5 ms·
It is sad. The current model has always been a contradiction, and thus is unreasonable. A law must be public. To do otherwise is to erode the very concept of t
by mindslight 10y ago
It is sad. The current model has always been a contradiction, and thus is unreasonable.
A law must be public. To do otherwise is to erode the very concept of the rule of law.
If a state adopting a code puts it in the public domain, then the code bodies should be suing the state for copyright infringement (unauthorized derivative work), and demanding that states pay to license the code for such use.
If a state adopting a code does not put the code into the public domain, then it should lack all legal force. This isn't a fantastic outcome with regards to building codes, so the state will need to fix the situation.
But instead of forcing a decision one way or another, both the code bodies and slimeballs in government have been content to just let it slide. They both benefit in their own way by corrupting the rule of law, while only the citizens suffer.
- rayiner 10y agoThat's a very ideological take on the issue. The law regularly references standards that often aren't even reducible to writing. E.g. a doctor may be liable to a patient for not conforming to accepted standards of medical practice. But no writing exists that completely defines what those standards are! As a practical matter, the folks charged with following the laws in question are builders. Builders are also members of the standards bodies that create these standards. And they're the ones who pay for the standardization process by purchasing copies of the standards. I actually agree with you that these standards should be publicly available, by the way.
- icebraining 10y agoBut no writing exists that completely defines what those standards are! So what? Being public is not the same as being in writing; you could have doctors responsible for answering questions from the citizenry, for example. And they're the ones who pay for the standardization process by purchasing copies of the standards. And why couldn't it just be an extra fee added to the license required to do construction work?
- mindslight 10y agoThe justification for the rule of law is inherently ideological. If the law is just another pragmatic tool for the powerful to oppress the weak, then why should the masses respect the concept? > a doctor may be liable to a patient for not conforming to accepted standards of medical practice. But no writing exists that completely defines what those standards are! It seems like an "accepted standard of medical practice" is therefore a matter of opinion, meaning you could find two professional witnesses who reasonably disagreed. But much of the building codes are hard requirements - you're never going to be able to find a professional opinion that running a 20A residential circuit on 14AWG Romex is acceptable, even if say it's only in an uninsulated wall and is therefore likely safe. So the two are completely different. Likely in the medical field, ambiguously policing those who stray too far from the herd is the best that can be done. But in disciplines with hard engineering rules, we can do better. > As a practical matter, the folks charged with following the laws in question are builders Erm, what? That's somewhat like saying the only people tasked with following traffic laws are drivers. Well sure, but in that sense we're basically all drivers. Or if you mean that imply that only professional commercial builders are bound by those laws, that is definitively incorrect. People doing their own work are still bound by the law, even in the ridiculous nanny states that attempt to criminalize people working on their own home.
- rlucas 10y ago> The justification for the rule of law is inherently ideological. If the law is just another pragmatic tool for the powerful to oppress the weak, then why should the masses respect the concept? The ideological justification for the rule of law is not necessarily opposed to it also being a pragmatic tool for the powerful. One of the best ways to understand the legal system is as a tool for elites to secure their privileges and avoid violent confrontations over who gets those privileges.
- mindslight 10y agoBut in order to actually accomplish that, it needs to have the buy in of the masses, who would otherwise revolt to take away those privileges. The common person needs to believe that they too are protected through the legal system, and so it is worth following the rules and forcing others to follow the rules. This is what makes it a Schelling point. As an aside, the "drug war" has helped destroy this belief, especially harshest for minority communities. This has resulted in social breakdown and creation of movements like "stop snitching" and Black Lives Matter.
- mindcrime 10y agoBuilders are also members of the standards bodies that create these standards. And they're the ones who pay for the standardization process by purchasing copies of the standards. But if you re-do you own home wiring, you effectively become a "builder". And you probably aren't a member of that industry organization. The real problem is here is that two things are being commingled that should not be. Something that is inherently "public" - the law, and something inherently private - codes developed by industry standards. The real solution is to stop doing this "incorporation by reference" altogether. But if we are going to incorporate, it makes no sense to treat this chunk of law as different from the rest.
- rayiner 10y ago> But if you re-do you own home wiring, you effectively become a "builder". And you probably aren't a member of that industry organization. But what fraction of people do that? That's my point--ideologically I agree with you. But I don't think you can take what is basically a corner case in the legal regime and point to that and say it's an unreasonable tool for the elite to use the law to oppress the weak. I don't buy your "public/private" dichotomy at all. The government should defer to the expertise of private industry when necessary. The small potential for abuse (and there is no evidence that the standards bodies here are abusing their position), does not justify imposing laws on everybody designed by government bureaucrats acting outside their area of expertise.
- mindcrime 10y agoBut I don't think you can take what is basically a corner case in the legal regime and point to that and say it's an unreasonable tool for the elite to use the law to oppress the weak. I guess we don't disagree too much then. FWIW, I'm not saying anything about "the elite oppressing the weak" - at least not in this context. To me this really is just a matter of principle. The government should defer to the expertise of private industry when necessary. The small potential for abuse (and there is no evidence that the standards bodies here are abusing their position), does not justify imposing laws on everybody designed by government bureaucrats acting outside their area of expertise. This is why I'd prefer to get the government out of this altogether. But, then again, I'm a Libertarian, so I want the government out of pretty much everything altogether. :-)
- harryh 10y agoHow exactly have I, a citizen, suffered from the current state of affairs? I get the theoretical argument that all laws should be 100% public but are there any practical negative effects that you can point to?
- convolvatron 10y agoi've found that particularly with electricians, during negotiations they often deflect discussion by saying 'thats not code.' i'm sure that the majority of the times i've been told that, there was a good basis written down someplace. but not having access to the code further skews an already asymmetric relationship between domain expert/contractor and customer.
- mindslight 10y agoThere are a lot of things one could do when wiring that seem like they'd be fine, or even actually are fine, but go against code. And reading the code, one really does get the impression that a lot of it was "written in blood". Based on your wording, I don't know if you know this. But presently the issue of practical accessibility is actually moot thanks to the work of Malamud. The NEC, along with many others, is available right here: https://law.resource.org/pub/us/code/ibr/ https://law.resource.org/pub/us/code/ibr/
- mindslight 10y agoObviously if you don't need anything done that is subject to those laws, then you do not suffer. But, for example, if I didn't have access to the electrical code, I would have been unable to definitively follow the law when running some new power circuits. I would have had to rely on folk guidelines and general engineering knowledge, and could have possibly done something that would cause legal problems down the line. Furthermore, I may have decided that such a thing wasn't worth getting into, and been pushed into hiring an expensive contractor instead. (Also, this excellent comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12480626 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12480626)