3 ms·
I was disappointed in this article when it was first published in July. Whenever a newspaper columnist makes a plea to reset humanity's "moral compass", you kno
by vonnik 10y ago
I was disappointed in this article when it was first published in July. Whenever a newspaper columnist makes a plea to reset humanity's "moral compass", you know that the article is basically worthless, an exercise in futility. Usually, these posts are inspired by a sort of lazy annoyance that results when they receive one too many press releases about startups they don't want to cover.
But more importantly, writing like this makes a fundamental mistake about how humanity moves forward. We don't do it efficiently, moving in a straight line. We do it while wasting tons of effort. A bit like the media. We could turn Allison's own criticism against her with an article about media coverage entitled: Writing All the Wrong Articles.
If you look at any website, there is remarkably little news, and a whole lot of speculation, various ill-informed opinion pieces and other forms of clickbait. Waste is just part of human activity. You need to make mistakes before you get them right.
Also, many startups create solutions that are appropriate for niches that any given newspaper columnist may not occupy. They look useless from the outside, but may serve their target well.
Finally, the author doesn't even address the fact that industries core to human wellbeing, such as healthcare, are among the most heavily regulated. Founding a healthcare startup is a good way to waste 10 years of your life navigating obscure laws that impose a heavy compliance burden. And that is not startups' fault, it's the fault of lawmakers and industry lobbyists.
- matt4077 10y agoTHere's the difference between aiming high and failing vs. aiming low and glorifying it (and often still failing). Her argument is that there are a lot of low-hanging fruit that have the potential to actually help people but that the startup community is too homogenous to know or care about such project domains. Some of the domains may be hard to tackle but even within the software domain there are certainly classes od problems that are underserved vs. the gaming/photos/music/sharing market. Indeed one of my favorite example is visible right here: not a week passes without someone writing a new client for Hacker News on (the cli|oculus|as a kernel module). These ate usually side project to learn a new technology and it's completely legitimate to chose a domain you're familiar with, but with a bit more effort I belive it'd be possible to redirect that creative engery to projects that are both more enjoyable and actually useful.