3 ms·
I think what everyone's missing is that this is entirely about economics. SpaceX only had the previous generation expendable rockets for competition and were co
by simonh 10y ago
I think what everyone's missing is that this is entirely about economics. SpaceX only had the previous generation expendable rockets for competition and were cost constrained so went for a low cost rocket system and a tripling-up strategy for Falcon Heavy. Bezos knows SpaceX exists and knows what their rocket's characteristics are. A smaller launcher would compete directly with Falcon 9, better to leave that market to them, so he's scaling up to crate a more efficient large launcher. It may not quite have the capacity of FH, but should be significantly cheaper per pound to orbit.
Also Bezos doesn't give a fig about Mars, so his design doesn't have any compromises BFR might have in terms of size, propellant choice, etc to be a custom launcher for MCT. Musk had no real existing benchmarks to compete against when setting SpaceX's strategy because he was leaving everyone else face down in the dust. Bezos has SpaceX as a benchmark so he's building a strategy asymmetric to theirs to carve out his own niche and beat SpaceX in that sector of the market. Also if SpaceX cost efficiencies create an expanded market for access to space, a larger vehicle will become more viable in that environment than it might be now. Bezos is aiming for where the puck is headed, not where it is now.
- greglindahl 10y agoMethane rockets are bigger than kerosene rockets, that's a problem and not an advantage. Good thing most launches can be served with a factory at the Cape. Second, there's (so far) only a modest market for heavier launches, and it's unlikely that a low-volume big launcher is significantly cheaper than FH, which has more parts but they're higher volume. So it's not necessarily any easier to enter the market there than it is to enter the market with F9-sized payloads. Third, nobody knows what the BFR will be, and yet it may fly before New Glenn. Truely, when billionaires compete, we all win! :-)
- nixos 10y agoThe problem with large rockets is that they require multiple satellites to be placed in a close orbit. It's not that simple.
- simonh 10y agoBezos doesn't really talk about launching lots of small satellites. He talks about heavy industry in space. That will require launching large payloads. I'm not saying his strategy is right or wrong, just that his strategy appears to follow from his objectives.