3 ms·
> While a lot of the research was done by industry (which is how its supposed to, why should the public pay for safety testing of products ?) Actually, no, thi
by xg15 10y ago
> While a lot of the research was done by industry (which is how its supposed to, why should the public pay for safety testing of products ?)
Actually, no, this doesn't make sense to me. If a manufacturer is in charge of safety-testing its own product, there is an obvious conflict of interest and incentive to interpret the test result as favorable for the product as possible. (Or to tailor the product to the test)
To put it bluntly, you wouldn't put the wolf in charge of safety-testing the chicken pen either.
So especially for safety tests a publicly funded, independent institution would make sense to me. (Of course, keeping that institution independent is another problem)
- 7sigma 10y agoI agree, but that doesn't mean that the safety testing has to be done by the company. A system where the company pays for the a 3rd independent party to do the testing is desirable IMO
- merraksh 10y agoBut then the independent third party has an incentive on results that are in favor of the payer, i.e., the company.
- 7sigma 10y agonot necessarily. if they get paid to do the tests whether or not it there is a positive or negative outcome, that incentive is reduced. The choice of 3rd party should be open, transparent and done by the regulating agencies.
- JamesBarney 10y agoIf you're thinking of just one round of testing this is true. But if a 3rd party tester gets a reputation for being tough then everyone tests with another tester. This creates a race to the bottom, where the is an implicit competition to get a reputation as the least stringent tester. This is essentially what happened with the credit rating agencies during the financial crisis.
- hueving 10y agoyou missed the part where he said choosing the tester is done by regulating authorities. That would prevent the financial ratings agency fiasco.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]