clearly they're not learning the lesson.
- CaptSpify 10y agoYou have to remember the goal of the school: To avoid a lawsuit. If they tell a kid to fight back, they are opening themselves up for trouble. Their best option is to tell everyone to stop fighting, and hope the problem goes away.
- mikeash 10y agoThen they should be held liable for allowing violence to occur. That would fix the problem pretty quickly.
- CaptSpify 10y agooften times it can be a he-said she-said situation though
- mikeash 10y agoIf my child regularly sustained serious injuries at home, Child Protective Services would eventually stop accepting my failure to supervise her as an excuse. Schools should not be allowed to get away with it. This problem can be solved. The trouble is that it probably requires money, which taxpayers really hate to provide.
- ScottBurson 10y agoSurveillance cameras are pretty cheap these days.
- 1ris 10y agoAs Mikeash said, it's a he-said she-said situation when there was no supervision. If it is frequently (or even usually) a he-said she-said that means there is not enough supervision.
- M_Grey 10y agoThat's going to change the very second a wearable emergency 360 deg camera starts to be marketed to parents of bullied kids, and is adopted widely.
- GauntletWizard 10y agoYes. The modern school systems are a criminal institution, teaching kids not to fight back against a lifetime of bullying and abuse. I am currently taking a previous landlord to small claims court (The had the temerity to withhold my entire security deposit and ask me for more to pay for expenses that are explicitly the landlord's under California law). When I have talked to my peers, I've gotten two reactions; One is a "hit them for all they've got", and one is "Why would you do that? They have money and power!" The former from my peers who were homeschooled (as was I, in part), the latter from those who'd gone through traditional schooling. Modern US schooling is more-or-less intentionally training to not fight injustice, to not speak up unless spoken to, to fail to learn. Zero Tolerance policies are just one symptom. Spend some time in a classroom and you'll see the teachers favoritism, trying to be 'cool' and catering to the popular kids (and further alienating the unpopular ones), telling kids that they're wrong when they're ahead of the class and more right than the teacher wants to teach. Modern curriculums have been watered down and focus grouped into meaninglessness. Scholae delenda est.
- alasdair_ 10y agoI too have had a California landlord have "the temerity to withhold my entire security deposit and ask me for more to pay for expenses that are explicitly the landlord's under California law" and started the process to take him to small claims court. I started legal proceedings too. I went to a "traditional" school, so I think you are perhaps reading too much into things. As an aside, I recommend asking for receipts for all of the expenses they are claiming and keeping track of the deadlines for the provision of paperwork. In my case, the landlord had 21 days to provide receipts or they were liable for the FULL deposit. They failed to provide receipts, admitted so in writing and then stopped talking to me entirely for a bit until I pointed out that CA law allows for automatic triple damages for landlords witholding security deposits and that they had already missed their deadline to return the required paperwork to me.
- ScottBurson 10y agoThat would be "Scholae delendae sunt". I guess your homeschooling didn't include Latin grammar :-)
- dimino 10y agoJust to be clear, the parent of my comment is absolutely not true. You are told the adult equivalent of "just ignore them" when faced with a mugging (do what they say, give them what they want, your wallet isn't worth your life). Furthermore, in most states, you do not have a legal "right" to stand your ground when attacked, you are expected to retreat if possible, and there are very frequently countersuits on the behalf of the assailant that are successful in civil courts, not to mention the criminal charges that may stem from "defending yourself" against an assailant, especially depending on how much damage you do. It's alarming to me the number of people in this comment section who believe violence will solve a problem for children or adults. It's also alarming this "if adults were in situations like children are" analogy is getting so much attention. Kids are not adults, they lack the cognitive capacity to reason as adults, and need safe places to learn how to be humans. We're casually throwing away hundreds of years of experimental results and academic consensus on childhood because our two-minute reasoning is superior. Come on, HN, we can do better.
