5 ms·
If you want freedom from government interference in your life, Somalia is still a pretty good bet. And no, I am not being facetious. People like to think of f
by lisper 10y ago
If you want freedom from government interference in your life, Somalia is still a pretty good bet.
And no, I am not being facetious. People like to think of freedom as a scalar, but it's actually a vector with complex interactions among its various dimensions, one of which is the government.
That said, I am absolutely signing the petition. Ed Snowden put a lot more on the line by blowing the whistle than I am by signing.
- hutzlibu 10y agoErm no. In Somalia you do have a lot of government interference - you just have many smaller (wannebe) ones there, fighting against each other for power, vs. one big.
- lisper 10y agoBut "one big" vs "wannabe" is the defining characteristic of a government. The reason that Somalia is universally considered a failed state is precisely because it has many smaller wannabe governments fighting each other rather than one big government maintaining order. And that is precisely my point: people think of freedom as a scalar, as the absence of constraints on their personal decision-making. But this is wrong. Your decisions are always constrained, if not by "government" (however you choose to define it) then by your fellow humans. And if not by your fellow humans (e.g. if you go live in the middle of Nunavut) then by the laws of physics.
- antisthenes 10y agoThat's exactly the scenario that would happen in a libertopia most libertarians describe - minimal government. It's an incentive for other actors to try to imitate the role of government through other means. Actually, not just Somalia - Africa is ripe with examples of these.
- pbarnes_1 10y agoPower vacuums are not left unfilled for long. Also, I've never met a "true" (in the sense that they tell you about it as soon as you talk to them) libertarian who isn't also a raging asshole. But there are assholes on all points of the spectrum, so I'm not sure what that proves. :D
- smsm42 10y agoThe question is not "most free from government", but "most free". It's like answering the question about which restaurant is most sanitary by suggesting to eat nothing at all - of course, you'll starve to death but at least no chance for food poisoning! And you're wrong about Somalia btw: they do have a government, which collects taxes, introduces regulations and does all good government supposed to do, including corruption. [1][2][3] > Ed Snowden put a lot more on the line by blowing the whistle than I am by signing. Well, yeah, by signing you are putting absolutely nothing on the line so that's true :) [1] http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/africa/5176102.stm http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/africa/5176102.stm [2] http://www.hiiraan.com/news4/2011/jan/17383/somalia_s_government_plans_regulations_taxes_for_mobile_phone_operators.aspx http://www.hiiraan.com/news4/2011/jan/17383/somalia_s_govern... [3] http://goobjoog.com/english/?p=20975 http://goobjoog.com/english/?p=20975
- lisper 10y agoYou're right, the halcyon days of the 1990's, after the complete collapse of the Somali government, do seem to be drawing to a close. You might try Yemen or South Sudan.