4 ms·
I don't understand the downvotes, the OP is correct, the explosion could have resulted in a environmental disaster but in effect it would've been a "dirty bomb"
by dogma1138 10y ago
I don't understand the downvotes, the OP is correct, the explosion could have resulted in a environmental disaster but in effect it would've been a "dirty bomb".
In the book they went over the trigger mechanism and overall there was no way for the 1st stage fission warhead to detonate not to mention for the 2nd stage fusion reaction to kick off.
A nuclear warhead is pretty darn hard to detonate, the detonation sequence is extremely precise and the smallest deviation would result in a dud and in rare cases an extremely low yield fizzle.
You can do whatever you want to a nuke, blow it up, set it ablaze, put it in a microwave, hit it, drop it even from orbit, it will not go off, not even because there are failsafes but because there is virtually no way for the nuke to "fail" in a way that would be even remotely close to a detonation sequence, an accidental detonation especially through brute force that would physically damage the warhead is about as likely as a tornado passing through a junkyard leaving assembled 747's in it's wake.
- sandworm101 10y ago>> an accidental detonation especially through brute force that would physically damage the warhead is about as likely as a tornado ... Even if you do damage the warhead, even if you get the high explosives of the warhead to detonate, that detonation will not be symmetrical. If it isn't perfect, the shell doesn't collapse evenly --> no critical mass --> no nuclear fission --> no nuclear fusion == a week dirty bomb. No mushroom cloud. The bomb's brain has to be involved. It has to want to go off.
- Kadin 10y agoI am in complete agreement, with the exception of this statement: > there is virtually no way for the nuke to "fail" in a way that would be even remotely close to a detonation sequence That is not true, at least not universally. Nuclear bombs are, by definition, designed to go off, and as a result there is a category of failure modes that could lead to inadvertent detonation. Basically, a failure that produces the same command that would cause the normal detonation sequence to begin, could cause an unintended detonation. The Mk. 39 bomb involved in the 1961 North Carolina B-52 crash [0] reportedly came close to detonating in this manner. Additionally, there are weapons designs that are not "one point safe", such that a failure which causes ignition of the high explosive could lead to a nuclear detonation. Weapons considered "one point safe" require multiple, carefully timed or simultaneous ignitions of the high explosive. The last non-one-point-safe weapons in the US arsenal were built in the 50s but not disassembled until recently; the W56 was reportedly not one point safe [1], or at least not provably so to the safety margins now recognized as reasonable. I don't know of any information in the unclassified literature about whether Soviet weapons are universally one-point-safe or not. It would not surprise me if there are a variety of weapon designs still floating around in the world that aren't one-point-safe. Single compression "gun type" bombs, like the Fat Man design, would require additional engineering to make one-point-safe beyond what is minimally required to get them to detonate, which makes me suspect that some marginal nuclear powers probably don't bother. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1961_Goldsboro_B-52_crash https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1961_Goldsboro_B-52_crash [1]: https://web.archive.org/web/20070110205223/http://www.pogo.org/p/homeland/hl-061201-bodman.html https://web.archive.org/web/20070110205223/http://www.pogo.o...
- mikeash 10y agoCan a gun type weapon ever be made one point safe? You'd have to somehow make sure that the explosives could never accidentally drive the two pieces together, which seems impossible. Doing it for an implosion weapon is, relatively speaking, much more straightforward: implosion is inherently finicky anyway, so you design it to fail unless multiple detonations happen at precise times.
- Animats 10y agoThe US hasn't had a gun-type nuclear weapon since 1963. The Hiroshima weapon was gun-type, and there was a serious risk of accidental detonation. Later gun-type bombs were used in the "atomic cannon" artillery shells. These apparently came in two parts intended to be assembled just before use. Other countries, who knows? The first Soviet atomic bomb was an implosion device.
- sandworm101 10y agoYes, mechanically. You put something in the barrel that would shatter the 'bullet' should the explosives go off. Detonation then occurs only if the safety is moved prior to explosion. Then, as another measure, you can rig that mechanical safety mechanism to snap back in place in cases of external fire (ie some part is designed to melt and swing it back in place).
- mikeash 10y agoSounds like a good system! Does it really eliminate the possibility of any detonation, though? Seems like you could still potentially get enough stuff together to exceed critical mass. The explosion would probably be smaller than nominal, but more than the 4lbs TNT equivalent that the US military specifies as its criteria for one-point safety. But perhaps I overestimate the chances of this happening. I'm far from an expert here.
- dfsegoat 10y agoHaving read the following, I am now convinced that Goldsboro was NOT anywhere close to a nuclear detonation. Author below has documents FOIA'd from NNSA and DOE to back his claims in a well written / detailed document: TLDR: These weapons require auxiliary aircraft power and aircrew intent to initiate the mechanisms and sequence (19 steps) required to even arm the bomb so that it can produce a nuclear detonation. http://nuclearweaponsaccidents.blogspot.com/2013/03/goldsboro-19-steps-away-from-detonation.html http://nuclearweaponsaccidents.blogspot.com/2013/03/goldsbor... "Bomb 2, the object of the Goldsboro controversy, was not "one step" away from detonation (nor was Bomb 1). The Mark 39 Mod 2 had two additional safety switches, the Trajectory Arm Switch and Rotary Safing Switch."
- dfsegoat 10y agoYou refer to the spreading of fissile material. The original post refers to an "explosion 600 times more powerful than Hiroshima" -- which would obviously refer to a Nuclear detonation. So yeah, I have a problem with that based on the literature available to the public regarding the safety of these weapons.