3 ms·
It's part of something bigger, it's not just cars as status symbol in decline, but cars as a lifestyle enabler. I'm a diver, and to live the dive lifestyle, i.
by gaius 10y ago
It's part of something bigger, it's not just cars as status symbol in decline, but cars as a lifestyle enabler.
I'm a diver, and to live the dive lifestyle, i.e. diving regularly at the weekends not just a week a year on holiday, pretty much requires owning a car. You can load it up the night before, set off at 0-dark-30 to make the tide, use it as a base for the weekend, come back late and unload the next day, etc etc. Do-able with a rental but a lot more hassle given the timings. Including tanks and weights, the Mrs and I would probably take 150-200kg of gear for a weekend trip.
Diving as a sport is in long-term decline since the 1990s, so are mountaineering, basically all outdoor pursuits that require some logistics get to remote places, and possibly even all outdoor activities. People these days prefer to not go outside at all if they can avoid it. This can't be good for public health.
- CalRobert 10y ago"People these days prefer to not go outside at all if they can avoid it. " Counterpoint: I LOVE cycling. Do it all the time. I love riding anywhere I can make it my main mode of transport. When I lived in LA, this was rarely. I rode down Lincoln Blvd. several times and still remember the sound of tires squealing from the pickup behind me. My best guess is that the driver looked up from their phone and saw me with about 0 seconds to spare, given that they came to a stop about an inch from my rear wheel. I like cycling so much, in fact, that I moved to a European city where I can cycle to work, to the shop, to my friends' places, every day. There were other reasons too of course, but that was one of the biggest. Living in a European city where things can be reached by cycle meant that really, I don't even need a car, so I don't own one. Anyway, there are outdoor activities that don't require a car.
- Broken_Hippo 10y agoI'm in Norway. In the city I'm at, a car is definitely a luxury. We have a used one that is only used to transport heavy goods (kitty litter) and go out of town occasionally. I still walk to the grocery store and most places in town or ride the bus. However, we would go out of town before we had a car... because public transportation is really a thing. City to city. Not all-inclusive, but enough that one can travel to the outdoors so long as you are willing to walk or cycle as well. It just takes slightly more planning is all. I could have never had this sort of car-less freedom in the states. Living in a larger city was probably one thing, but getting from city to city - or city to the outdoors - was quite another entirely.
- CalRobert 10y agoI remember visiting Seoul and being quite surprised that you can take the Metro to the surrounding hillside. It's lovely. Of course, I still use a car now and then. I'll rent one a few times a year for a long weekend, and I use GoCar when I need to rent a van for whatever reason. I definitely don't want to own one though. It feels about as practical as owning an airplane - another class of vehicle which is useful, but not necessary to build your civilization around.
- Broken_Hippo 10y agoI'd imagine your life would change very little if you bought something used - that is what we did. Better than renting a few times, for us, anyway. If I were living some other places, though, I'd have the same attitude as you. Talked to a cab driver in Amsterdam once and found out there was something like a 4-5 year wait on parking spaces. I was completely amazed - owning a car is definitely not that important to me.
- CalRobert 10y ago"I'd imagine your life would change very little if you bought something used - that is what we did. Better than renting a few times, for us, anyway." The local garages charge at least €150 a month for parking. Auto insurance, just for liability, is quite expensive as well. I'd have to pay tax and get an NCT inspection every year too. Not to mention that I have spent too much of my life crawling underneath crappy old cars ('88 Volvo 760, '86 Volvo 240, '90 Nissan Sentra) when I could have just rented something new and well-maintained by someone who isn't me. There are plenty of folks here who will say "but you're a HN reader! Clearly several hundred euro a month should be a trifling expense!" but, well, it's not. Also, the idea that everyone has a car is how employers in less hospitable places (namely, the US) justify putting their offices a zillion miles away from transit.
- Broken_Hippo 10y agoYeah, see, that parking fee would be about enough for me to pass on the car. Just because one is a HN reader doesn't mean they find that a trifling expense. Luckily either that isn't as common in the city I'm in or we are lucky enough to live in a small house turned apartments with parking right outside. I'm not entirely certain about insurance rates on that one - truth be told, that is just something my spouse picks up and I never bothered to ask. I'm still not actually legal to drive here yet. I missed the short deadline, now get to take classes and re-learn. I think if we didn't have dreams of living out in the countryside where transport is much more sparse, I'd not even bother with the expense.
- acdha 10y agoI think your first part is right - and would fit the general trend of people earning less and having longer hours or less convenient schedules - but the second part seems way off. Running, jogging, hiking, and cycling seem at least as popular as ever, which would also fit the theory that sports which have a larger logistical and equipment footprint are more affected by the general decline in economic security. Something like diving or mountaineering costs a lot more in time just to acquire the skills you need to go on a trip but almost anyone can slip on some athletic shoes or ride a bike casually.
- forgetsusername 10y ago>People these days prefer to not go outside at all if they can avoid it. I don't know if this is true. I think I agree with you, but have no idea if the data supports it. Sports and outdoor leisure activities sometimes seem more accessible than ever.
- detaro 10y agoI think for many, cause and effect are reversed from your theory. Hobbies that more or less require a car are less popular with people that do not need a car otherwise, or are moved to locations & styles that are accessible without one. Not having a car limits my outdoor locations to what I can reach by bike and public transport (and my holiday travel locations), but it's hard to justify the hassle of a car just for that. Still enough interesting locations around.
- ghaff 10y agoSports go in and out of fashion all the time. For example, in the communities that I'm involved in, open boat canoeing has been on a fairly long-term decline but paddleboarding is extremely popular, at least in the Northeast, these days--which requires big and hard-to-transport gear. Sea kayaking remains pretty popular as well, as far as I can tell. Not sure what the overall hiking stats are. I can say that a lot of national park visitation (such as to Acadia in Maine) is up. https://irma.nps.gov/Stats/SSRSReports/Park%20Specific%20Reports/Annual%20Park%20Recreation%20Visitation%20(1904%20-%20Last%20Calendar%20Year)?Park=ACAD https://irma.nps.gov/Stats/SSRSReports/Park%20Specific%20Rep... (I'm told it's way up this year. The speculation is that Americans are putting off travel to Europe for various reasons.)
- bluedino 10y ago>> it's not just cars as status symbol in decline, but cars as a lifestyle enabler. That hasn't changed one bit in the midwestern United States. People go 'up north' or 'to the lake/cabin' for the weekend, every weekend. So you need a camping trailer (huge monstrosities in their own right), or a trailer + boat, jetskis, 4-wheelers, dirt bikes, or maybe just some road bikes or canoes/kayaks. If you have a boat/camper you need a full size truck to pull the trailer. Many people go for the 3/4 ton trucks for their hauling and payload capacity. Anything smaller and an SUV will do, and you have quite a few people who put their kayaks or bikes on the roofs of their car.
- MrBuddyCasino 10y agoI can relate. I'm don't own a car, preferring to use car-sharing services instead, but I would love to go kajaking more, which requires a car. Very costly, very annoying.