- mikeash 10y agoAre you implying that locking hundreds or thousands of children in a building all day with periods of minimal supervision is a system built on hundreds of years of experimental results and academic consensus? You are not simply told to ignore muggers. You are told to comply with muggers because muggers are life-threatening. You are also told to fight back if they go from threatening your wallet to threatening your physical well-being. Many places will actually send out the authorities to search for and imprison muggers after you report them. You are definitely not supposed to "just ignore them," you're supposed to do what it takes to survive, then report them, and have them brought to justice. I don't see people saying violence is a solution, only that it can sometimes be the best choice out of a bunch of bad ones if you're in a situation where the authorities have failed you and you have to fend for yourself. Me, I'm advocating the exact opposite of violence being a solution: I'm saying, repeatedly, that schools need to do more to prevent violence, precisely so children don't have to take matters into their own hands. Come on, you can do better than this weird straw-manning.
- theorique 10y ago
- jupiter90000 10y agoBe careful of heeding this as fact, depending on the laws of the locale you could end up in prison, subject to civil suits, and/or other consequences for practicing violent behavior even if it is in self-defense. For example, an eyewitness may only see you break the assailant's arm and miss that they initiated aggression. Then you go to court and are held liable for damages to your assailant plus a felony charge, because the assailant's lawyer was able to convince a jury you used greater than necessary force or even that there were no witnesses to support your assertion that the assailant initiated the attack, and then you are labeled as the violent felon. So what's the solution? Not easy to decide, but if these situations are a concern best to think ahead and get appropriately prepared instead of just reacting with unrestrained violence..
- conductr 10y agoI guess I see your point, but I disagree. Part of sticking up for yourself is willing to risk these things. The bully's advantage is that he is willing to break the rules and you aren't. So you have to break the rules and risk some of these things that may happen. Maybe just draw the line at snapping the kids arm and you'll be safe.
- jupiter90000 10y agoNo, a person may not be safe under the law when doing that. There are ways to minimize legal risk and also fighting back, if one is willing to look into them. Risking going to prison and becoming a felon to prove yourself is foolhardy. Edit: one example of this back-firing: http://crimefeed.com/2014/10/bullied-teen-charged-with-assault/ http://crimefeed.com/2014/10/bullied-teen-charged-with-assau...
- dismantlethesun 10y agoGetting back to the original premise: would the same advise be given to adults that is regularly given to children? If an adult comes to tell you that they are being regularly harassed and beaten up by a coworker, will they be told to be careful about retaliation, and oh shucks since there's no direct proof of anything we can't separate you from your attacker? No. And I think there's a good reason (not that I particularly agree with it). People, the justice system in general, trust adults to be reasonable and act within the law so anyone who goes to a police officer and says X man attacked me is believed. With children, there's always the question in the back of the mind "did they lie to get their enemy in trouble? are they pushing boundaries? Are they just seeking attention? Are they exaggerating?" For an adult, just your word that you were attacked is often good enough to kick start an investigation for physical evidence. For a child attacked by another child, their word is often not seen as good enough.
- hindsightbias 10y agoMy generation grew up with "It takes two to fight" For most victims, it was never a fight, it was an outright assault. But it's how places of involuntary incarceration work.
- cgag 10y agoPeople don't respect children as actual humans. I think that's pretty much the answer with most children related problems.
- cgag 10y agoPeople don't respect children as actual humans. I think that's pretty much the answer with most children related problems.
- Retra 10y agoAs an adult, it is far easier to avoid your tormentors. Adults tend to be better at measuring risk as well: picking a fight with me, for example, would mean voluntarily engaging in a physical confrontation with a fully grown, professionally trained combatant who happens to be a member of the most violent species ever known to exist in the universe. If you attack me, one of us will become a murderer. There's little reason to go down that road, and I'll make sure you know it. However, children don't really think, nor are they permitted to follow through on that kind of threat. And they tend to care more about what they are permitted to do.
- mikeash 10y agoYes, exactly. Everybody saying "but you're not supposed to resist muggers" is missing the point. If you get mugged by the same person 47 times in a row, you're not going to keep getting that advice. A one-off incident at school which goes unpunished is troubling but understandable. It's the repeated long-term bullying that gets nothing but shrugs and "ignore it and it'll go away" that is completely nuts.