2 ms·
Bit of a hysterical rant ✓ Written in the over-defensive Apple-fanboi style ✓ Tells me nothing I didn't know ✓ There's nothing wrong with checklists, it's ju
by ZeroGravitas 17y ago
Bit of a hysterical rant ✓
Written in the over-defensive Apple-fanboi style ✓
Tells me nothing I didn't know ✓
There's nothing wrong with checklists, it's just information, unless you have some weird compulsion to claim that the one with the most, or the fewest, is in some way superior. That's the dysfunction.
This does happen in committee-driven enterprise software design and purchasing and is I think a genuine problem. Gadget blogs summarising useful information about products (does it have a CD drive yes/no) isn't a problem unless you've taken it as some kind of direct insult to your lifestyle choices because you bought the one that did, or didn't, have that feature.
Removing the checklists is not going to magically stop geeks fighting over pointless tech choices, they are just a tool that is too often used as a weapon.
- stcredzero 17y agoThe antidote: the wholism / reductionism section of Goedel Escher Bach.
- joshu 17y agoI agree. However, I do think that when there are long lists of comparable features between very comparable systems (intravendor rather than intervendor, I guess) I do wish they would do something to typographically offset the things that are different. Compare variations of Thinkpads and they are often VERY similar. What are just the important differences? Etc.