5 ms·
>> I always wonder why people think the only 'fair' pricing is pricing based on costs. This is not how free markets work. In a real free market that is how it
by phkahler 10y ago
>> I always wonder why people think the only 'fair' pricing is pricing based on costs. This is not how free markets work.
In a real free market that is how it should turn out. If someone is charging too high above cost, a competitor will likely step in to grab market share by offering the same thing at a lower cost. Companies go to great lengths to make the playing field uneven - "unfair" practices, unfair employment agreements, patents (government granted monopolies), lobbying for barriers to entry, etc...
Lots of people like to talk about "free markets" when they really want no such thing. In a real free market, everything tends toward commodity pricing.
- mannykannot 10y agoYou seem to be suggesting that something unfree is going on here, but in this case there is no evidence for any of the candidate causes that you list. The reality is that the tendency towards commodity pricing is only a tendency, with a highly situation-dependent lag and inertia, even in the absence of more direct restrictions on competition.
- _Codemonkeyism 10y ago"In a real free market, everything tends toward commodity pricing." No. This assumes people only buy products based on price and would choose cheaper alternatives. Doesn't look like this to me, e.g. I'm a consultant, I base my pricing on value not cost (what is my cost anyway?) and people pay on value. Other consultants are not undercutting my prices, for various reasons, e.g. because reducing prices would diminish value perception. I'm not a commodity and never will be (perhaps if AI makes great leaps forward). Same happens with Apple devices which are far from cost based pricing. Assuming others have the same product - I don't want to get into quality, brand recognition etc. just pretend - if they base their products on cost and undercut Apple, they would move out of the luxury/premium segment. One could argue Apple pricing is high because of an 'Apple monopoly on Apple devices', but the same works for any premium segment (Nike and Adidas premium shoes for example). Beside the premium argument there are other examples where "In a real free market, not everything tends towards commodity pricing" - in particular only commodities do. (Interesting side note: Read about value maps, evolution of products towards commodities and strategies from Simon Wardley)
- phkahler 10y ago>> I'm not a commodity and never will be Consultants can be somewhat specialized and can have high demand. Gold is a commodity, but scarcity (or perceived scarcity) makes it higher priced than other metals. If there weren't as many consultants out there, you might be able to charge even more. Android is a cheaper alternative to iPhone, as is Nokia. You are correct that there are other factors at play that make the situation less like a commodity market. Copyrights and patents - both government sanctioned monopolies - are the primary thing enabling Apples high prices. That's not to say I'm against those things, just pointing to the real reason for what's going on.
- _Codemonkeyism 10y agoNo. Brand is the primary thing enabling Apples high prices.
- phkahler 10y ago>> Brand is the primary thing enabling Apples high prices. Trademarks are another government enforced monopoly.
- marcoperaza 10y agoEven in a perfectly free market, there would not be "perfect competition" for every product. This page lists the many reasons https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perfect_competition https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perfect_competition