3 ms·
This arguments fails to see Snowden in context. Edward Snowden went to the press with revelations because he was aware of the experience of previous whistleblo
by nabla9 10y ago
This arguments fails to see Snowden in context.
Edward Snowden went to the press with revelations because he was aware of the experience of previous whistleblowers.
Drake, Binney, Wiebe, Loomis, Roark followed the official channels and reported their concerns within the system. There was intense retaliation against them. They were arreested, fired and charged with crimes that could put them into jail for the rest of their lives.
It did not stop there. John Crane who worked as assistant inspector general of the DoD was supervising the whistleblower unit as well as handling all whistleblower allegations. He faced retaliation after taking them seriously.
Before Snowden: The Whistleblowers Who Tried To Lift The Veil
http://www.npr.org/2014/07/22/333741495/before-snowden-the-whistleblowers-who-tried-to-lift-the-veil http://www.npr.org/2014/07/22/333741495/before-snowden-the-w...
How the Pentagon punished NSA whistleblowers
https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2016/may/22/how-pentagon-punished-nsa-whistleblowers https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2016/may/22/how-pentagon...
- tptacek 10y agoNone of those people were put in jail for the rest of their lives. Binney, Wiebe, Loomis, and Roark were never arrested, let alone charged, let alone "with crimes that could put them into jail for the rest of their lives". Drake was charged --- he was believed to be the source for the NYT's blockbuster story on NSA surveillance --- but those charges were dropped.
- nabla9 10y ago>None of those people were put in jail for the rest of their lives. Prosecutors tried hard to build a case to put them into into prison. They received punitive treatment and bullying, their houses were raided. They raided Drake's house after he anonymously contacted DoD IG. Someone leaked this confidential information to DoJ. He faced 35 years of imprisonment. The judge in the case had some harsh words against government. https://fas.org/sgp/jud/drake/071511-transcript.pdf https://fas.org/sgp/jud/drake/071511-transcript.pdf
- tptacek 10y agoThat's not what you said. We could further litigate your revised summary of what happens to NSA whistleblowers, and I'd be happy to do so, but first I'd like to know that we're not just playing Calvinball.
- nabla9 10y agoI think you were right and I was wrong using the term arrest.
- tptacek 10y agoThanks! So I think my objection to this narrative is clearer if we put it back into context. What we're really debating is whether someone like Snowden had the means to appropriately handle the issues he discovered through official channels. The narrative on places like HN is that by raising issues and escalating them, perhaps beyond NSA, and NSA's IG, all the way to Senate Intelligence, someone like Snowden would face retaliation. Here, I think, I have two points to raise: * First, if by retaliation we mean "termination", it's hard to fit that into the actual Snowden story. Snowden took the Booz job in the first place in order to gain access to this information and route it to the people he thought needed it. His only reason to be there was to do the thing we're saying he'd get fired for. That's not a real deterrent. * Second, if we look at actual prosecutions --- or even FBI investigations, like what happened to Binney and Roark --- they're tied up with news leaks. It's hard, I think, to find a case of an NSA whistleblower who faced law enforcement retaliation for escalating concerns to the NSA IG or Senate committees. Where you see the DOJ go ape-shit is when NSA secrets wind up on the front page of the New York Times. Indeed, that's what happened to Roark and Binney and Loomis! They got caught up in an investigation into an NYT story that was launched at the (direct!) behest of George Bush.
- nickpsecurity 10y ago"they're tied up with news leaks. It's hard, I think, to find a case of an NSA whistleblower who faced law enforcement retaliation for escalating concerns to the NSA IG or Senate committees." I agree with this. The natural follow-up is, "Are there any examples of those doing internal whistleblowing on programs endorsed as much as these by Executive and Congressional groups getting results that Snowden leaks have gotten?" It usually business as usual with occasional fine or scathing report that I've seen. I doubt a leak-less version of Snowden would get new bills in, jurisdictions changed for major companies, all kinds of privacy startups, etc. I'd be interested in example you have where similar things came from internal links. You didn't claim you did but I'm asking just in case.