4 ms·
I don't think this is a given. When Facebook is many people's main communications platform and source of news, censoring Facebook is, effectively, censoring com
by sp332 10y ago
I don't think this is a given. When Facebook is many people's main communications platform and source of news, censoring Facebook is, effectively, censoring communication and news. Since they have such power to affect our societies, they should have some obligations.
- electic 10y agoDisagree. It is the main platform because those folks agree with the terms of use and privacy policy. As suggested, you can use something else that lines up with what you believe and frankly, if a lot more people do that, there will be another viable rival to Facebook. Vote with your clicks.
- fsloth 10y ago"It is the main platform because those folks agree with the terms of use and privacy policy" I disagree. Do you know how many general users have the vaguest ideas what those things are? People en masse use Facebook because other people do - they have very limited of awareness of anything how Facebook skews their view of reality and what limits their communication on the said platform has - until they hit those limits. They just know all of their friends are on the platform, so they must be there too.
- electic 10y agoI think you nailed it right there. People have not hit those "limits" and are okay with what they see on the platform. Since there is no decent, the people are OK with Facebook's handling of cleaning content.
- sp332 10y ago[Assuming you mean "dissent".] I see plenty of complaining about what Facebook doesn't allow... like the article we're referring to for example. I even see some on Facebook, especially about the breastfeeding policy. See also https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Criticism_of_Facebook#Censorship https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Criticism_of_Facebook#Censorsh...
- sp332 10y agoThere are consumer protection laws that prevent companies from abusing their customers even through "agreements". http://fortune.com/2016/03/02/facebook-germany-antitrust/ http://fortune.com/2016/03/02/facebook-germany-antitrust/
- electic 10y agoThis has nothing to do with what the OP said. The discussion is about what is allowed on FB and what is not allowed on FB. The article you linked to is talking about data collection policies.
- shiftpgdn 10y agoExactly! The more people that leave the platform for somewhere else the less control that Facebook has over communications. Facebook has no more obligation to allow you to write whatever you want on their site than the New York Times has to publish your op-ed piece.
- az0xff 10y agoIt will be interesting to see how this fact will come up in legislative discussions. Has it happened before -- that so many people ended up relying on a single corporations that the corporation needed to take on special obligations?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- jimmytidey 10y agoI completely agree with the above. The idea that society should accept that it has no control over the design of a major artery of communication is not sensible. With print media, TV, phone and post, all developed countries have special regulations that ensure these (often privately run) services align with values of democracy (with varying effectiveness). I think the ideal solution would be to compel Facebook to make its architecture more open. For it to have real APIs, which, among other things, would allow other companies to transition users from Facebook effectively and seamlessly. This is analogous to the reasoning that says that banks cannot make it unreasonably difficult to switch to another bank by creating admin around direct debits and the like (rules currently being implemented in the UK). Facebook can engage in whatever kind of censorship it likes as long as the barriers to leaving it are sufficiently low that we can realistically imagine users doing so. (Unfortunately FB is not a formal monopoly because it's free to users.. so we absolutely do need new legislation).
- austinheap 10y agoYou can download an archive of your Facebook data already. What "real APIs" would you like the government to "compel" this private corporation to add?
- sp332 10y agoYou can't download most of the data facebook collects about you. This guy tried, and it was a legal battle. http://www.wired.co.uk/article/privacy-versus-facebook http://www.wired.co.uk/article/privacy-versus-facebook "The concept of access [to your data] was just alien to them. In the US consent is just a privacy policy and a tick-box approach." "They break democratically decided laws in the EU and get away with it. Instead of putting money into compliance, they expect NGOs and authorities to do that work for them."
- jimmytidey 10y agoBy real APIs I mean ones with sufficient durability and access to data to allow third parties to provide innovative products based on them. The bundle download that Facebook offers (which I have used) doesn't meet those criteria, we can see this because no one has built a business off it. At the moment Tinder is the only company I'm aware of that really does this, and it's not exactly a corner stone of democracy. I've no idea why you've written the word compel in speech marks? If it is because you think it is unacceptable to ever compel a private corporation to anything, I'd point out that Facebook and all other corporations are already bound by all kinds of laws, many of which are very widely accepted. Especially relevant here are the laws (and social norms) TV and print organisations adhere to.