4 ms·
Statistics is a very interesting subject, and it is a distinct subject from mathematics proper. Here (in what is becoming a FAQ post for HN) are two favorite re
by tokenadult 17y ago
Statistics is a very interesting subject, and it is a distinct subject from mathematics proper. Here (in what is becoming a FAQ post for HN) are two favorite recommendations for free Web-based resources on what statistics is as a discipline, both of which recommend good textbooks for follow-up study:
"Advice to Mathematics Teachers on Evaluating Introductory Statistics Textbooks" by Robert W. Hayden
http://statland.org/MyPapers/MAAFIXED.PDF http://statland.org/MyPapers/MAAFIXED.PDF
"The Introductory Statistics Course: A Ptolemaic Curriculum?" by George W. Cobb
http://repositories.cdlib.org/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1002&context=uclastat/cts/tise http://repositories.cdlib.org/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=10...
Both are excellent introductions to what statistics is as a discipline and how it is related to, but distinct from, mathematics.
A very good list of statistics textbooks appears here:
http://web.mac.com/mrmathman/MrMathMan/New_Teacher_Resources.html http://web.mac.com/mrmathman/MrMathMan/New_Teacher_Resources...
I have encountered some recent examples of people finding interesting work by being able to step into the intersection of computer science and statistics, with a strong pure math background besides. A lot of statistical researchers need programming help, and a lot of programmers need to be more aware of statistical issues. It's a win-win when a learner learns a lot about math, statistics, and computer science.
- eru 17y agoI like your comment. Let me add a second view-point to your first sentence. > Statistics is a very interesting subject, and it is a distinct subject from mathematics proper. Mathematics proper is more than one subject, already. (Theoretical) computer science and statistics are just two more branches of math. The notion of statistics as being outside math remains me a bit of how thermodynamics was viewed as not proper physics (or prober chemistry) in the 19th century. The study of thermodynamics got a huge boost from the commercial need to understand and build better steam engines. If you look close enough, thermodynamics is actually statistics. (And of course statistics and probability theory is just applied measure and integration theory.)
- bitdiddle 17y agoreminds me of a comment a classmate used to make (we were taking a course together on measure theory, taught in the statistics dept. which was separate from our math dept.); "Inside every hard statistics problem is a trivial analysis problem struggling to get out"
- eru 17y agoOur teaching assistent for probability theory gave us real hard nuts to crack. And he was strict about the rigour of our answer--we often had to ground our proofs in measure theory to get past his radar. And he allowed no handwaiving. The demands were a bit annoying at the time, but I credit him with getting a understanding of probability theory. I wish every course would have been like this.
- dagw 17y agoI kind of agree that statistics should be viewed as slightly different subject from math proper. The math aspect of statistics is not, in itself, the important aspect. The interesting (and in my opinion harder) aspect is the more subjective part of getting a good feel for how to pick from the myriad of statistical tests available to use on your data and to analyse exactly what the results from those tests mean relative to your data. Both of those aspects are core to applying statistics and neither are purely mathematical. Both are also often ignored or marginalized by those who simply see statistics as applied analysis-light.
- yummyfajitas 17y agoActually, picking tests is a purely mathematical topic. The only reason it feels like an art and not math is because people still use frequentist statistics.
- eru 17y agoPicking an optimality criterion for your tests is an art. Then picking optimal tests is pure math. But for anything beyond toy problems picking an optimal test (or optimal parameters for your test), so there comes the black art part in again. What do you pronounce as the alternative to frequentist statistics? May I guess you'd pick Bayesian approaches? Mathematical things like maximum likelihood estimators can be seen as solving a min-max problem atop of Bayesian calculations.
- tokenadult 17y agoThanks for your reply. What I refer to in my grandparent post is the core issue that statistics is about DATA--it is very different from any branch of pure mathematics in that regard, as the first link in my previous post makes clear.
- eru 17y agoOh, that's true. Any math can get pretty applied, even in the supposedly pure fields.