3 ms·
Rationality is relative. People do tend to make decisions based on reason, even seemingly irrational people, but 1) people possess differing information, from w
by kibwen 10y ago
Rationality is relative. People do tend to make decisions based on reason, even seemingly irrational people, but 1) people possess differing information, from which two rational actors can draw contradictory yet individually-logical conclusions, and 2) everyone is susceptible to flawed logic. In the case of the latter, trying to directly "correct" someone's logic is often unwelcome (especially in a heated emotional context). Furthermore, sometimes people become invested in a particular decision for foregone reasons, possibly due to information that is secret or inexpressible (e.g. the degree of suffering one experiences from a mental illness, which is very hard to intuitively empathize with for people who are neurotypical).
So the answer is no, rational argument doesn't always work. Sometimes the best that you can do is simply minimize harm to a relationship by not letting the argument escalate or letting anyone burn any bridges. Depending on context, sometimes it might even be worth yielding to a seemingly-irrational argument if it means preserving a valuable relationship (this should be done with caution, obviously). And sometimes things really are just irreconcilable (though hopefully not too often).
- AstralStorm 10y agoPeople often act according to heuristics rather than truly rational analysis. These heuristics are rational on their own, just misapplied at times.