3 ms·
College is just all sorts of disgusting in the US right now. I support relief, but I'm sure that we're going to have to see a massive crash in the system befor
by krinchan 10y ago
College is just all sorts of disgusting in the US right now. I support relief, but I'm sure that we're going to have to see a massive crash in the system before anything happens.
I managed to go to a small public university after the tuition hike but before the Great Fees Gouging. I'd probably have escaped with $5,000 less in debt if I had started with my state's (Georgia's Hope) merit based scholarship instead of having to build up 10 semester hours totally on Federal UnSubsidized Loans the first year.
At that point, used Ebay books could run you well past $1,000 a semester. Hope only gave you a $150 for books. Hope also did not cover fees. Those started at about $800 every semester when I enrolled. My 4th year, they had hit well past $2,500 per semester. Included in that was $150 to build a new student recreation center that I would never use since it wasn't even being built yet.
The amount of hustle I had to do just to escape that school with minimal debt was insane. My overloaded schedule (because semester hours past 12 didn't increase your tuition or fees) meant I needed a job that let me do study or homework while working. So typical service jobs off-campus were out of the question. My year basically was applying for summer retail jobs, lying my face off during the interview that I was going to stay on past the summer, and then of course quitting. I'm basically black-listed from several retailers for quitting for this reason. Christmas was always easier because those jobs are naturally seasonal.
During school, I'd tutor various core classes under the table. At my university, this was considered quasi-against-the-rules. Tutors were supposed to go through the Student Support Center. They'd pay you hourly minimum wage and set you up with other students for free. Tutors who were students caught not going this route were usually sanctioned by the university and threatened with all sorts of administrative punishments.
Naturally, this was unacceptable to tutors, so we all snuck around advertising by word of mouth and meeting off campus. I mean, when I can easily pull $100 a session as the only person willing to try to cram Plato into your brain, why would I go through the SSC? Calculus was a bit harder because there was more competition, so that usually ran about $60 to start. Once I had kids getting their B's and telling their friends, I was able to pull $100. I ran a group rate for a Fraternity that was a flat $350 a month.
I lived off campus, because rent on a 3 bedroom, 2 bath was $950/month plus utilities. Speaking of hustle, keeping those bedrooms stocked with roommates was it's own drama. Kicking roommates who fell behind was even worse. The lease was in my name, because most places I went to rent a room were on 6 month leases and headed home every summer. I wanted something more permanent since I was staying in town year round.
All said, I managed to escape with just over $30,000 in debt. That's tuition, fees, and about $10,000 a year to supplement all my other income. I hit a job immediately and started burning it down as fast as possible. I landed a better job with nice, $10,000 yearly bonuses and finished murdering it.
This was right as the next big wave of inflation hit higher education. Now? I went back and poked some of my social circle in that town. Getting out without $60,000 in debt is basically impossible. If you live outside of a 10 mile radius of the campus, you are required to live in the dorms your Freshman year. Literally every course uses some sort of book with an online component. To access that component, you have to buy the book new to get a code. The university regularly charges current students fees to raise money for buildings that won't be built for 5 years. They recently charged a parking fee, and then made all lots on campus hourly paid parking. The lot that parking fee is for? It's about a 4 minute walk off campus. Good luck if your class is on the other side of the campus.
Part time students are actually charged the exact same fees, but are not allowed access to several benefits of of the campus. This is disguised as "discounts" for full time students at on campus food vendors, a higher co-pay for health services (physical and mental), and being barred from the free tutors (that no one can use because we won't work for them) Student Resource Center.
The problem isn't just the loans, it's a deep cultural problem in the administration of these universities. University presidents down to the department chairs are held to metrics that lead to perverse incentives. They must milk students of every dollar possible so they feed the enrollment machine. This leads to admitting students that probably shouldn't be admitted. This leads them to dumb down courses to graduate students who have no business having a degree to feed the graduation rate.
TL;DR: The US higher education system is abusive and terrible. Avoid at all costs.
- thearn4 10y agoA good read, and I agree on your points. Like you, I worked my way through undergrad (including a period in the national guard and active army), and escaped with only a few thousand in debt thanks to that. Masters and PhD were free, but that's not too unusual in my area (applied math). I'm teaching one class as a part-time instructor now back at my old university (basically for beer money on top of the day job), and it's blowing my mind how much more flashy the campus is. And naturally, how ridiculously expensive it is after only 10 years. The focus on "student life" facilities strikes me as an odd set of priorities considering how long hiring and pay raise freezes for faculty seem to last. The mandatory online book thing is pretty insidious. We're required to use it by the department, and I can see how there is a kernel of a good idea there. It basically helps you run gigantic course sections while grading all homework for you, but while simultaneously killing the secondary textbook market (which is pretty evil). Worse, they are clearly implemented by the lowest bidder and break every web standard you could imagine. Basically, with increased class sizes and mandatory online content, every core course is slowly turning into a weird online hybrid class. I think this is decreasing the difference between a traditional education and a MOOC bit by bit, which is eventually going to give a lot of universities a bit of an identity and marketing crisis. Pearson, Wiley, Mcgraw-Hill et. al. are the entities that I would most like to see disappear when the college bubble pops. Free open-source community maintained textbooks seem like the obvious way forward to my software developer brain. On the bright side, I do enjoy actual lecturing. It's a lot more fun when you can do it with few or no stakes, since I don't have to rely on it for a living. I'm literally on the exact opposite of the spectrum from a tenured professor, but I weirdly feel like I have to same level of freedom.