2 ms·
A couple of notes, this is from 2014 and the results of ocean fertilization are better understood today. The interesting thing for me over the controversy when
by ChuckMcM 10y ago
A couple of notes, this is from 2014 and the results of ocean fertilization are better understood today.
The interesting thing for me over the controversy when this was being done was that it reiterated the concern that nobody feels they know how to direct climate change. As a result the only action they can endorse is "affecting it less" by reducing our own carbon emissions. This guy is taking it from the other side saying, "Let's start driving the model and get it to a point we like."
- rhino369 10y agoAnother interesting issue is that not all nations aren't going to agree on a point "we like." Island nations might want to fight for every .1 degree C. Russia and Canada might say fuck it, warming helps us. W Europe who is fairly shielded again major change by ocean currents might say that nobody should geo-engineer because it's not worth the risks (because their risk is lower than others).
- civilian 10y agoI agree with your analysis, except for some of Western Europe. In North-Western europe, Britain and Scandanavia greatly benefit from the Atlantic jet stream being fairly consistently aimed a little farther north; it gives them a warmer climate. We think that global warming has been destabilizing jet streams, and it's making weather have great variation in North America and Northern Europe. http://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-26023166 http://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-26023166
- ArkyBeagle 10y agoThe problem is that now AGW is on a moral footing, with oil companies in the role tobacco companies were in 20ish to 30ish years ago. That's an artifact of the propagandistic nature of the actors in the issue - on both sides. I believe they do that because it better meets their goals. They have a need to win. And it's not an imagined need - the issue has slipped into an adversarial shape. The article exposes this well - people are well-bifurcated around two poles - 1) it's the end of the world or 2) it's no big deal. Maybe that is right, but I rather expect there's something else in play ( because the timescales are fairly long and we're bounded by out ability to learn ) , and that the more productive approach will be more moderate and possibly more experimental. Taking the position of "no, everyone must modify their behavior" does not seem the most reasonable of all possible positions. But I am just interested in it as a problem to be solved, not as a means of winning something. IMO, all the furor seems more likely to produce heat than light. It's slightly crank-ey but I still enjoyed Chrichton's "State of Fear" immensely.