4 ms·
Can a gun type weapon ever be made one point safe? You'd have to somehow make sure that the explosives could never accidentally drive the two pieces together, w
by mikeash 10y ago
Can a gun type weapon ever be made one point safe? You'd have to somehow make sure that the explosives could never accidentally drive the two pieces together, which seems impossible. Doing it for an implosion weapon is, relatively speaking, much more straightforward: implosion is inherently finicky anyway, so you design it to fail unless multiple detonations happen at precise times.
- Animats 10y agoThe US hasn't had a gun-type nuclear weapon since 1963. The Hiroshima weapon was gun-type, and there was a serious risk of accidental detonation. Later gun-type bombs were used in the "atomic cannon" artillery shells. These apparently came in two parts intended to be assembled just before use. Other countries, who knows? The first Soviet atomic bomb was an implosion device.
- sandworm101 10y agoYes, mechanically. You put something in the barrel that would shatter the 'bullet' should the explosives go off. Detonation then occurs only if the safety is moved prior to explosion. Then, as another measure, you can rig that mechanical safety mechanism to snap back in place in cases of external fire (ie some part is designed to melt and swing it back in place).
- mikeash 10y agoSounds like a good system! Does it really eliminate the possibility of any detonation, though? Seems like you could still potentially get enough stuff together to exceed critical mass. The explosion would probably be smaller than nominal, but more than the 4lbs TNT equivalent that the US military specifies as its criteria for one-point safety. But perhaps I overestimate the chances of this happening. I'm far from an expert here.