15 ms·
How Did GM Create Tesla’s Dream Car First?
- samfisher83 10y agoEveryone should watch the documentary: who killed the electric car People loved the EV1. It had its limitation due to the battery tech at the time. If they had kept up the program up we would probably have a $35000/200Mile electric car by now.
- maxerickson 10y agoCould that GM afford to keep the program running? It went out of business 8 years ago. I also wonder how much impact selling money losing electric vehicles would really have had on battery research (vastly better batteries are the big difference between 2002 and now...).
- jtrip 10y agoThe documentary mentioned above implies that the car was killed, not because it was uneconomical, because the law that insentivised them to make the car wasn't worked out properly and the car companies found killing the law insidiously, and the car, a better option than complying with it. The company truly was enthusiastic about the electric car, but then the law played unfavourable and they had to kill it.
- maxerickson 10y agoYeah, but it was massively uneconomical. They were leasing it for less than $500 a month and producing it at a cost higher than $50,000. Of course people thought that was great.
- WorldMaker 10y agoA great follow up documentary is Revenge of the Electric Car from the same documentarian. He was invited to witness the launches of the Chevy Volt, Nissan Leaf, and Tesla Model S.
- imh 10y agoMy grandpa had one of those, and I thought it was the so cool. For a general commuter car, it worked perfectly for him.
- codeulike 10y agoTesla fans (e.g over at r/teslamotors) are watching the Chevvy Bolt with interest. Persuading other manufacturers to make electric cars is, after all, consistent with Tesla's mission (accelerate the advent of sustainable transport...). I think the Bolt looks really good, and the recent range announcement is really exciting. I still can't quite believe it is happening, it seems like GM might still mess it up somehow. Will they make the Bolt in large enough numbers? Will the dealerships bury the car and fail to promote it properly? It will be really interesting to see how the launch goes.
- codeulike 10y agoAlso: The Bolt is rumoured to have a 60kwh pack, I'd be interested to know how GM are building those at that price point.
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoMaybe by leasing them, and recycling? Something creative anyway.
- JoelBennett 10y agoA special deal with LG, because they are the one making the packs? I suspect LG gave them a discount because they contracted LG to take care of a bunch of other stuff in the car. A bit like a lost-leader sale. You lose a bit on one thing, but you gain it back on something else.
- WalterSear 10y agoLike, perhaps, their rideshare adventure.
- PeterisP 10y agoAs the article states, due to current implementation of emission laws it may make economic sense to cross-subsidize Bolts and sell them below cost because it then allows them to sell more high-priced high-emission cars.
- 10y ago
- 6DM 10y agoIf I'm going to buy an electric car, I don't want to buy a hatchback or something weird looking. Compare this: http://blogs-images.forbes.com/brookecrothers/files/2016/01/chevy-bolt-front-small.jpg http://blogs-images.forbes.com/brookecrothers/files/2016/01/... to this: https://www.tesla.com/sites/default/files/images/model-3/gallery/gallery-1.jpg?20160401 https://www.tesla.com/sites/default/files/images/model-3/gal... In my opinion that's why Tesla has big fans. It's not because people are rallying around the "little guy", it's because we want a car that looks nice and actually has technology from this decade in it. Edit: I don't mean to knock on the hatchback in particular. I can't articulate it, but this car just communicates the typical EV look. As opposed to something more serious imo.
- ISL 10y agoApples ought to be compared with apples: http://blogs-images.forbes.com/brookecrothers/files/2016/01/chevy-bolt-front-small.jpg http://blogs-images.forbes.com/brookecrothers/files/2016/01/...
- joeblau 10y agoThat car looks terrible also. I'm biased because I ordered a Model 3, but the Chevy Bolt looks like it was purposely made ugly to steer people towards combustion engine vehicles. They would have done better to make the Chevy Malibu body electric or hybrid.
- ptaipale 10y agoMalibu (Opel Insignia) is a significantly larger car (it's about 4.8 m long, Bolt is 4.2 m, and Malibu/Insignia has the same curb weight of about 1600 kg even though it is a gasoline engine version that has no battery (which in Bolt weighs 440 kg). Sure, Malibu/Insignia looks different but it also takes more space.
