3 ms·
FSF has a lot of problems, too, like an unresolved contradiction in its rhetoric between claimed populism ("everyone can be free!") and evident elitism ("but if
by throwanem 10y ago
FSF has a lot of problems, too, like an unresolved contradiction in its rhetoric between claimed populism ("everyone can be free!") and evident elitism ("but if you don't choose to act in exactly the way we promote, to hell with you!") I thought hard about joining, but I'm not comfortable with endorsing such a contradictory and self-defeating stance.
I don't see why you should be embarrassed to use Facebook et cetera. As I've discovered to my personal cost, there can easily be very real social consequences for opting out of these services, Facebook especially. I think you'd have to be Richard Stallman to blame someone for choosing not to suffer those consequences over a point of principle. And I don't think very highly of him for so doing, given the nomadic and largely asocial sort of life he's chosen. That such a life suits him is clear, and he's welcome to it, of course. But his judgment of those who find it not so easy to make the same choice is harshly contemptuous and utterly lacking in nuance, and I find that impossible to respect.
- king_magic 10y agoI agree with you, and I think it's a shame people are downvoting you.
- throwanem 10y agoI appreciate that, and I don't mind paying a few points of karma for a chance to start a conversation worth having. Perhaps that will happen here.
- renaudg 10y agoGNU legacy aside, I see RMS as a sort of extreme moral compass whose views and principles are an important contribution to a number of conversations, but anyone would be insane to actually try and live by them.
- throwanem 10y agoI find I feel rather the opposite - that while Dr. Stallman's technical accomplishments are meritorious in the extreme (especially to a longtime Emacs user like me!), his principles are so uncompromising and lacking in subtlety that they do more to polarize a discussion than the converse. Such, at least, has been my experience.
- covekeyboard 10y agoMaybe I'm just oblivious to the underlying tone of what I've been reading, or I haven't been reading the right things, but I don't think I've seen the FSF say "to hell with you" or anything similar to people who don't choose to act exactly in the way they promote. If you have to use Facebook because of the consequences on your social life from not using it, that's understandable, but then there's nothing the FSF can do for you aside from recommending a few addons. This doesn't mean "to hell with you", it literally means "there's nothing we can do for you". As for Stallman, has he really been showing contempt for users of non-free software? He dislikes proprietary software and actively campaigns against it, and this involves writing about their problems without holding back, but I've never gotten the sense that he has contempt for the users. Even when he uses the word "useds" to refer to Facebook users, I've never gotten the sense that he has actual contempt for users of Facebook. I get that it can be insulting, but I don't think it was meant that way. It's just Stallman trying to get his point about Facebook across and ending up being abrasive about it. Also Stallman is not uncompromising. He believes in freedom and is working to maximise it, but along the way he's used non-free software when there were no alternatives (the most recent example being BIOS some number of years ago), has promoted non-strict free licenses in some cases, allowed the LGPL/GPL/AGPL instead of just making everything maximally protected with the AGPL, etc. He compromises a lot less than most on the issue, that's true, but that's because it's literally his mission.
- throwanem 10y ago> I've never gotten the sense that he has contempt for the users. Neither had I, until I attended his talk at HOPE XI this year. I found his rhetoric in person to differ markedly from that in his writings. The full video of his talk and the following Q&A session is online [1]; I encourage anyone interested in the subject to hear the man out and form your own opinion. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uckLT7mPPIw&list=PLfcAmpILMMdpm-Kf4n37GAmEjKbJbjIDz https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uckLT7mPPIw&list=PLfcAmpILMM...