True. But if you compared those numbers to the sales of the iPhone 3G or 3GS, they would look less rosy. What you've got there is a non-smartphone without an ap

True. But if you compared those numbers to the sales of the iPhone 3G or 3GS, they would look less rosy. What you've got there is a non-smartphone without an app store on a smaller carrier being compared with a smartphone with an app store on a larger carrier that's famous of not having many options in the phones you can select because of its CDMA network. Anyway, the whole discussion of which is doing better is completely unrelated to my original objection to the top-level poster.