- rch 10y agoThe pressure has been reduced somewhat since the bailouts, but the car industry does enforce a perceptible hierarchy to keep lower-end models from poaching sales from high-margin vehicles/brands. It's frustrating to see the practice extended to EV vs. combustion though.
- 0xCMP 10y agoI'm really rooting for Tesla here. "Tech start-ups", like Tesla, are disrupting lots of companies that have been doing seemingly nothing for consumers because they haven't needed to or, when they did, things it were half-assed. Tesla is much an example of how Tech People can make things better. What makes me worried is they're not taking the high road. They're pumping out cars and not following the smart approaches. They're making mistakes that have already been made (thats not innovation or iterating fast...). They may screw up the narrative. I'd still rather use my ok Honda Civic while I wait for a Model 3 in the future than get the Bolt.
- cowsandmilk 10y agoTesla is a "tech startup" that cannot even include support for Android Auto or CarPlay.
- 0xCMP 10y agoYea I also have my issues with Tesla. I'm rooting for them, but I'm hoping they fix the obvious problems they have too.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- pmarreck 10y agoWithout supercharging infrastructure, this vehicle will be bound to relatively short distances and then a long charge time. I'm glad there's a bit of competition, though.
- nicwest 10y agoIs there any reason GM can't just make the bolt compatible with Tesla's super chargers? Seems like a win for both parties.
- codeulike 10y agoThey would lose so much face. And they would have to pay Tesla, which they dont want to do. Even assuming that Tesla would do a deal with them, which they may not.
- nbarbettini 10y agoTesla have stated that they are open to other manufacturers using the Superchargers, so I think they'd at least entertain it. Who knows what the price negotiations would be like, though.
- pmarreck 10y agoMusk doesn't seem like the type to shy away from the unknown, so commence the price negotiations!
- codeulike 10y agoI think there's going to be an SAE combo option for the Bolt, which will mean about 90 miles range recharged in 30mins. Not as good as the Tesla supercharger, but not terrible. edit: coverage is good in europe but not so good in the US from what people are saying elsewhere in this post
- pmarreck 10y ago
- RankingMember 10y agoThis article insinuates GM is beating Tesla to the punch on the "everyman" electric car as though it's some big surprise that an auto manufacturing giant is able to produce something at scale much quicker than a scrappy upstart. The bigger story is that it took this scrappy upstart and its "[c]ocky billionaire" CEO for this lumbering behemoth to inch their rudder 1 degree away from cranking out SUVs.
- jhugg 10y agoWhat scale? Tesla has hundreds of thousands of pre-orders. How many of these will GM sell? It’s not like there’s a wait-list for Volts.
- brohoolio 10y agoThe Ford Escape sells 600,000 units a year in America. That's one SUV from one manufacturer. That's more than the entire minivan segment. If GM can leverage one of their platforms for most of the Bolt it can dramatically lower the cost. What they do with the Bolt can bleed back over to the rest of the platform.
- objclxt 10y ago> as though it's some big surprise that an auto manufacturing giant is able to produce something at scale much quicker than a scrappy upstart I'm not sure I'd call Tesla a "scrappy upstart". They're a publicly traded company with a market cap of $28B, versus GM's $47B. They employ 14,000 people. That's a lot less than GM, but it's also not an insignificant amount. At what point does one stop being a scrappy upstart, and start being a mature company?
- codeulike 10y agoTesla is truely both an upstart and a startup. They are barely 10 years old and its only in the last 3 years that they've produced more than 10,000 cars a year. Their huge market cap reflects their huge plans, not their current state.
- reacharavindh 10y agoIsn't GM the same company that knew about a faulty(possible fatal implications) ignition system and let it be because it wasn't cost effective to fix it publicly? I grew wary of GM the moment I read that news and watched Jon Stewart butcher them on Daily Show. I'd buy a Tesla definitely for their effort to improve safety more than the "coolness/tech" factor. If only I had so much money. ... flies away from HN to do the daily job ...
