3 ms·
My problem with the iPad is that it's more closed than it needs to be. It's fine to provide people with a simple, immediate, intuitive and trouble-free interfac
by cageface 17y ago
My problem with the iPad is that it's more closed than it needs to be. It's fine to provide people with a simple, immediate, intuitive and trouble-free interface to information. Not everybody needs to be or wants to be a content creator. But why not allow people to install apps outside the App store if they manually opt-in, as Android does? Why the absurd secrecy around the sdk and developers agreements? Why the seemingly arbitrary rejection of apps that in some way impinge on functionality Apple reserves for itself to implement?
The almost paranoid and unduly aggressive control Apple exerts over its platform is worrisome, particularly for a company poised to dominate an important emerging platform. This is why, as much as I respect Apple's engineering and design prowess, I do not use its products. After two decades of a suffocating Microsoft monopoly I'm not eager to spend the next two under another.
- lawn 17y agoWell said, you managed to articulate my feelings spot on.
- andreyf 17y agoBut why not allow people to install apps outside the App store if they manually opt-in, as Android does? Because people will install apps that don't work and then blame their iP(ad|od|hone) for misbehaving. If they could figure out a good process for it, I'm sure Apple would certify their developers before letting them develop applications. Why the absurd secrecy around the sdk and developers agreements? What absurd secrecy? AFAIK, the only threatening legalese was removed in 2008 [1]. I don't know for sure, but I imagine it was there left over from the developers that knew about it before the SDK was announced. Why the seemingly arbitrary rejection of apps that in some way impinge on functionality Apple reserves for itself to implement? Because people do get confused about things you might think are obvious. If you give people two "dialer" apps, I guarantee you they'll sometimes launch the wrong one. And again, frustration against apps is frustration against the device. 1. http://www.telecoms.com/5294/apple-removes-secrecy-oath-from-iphone-sdk/ http://www.telecoms.com/5294/apple-removes-secrecy-oath-from...
- nkassis 17y ago"Because people will install apps that don't work and then blame their iP(ad|od|hone) for misbehaving. If they could figure out a good process for it, I'm sure Apple would certify their developers before letting them develop applications." I don't buy that. What seems much more obvious a reason is that, they can't make money on selling applications outside the "AppStore"
- blhack 17y ago>Because people will install apps that don't work and then blame their iP(ad|od|hone) for misbehaving. Millions of people using OSX disagree with you.
- electromagnetic 17y agoThe people opting in to install non-store apps likely fully understand that the apps may not work on their particular device. Anyone remotely tech savvy is going to comprehend this fact, and you're likely going to have to be somewhat tech savvy to be willing to hunt down sites supplying non-store software. I wholly agree, there are quite probably untold millions who are savvy enough to comprehend the limitations of their devices.
- ynniv 17y agoMy problem with the iPad is that it's more closed than it needs to be. Ah, but it's not if you want to sell content. As most jailbroken iPhone users show, the first order of business is to download every app that sounds interesting - for free. Now, I am not anti-piracy. Applications have often become popular through piracy, and that results in eventual conversions. But in the past, the default has been a lack of protection with great effort required to enforce copyright. This favors the establishment who has the capital to develop protections and enforce them. The iPhone/iPad is a different model, where commerce is the default. Want to sell a $1 app? Trivial. Want in-app commerce? Trivial. Where once you had to build a web service that required 24/7 support, you can now build a standalone product and be done. This is the lone developers dream. But it is also the hobbyist's nightmare, and that's why the makers are up in arms. Since we happen to be hanging out in their camp, it sounds like this is an unnecessary evil, preventing us from "owning" our devices! But really, you need to see both sides to this: by enforcing copy protection by default, Apple has created a panacea for the starving developer. Write something good, something useful, something fun, and you will get paid by the masses. And when it's all said and done, you don't even have to use one yourself.