6 ms·
Are you an American? Because plenty of countries strike that balance just fine.
by komali2 10y ago
Are you an American? Because plenty of countries strike that balance just fine.
- ekianjo 10y agoCare to share examples of said countries ?
- snerbles 10y agoWhat other cultures consider just fine, many Americans would consider unacceptably collectivist.
- hackuser 10y ago> What other cultures consider just fine, many Americans would consider unacceptably collectivist. It's odd to focus on that one conflict of 'cultures', of the almost infinite possibilities. As one tiny example, some things other cultures do would also seem unacceptably individualistic and lawless.
- LyndsySimon 10y ago> As one tiny example, some things other cultures do would also seem unacceptably individualistic and lawless. Do you have any examples of this by chance?
- hackuser 10y agoSomalia ... many, many other countries around the world where violence and corruption are far more commonplace.
- pc86 10y agoAnd this isn't even a Republican/Democrat or conservative/liberal thing. I know plenty of what Republicans would call "big government liberals" who would agree that many cultures (largely western European in this case) are too far in that direction.
- jethro_tell 10y agoyeah, when your police are walking around with a stick and a helmet, the balance of power is pretty stable. Americans don't have this option.
- RonanTheGrey 10y agoThat seems a fairly shortsighted estimation of what balances power between police and the people. And FWIW the UK is arming more of its police, since that is clearly the country you are referring to.
- jethro_tell 10y ago>since that is clearly the country you are referring to no not really, there are a lot of countries without armed or heavily armed police forces. >That seems a fairly shortsighted estimation of what balances power between police and the people. So does the NRA's idea that the second amendment will allow people to overthrow the government if they still own guns. But at the end of the day, forcing your police force to think deescalation first has some real benefits. Carrying a fatal weapon and being trained that people within 25-30 feet are in your 'danger zone' has had a very poor outcome.
- hga 10y agoCarrying a fatal weapon and being trained that people within 25-30 feet are in your 'danger zone' has had a very poor outcome. But the "within 25-30 feet" at least has it being the truth in its favor. And none of this has changed, US cops have always been well armed, right? The problem I see is the switch from their being "peace officers" to warrior cops, or at the very minimum, having as their #1 objective making it home safely when their shift ends. Rather negates the "Thin Blue Line" concept of their being there to protect us, also calls into question their outsized benefit packages.
- jethro_tell 10y ago>US cops have always been well armed, right Not really, they carried a revolver or .38 special, might have had a shotgun between the front seats or in the trunk, Using khaki as the only body armor. Now there are police whose primary weapon is an ar-15 and the backup is a semi-auto .40 mm glock. everyone else has an ar-15 in the trunk and a glock in hand plus varying levels of body armor. That's a far cry from having a 6 shot revolver on your hip just in case.
- spdustin 10y agoI'm an American, and I have no problem with responsible gun ownership, nor do I have a problem with electronic records of gun purchasers. I assume FOID cards are in a database already. If I was a law enforcement officer responding to a domestic violence call of a husband battering his wife, I'd want to know if the oldest male in the house purchased an AR-15 derivative and several handguns. EDIT: Many adults also explicitly show their possession of a lethal weapon every day: their car, which is registered in a statewide database. EDIT2: I'd further like to be able to query that database as a civilian, so I know which of my neighbors may own an unusual cache of guns, so that I can have better situational awareness if I'm ever in a dispute with one. EDIT3: To apply a standard of transparency to this data collection, the person whose data about firearm purchases should be able to be notified by some immediate or otherwise automated means that their record was viewed by a LEO or a citizen or another state/federal agency.
- syshum 10y ago>>EDIT2: I am sure violent criminals would love such a database as well, this way when they need an illegal gun they know which homes to rob. No, you have no right to know what I own, be that Gun, Drones, or TV's. You have no right to compel me to publicly list my assets in a database you can search.
- spdustin 10y agoAnother good point. Though there are plenty of public records listing your truly high value assets, it should be noted.
- syshum 10y agoAnd I disagree with all of them. Unlike what you claim to be, I actually am a strong advocate for privacy. The fact that the government has already violated my privacy in many ways, is not a defense or justification for more intrusion upon my privacy. A privacy advocate should never use the justification you have
- wyager 10y ago