- Aqueous 10y agoAuthor seems a bit biased against Tesla, and pro-GM. First off, no mention of the fact that Elon Musk has said that he wants competitors for Tesla. He wants the entire market for electric cars to expand (more potential customers for them, right?), and they have said that they can't do that all by themselves. This is why he has open-sourced Tesla's patents [1]. Second, the author says Tesla is reaching the limits of its potential. His evidence is that they are unlikely to meet Elon Musk's lofty production goals. If Musk gets to half of his production goals, that will be a huge success. This is how he constantly drives his company forward - by making huge promises that he knows Tesla will not meet, but will still be greeted as a giant leap forward. It's the market's short-termism that has led to this epidemic of 'If you don't meet our arbitrarily-set profit goals designed to enrich us at the expense of almost every long-term goal, you are dead to us.' Musk is playing the long game, not Wall Street's game. [1] https://www.tesla.com/blog/all-our-patent-are-belong-you https://www.tesla.com/blog/all-our-patent-are-belong-you
- csours 10y agoBob Lutz (GM Vice Chairman Global Product Development - Retired) credits Tesla with the existence of the Volt Plugin Hybrid. I don't know if he's made the same comments about the Bolt EV, but I think he would if asked. Personally, I think competition is great. Now that the Bolt EV is entering the market and the EPA range has been announced, you can be dang sure the Tesla Model 3 will beat it. Disclaimer, I work for GM, but not on this program. Any opinions are solely my own.
- dogma1138 10y agoI haven't seen anything biased against Tesla, GM did pull out a "wonder" a 30,000$ car with 200+ miles range (reportedly longer than the Model 3) which is fully electric. The overall sentiment of the article isn't different than other coverage of the Bolt like from Wired for example: https://www.wired.com/2016/01/gm-electric-car-chevy-bolt-mary-barra/ https://www.wired.com/2016/01/gm-electric-car-chevy-bolt-mar... https://www.wired.com/2016/09/chevrolet-bolt-range-epa-rating/ https://www.wired.com/2016/09/chevrolet-bolt-range-epa-ratin... Effectively GM "beat" Tesla to the punch, while the Model 3 might have some additional features and luxuries over the Bolt they also won't be available for the base 30,000$ model. Without Tesla neither the Bolt nor it's predecessor the Volt would've existed but it doesn't diminish the accomplishment that GM has pulled off. Also while it's very nice that Musk has published the Patents it's not exactly "open-sourcing" them, they were released for "in good faith use" which is actually a pretty clever strategy that can be used against competition if the need arises, don't get me wrong this is still a huge deal but this isn't a pure altruistic move on Tesla's part either.
- S_A_P 10y agoIm a fan of what Tesla is doing from a distance. I cant afford any Tesla that fits my needs at the moment. Im not 100% sold on their viability long term, but glad that they are in business if at least to spur the incumbents into innovation. That said, the Chevy Bolt is not Teslas dream car. That car is ugly, awkward and poorly conceived. It may check out on the spec sheet but there is no passion or personality in that car. Tesla is at least trying to build cars that are desirable as well as efficient, and whether or not they hit the mark, you can see that they are trying to do that. I understand there is a demographic out there that doesn't care what their car looks like, and maybe that is what they were shooting for when they designed the bolt, but that is not a car I would ever drive. The Model 3 looks upmarket enough to satisfy aesthetics as well as practicality. The Bolt looks like what it is, a frankenstein model that had its ICE powertrain swapped with an electric one. Doing that required design compromises that just don't look good. This criticism carries over to BMW with their i series as well. The i3 is ugly and poor performing, and the i8 is impractical and expensive. Until GM/BMW/VW/FCA/Ford/ETC start with a real electric platform designed for both efficiency and driving dynamics they will never succeed. Part of me thinks they realize that electrification will largely lead to commoditization and remove a big chunk of the profits that are derived from ICE differentiation, and they don't want that.
- Nursie 10y agoIt was said in another post but it bears repeating - you might find that ugly, to my eyes it is indistinguishable from a good 50% of the cars on the road in the country I live in - the UK. I personally am not satisfied with an average hatchback, it seems most people are though. I agree with you about the BMW i3. The i8 is pretty though...
- serge2k 10y ago> The i8 is pretty though... It is, and it's not a car you buy for practicality.
- sremani 10y agoThis being the top post is bad news at many levels. As a Volt owner, I am more than satisfied by that car, and passionately recommend it to people. The BoltEV is perhaps unsexy, but its dimensions are practical and the reviews are overall good. Its the only long distance practical EV for at least couple of years for all markets in US, until Model 3 and Leaf Gen 2 come out. edit: here is the review of the car, http://www.caranddriver.com/reviews/2017-chevrolet-bolt-ev-first-drive-review http://www.caranddriver.com/reviews/2017-chevrolet-bolt-ev-f...
