5 ms·
It does not equate anything. It describes the correlation and steps to not waste huge talents. In fact it does say they do not know exactly why some highly inte
by AstralStorm 10y ago
It does not equate anything. It describes the correlation and steps to not waste huge talents. In fact it does say they do not know exactly why some highly intelligent people do not achieve much.
It is surprisingly easy to waste talent. For example, get a gifted person through standard school and they will likely never extend enough to achieve full potential, often by growing lazy and coasting. Or push them into a wrong field, they will do good but not exceptional.
See, if your niece was challenged enough, she would probably place more value on achievement and thus achieve more. It is a positive feedback loop. The correct approach is to give them as much challenge as they can take. Evaluating where this point is takes some major interpersonal skills and experience.
Emotional support is a necessary ingredient as well so that failures do not break them and they remain human.
- nils-m-holm 10y ago> See, if your niece was challenged enough, she would probably place more value on achievement You say that as if it would be a good thing. In my view, life is about happiness, not about achievement. If those two correlate, fine. If they don't, also fine.
- AstralStorm 10y agoThe values of children do not come from nowhere. They are not raised in a vacuum. While it is purview of philosophy, it seems unethical to let your talents be wasted; you could be improving life of others instead. Plus kids typically like to do what they are talented to do.
- panic 10y agoIMO the whole idea of "potential" that can be "wasted" is toxic. As soon as you feel yourself falling behind -- which you always will -- that idea that you've wasted your potential shows up to make you feel bad. This inevitably drives people toward easier kinds of achievement like awards, promotions, and degrees. But a lot of real progress happens outside systems like this! I think it's valuable to have smart people working on stuff for its own sake, not chasing any kind of achievement.
- cpkpad 10y agoIt depends on where the pressure is places. If the pressure is placed on kids, sure. If it's placed on schools, that's not toxic. The school system in most of the US works under an attitude that the smart kids will do okay, and don't need anything extra. Even gifted and talented programs are fading fast. The truth is those school system are toxic, abusive torture to someone smart. There were plenty of smart kids I knew -- some smarter than me -- who got horrible grades going through one of these school. Many of them did not, in any real sense, succeed. Imagine being placed in a room, today, and forced to listen to lectures on what you already know, and be given menial make-work tasks, like adding big numbers and copying letters, and doing that for hours each day. Some people are resilient enough to survive that. Others get pretty broken by it.
- DanBC 10y ago> Even gifted and talented programs are fading fast. What's the evidence that G&T programmes achieve better academic or life outcomes?
- luxpir 10y agoIsn't that the premise of the study? Sidenote: I read the SciAm article last week, not this one yet.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- nitrogen 10y agoEven if life outcomes are the same, if G&T programs make those kids happier while in school, the programs are worth keeping.
- tbihl 10y agoWhere's your study proving the opposite? Or is your proposal to do absolutely nothing without a study first telling you to? G&T programs try to utilize the diversity of students, rather than just ignoring it or trying to will it away. In a world where things actually have to function prior to the conducting of infinite studies, that makes a lot of intuitive sense.
- scandox 10y ago> they do not know exactly why some highly intelligent people do not achieve much My guess: an intelligent reaction to life is to value things that can't be measured
- AstralStorm 10y agoAchievement cannot really be measured either. Doctorates and patents are used as proxies. You could also add scientific papers, renowned works of art, successful businesses, charities etc. Anything that advances humanity.
- agumonkey 10y agoThere's a socio-affective component to 'achieving'. The pupils have to care about the people and about what society think is an achievement. And for this I believe they have to care about said pupils identity (which they might not understand for lack of overlapping common views)