- jlebrech 10y agoyou mean this car? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v5dpQaakHwI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v5dpQaakHwI
- gregwtmtno 10y agoThe author docks Tesla for being unable to meet demand for its Model 3 and notes that GM will easily meet demand for its Bolt. No mention of what that demand is likely to be. I don't have pre-order stats, but if Bolt sales are anything like Volt sales, which recently crossed 100,000 after years on the market, meeting demand shouldn't be that challenging. http://media.chevrolet.com/media/us/en/chevrolet/home.detail.html/content/Pages/news/us/en/2016/aug/080116-volt.html http://media.chevrolet.com/media/us/en/chevrolet/home.detail...
- WorldMaker 10y agoThere are no preorder stats for the Bolt because GM doesn't do preorders. Bolt sales start this year when they arrive in dealerships. It's quite possible that Bolt sales (actual cars in actual dealerships) can (will?) eat into Tesla Model 3 preorders, especially because they may be "car keys in hand" well before the Model 3 wait list catches up to many potential buyers. Also, comparing Volt sales to Bolt sales is a bit like comparing Model S sales to Model 3 sales; different target markets and different price points entirely. At this point I don't think anyone has a good idea (except for projections that may or may not be accurate) what the Bolt demand will be until the Bolts start showing up in dealerships soon.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- rch 10y agoIt's really not surprising that established manufacturers can create worthwhile products if they choose to, it is just that they typically won't bother to try.
- nbarbettini 10y agoExactly. What this article misses is that part of Tesla's stated goal is to force the hands of established manufacturers into doing precisely this. As much as the author wants to paint this as a win for GM and an upset for Tesla, the Bolt is a win for both.
- NDizzle 10y agoBy the time the Tesla 3 is generally available these Bolts will be available, used, with unsexy GM depreciation. I look forward to picking one up then. If you're curious what unsexy GM depreciation is, check out used Volt prices. Here's what I found in 20 seconds of searching: https://www.cars.com/vehicledetail/detail/675207037/overview/ https://www.cars.com/vehicledetail/detail/675207037/overview...
- nedsma 10y agoGM Chevy Bolt or Opel/Vauxhall Ampera-e should help with the electric car adoption in the US and Europe which I look forward to. While TM3 may be worth waiting, Tesla is going to be slow meeting the domestic demand, not to start going internationally. Affordable, high mileage electric cars is what we need to speed up the transition from ICE powered cars to electric ones. Apart from Nissan Leaf, BMW i3 or Volkswagen e-Golf are not really helping much this segment (source: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XQelhFzK3Po https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XQelhFzK3Po, translated "The electric car fairy tale"), so it's awesome to see an affordable, high mileage electric car.
- deepthought42 10y agoThe level of bias in this article makes the "journalist" look like a complete idiot. Yes, Tesla is building the largest battery factory in the world, alongside the largest battery manufacturers in the world for uses far beyond it's electric cars. I'm also a bit curious if this guy is an idiot or just misinformed, because those "scrappy startups" he touts GM as just crushing are actually the reason GM is still competing. Maybe it's not well known but everything from Electric car technology to self driving car technology inside GM are often being developed by multiple scrappy startups that are getting funding from GM. The author might as well have made a full disclosure statement of "GM paid me to write an amazing review of its new car as well as to bash Tesla, so I figured I'd do it all in one piece."
- bas 10y agoFarhad Manjoo is a well-respected and seasoned technology journalist.
- samcheng 10y agoThe New York Times has a longstanding anti-Tesla bias. http://www.nytimes.com/2013/02/10/automobiles/stalled-on-the-ev-highway.html http://www.nytimes.com/2013/02/10/automobiles/stalled-on-the... http://www.nytimes.com/2016/06/11/business/tesla-motors-model-s-suspension.html http://www.nytimes.com/2016/06/11/business/tesla-motors-mode... http://www.nytimes.com/2016/07/02/business/a-fatality-forces-tesla-to-confront-its-limits.html http://www.nytimes.com/2016/07/02/business/a-fatality-forces... Personally, I think we need as many Electric Vehicles as possible, so my kids' kids will be able to swim in the coral reefs and climb glaciated peaks. I don't care much for the hit pieces - I want BOTH Tesla AND GM to succeed.
- EdgarVerona 10y agoI don't see how this is getting "his wish, in the worst way". Wasn't one of their stated goals "to accelerate the advent of sustainable transport?" (https://www.tesla.com/blog/all-our-patent-are-belong-you https://www.tesla.com/blog/all-our-patent-are-belong-you) It sounds like that goal is finally starting to become successful. We should all be grateful at the economic pressure Tesla applied to change the market. I hope that our next milestone is to see more EV sold than Combustion vehicles.
- samch 10y agoI'd argue that these comparisons, while obvious to make, are missing an absolutely critical piece of Tesla's long-term plan: autonomous driving capability. This article and others are merely drawing comparisons based on price and range. GM has fielded electric cars off and on for 20 years now (going back to the EV1). The field is maturing quickly, but the Bolt and other cars like it are really just electric versions of existing ICE platforms. In the case of the Bolt, it's the same platform as the Buick Encore and Chevy Spark in the US. There are very few platform-specific updates that serve to differentiate the Bolt from its siblings. That's not a criticism in and of itself, but it serves as an illustration of how GM's approach differs dramatically from Tesla's. What Tesla is doing by creating entirely new platforms is ensuring that they are engineered not just to be electric vehicles but - more importantly - to be autonomous vehicles. This article is overlooking just how important that functionality will be in Tesla's vision for the Model 3 (and all of their other future offering). Musk has made no secret of this. So, no, the Bolt is not Musk's White Whale.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- _ph_ 10y agoI think it is great that the Bolt exists. We need as many as possible electric car offerings. And I do think that Elon Musk also welcomes more electric cars from other manufacturers. The article is a bit negative about Tesla though. It is obvious that a car manufacturing giant like GM could bring a car quicker to production than a small company like Tesla. It also seems, that GM is just responsible for the bodywork and suspension, anything electric seems to be of LG make. There are also rumors, that the production is limited to 20-50k cars per year. So much less than Tesla is already building, and an order of magnitude less than planned for the Model 3.
- Animats 10y agoQuit grumbling about the Bolt's exterior form factor. GM is starting with something mainstream. As the article mentions, the Bolt is being built on the same Gamma platform line as gas cars. There are about a dozen cars built on the Gamma platform, and they're selling well. GM can put different sheet metal on top of electric drive if they see a market. The real achievement is range. GM finally got good range at a low price point. That's what's needed to make electric cars go mainstream. (YC-type business opportunity: get public charging points to report their status (available, in-use, broken) and transmit that to cars and phones. There are maps of charge points, but not enough status info.) Tesla no longer deserves a market cap half that of GM.
- Corrado 10y agoI think the automakers, and the business reports, are missing the point of the Tesla (again). They think it's about simply making a car that has a better {thing} than Tesla, whether that is range or the size of the touchscreen or even the number of cars they can pump out. It's not. There is a reason that Tesla had 400,000 pre orders for the Model 3 and it's not because it has a cool key. Tesla is bringing all of the pieces together in a way that no current automobile manufacturer will. Could an existing car company (Toyota, Chevy, Porsche, etc.) beat the Tesla at the EV game? Maybe. But I think its far more likely that we are witnessing a paradigm shift and the existing companies are like the carriage makers in the early 1900's trying to compete with the Model T. How many vehicles to you see on the road built by the Frey Carriage Company?
- whamlastxmas 10y agoSeems to be a pretty obvious piece of advertising. As I recently commented elsewhere, I really want there to be non-Tesla options at this price point, but GM: -Probably won't have anywhere as good of warranty service -Probably has a much less nice interior -Probably has much worse control and media electronics for the driver -Probably isn't nearly as fast -Lacks access to the Tesla superchargers -Doesn't have advanced features like Autopilot -Won't receive anywhere near the same level of ongoing software support and updates For only potentially $5k less, I'll pass. GM has in no way made a competitive alternative to the new Tesla.
- mrfusion 10y agoDon't forget safety!
- serge2k 10y agoWithout reading the article, I'm gonna go with "100+ years of experience designing and building cars".