4 ms·
"Intellectual property" is a silly euphemism
- bayareaguy 19y ago"Digital property" would be a better term for the stuff Doctorow talks about in this article.
- LogicHoleFlaw 19y ago"Property" is exactly the word which should not be used for the things Doctorow discusses. The differences between the intrinsic value of knowledge and the intrinsic value of physical possessions are great enough that any attempt to control them in the same way is fallacious. The treatment of knowledge as property leads to unwise analogies, decisions, and laws. "Intellectual Property" is a loaded term used to mislead people into making decisions against their own self-interest.
- bayareaguy 19y agoYes, IP when used as a catchall moniker for these things just confuses the issues: - Ideas vs Expressions - Exhaustable vs Inexhaustable resources - Property vs Control
- RobF 19y agoDoctorow's article is all well and good. He doesn't like the term. I get that; he's said it before. But I never quite manage to understand exactly what he proposes to substantially replace the existing legal and semantic structure. If I make something that doesn't have a particular physical manifestation, what rights and obligations do I have to that creation? I think that, when pressed, many people who sympathize with Doctorow in this debate would assert that a thing that has no physical manifestation conveys no rights to its creator. But I wish they would come out and say that directly, instead of dancing around the issue while making essentially content-free semantic arguments.
- darjen 19y ago"I think that, when pressed, many people who sympathize with Doctorow in this debate would assert that a thing that has no physical manifestation conveys no rights to its creator. But I wish they would come out and say that directly" That is exactly what many IP opponents state. For example - Against Intellectual Property, by Stephan Kinsella: http://www.mises.org/journals/jls/15_2/15_2_1.pdf http://www.mises.org/journals/jls/15_2/15_2_1.pdf
- Xichekolas 19y agoI had the same problem. He seems to define the problem quite elegantly (it's use isn't exclusive, so it's not property, and the word 'property' leads to fallacious reasoning), but he never offers any idea what we should do/say instead.
- LogicHoleFlaw 19y agoI looked at the series this article was written for, and the previous article does make a suggestion, and names a group which is working for it at the WIPO. Here's the key summary: We need to stop shoe-horning cultural use into the little carve-outs in copyright, such as fair dealing and fair use. Instead we need to establish a new copyright regime that reflects the age-old normative consensus about what's fair and what isn't at the small-scale, hand-to-hand end of copying, display, performance and adaptation. Hopefully my small extraction here does not fall astray of the copyright laws. http://www.guardian.co.uk/technology/2008/jan/29/copyright.law http://www.guardian.co.uk/technology/2008/jan/29/copyright.l...
- RobF 19y agoI read the second article. It didn't help my understanding of Doctorow's position all that much. The problem, as always, is in the details. I want to understand what Doctorow thinks are the essentials of this putative "age-old normative consensus" which he finds so compelling. Just stating that such a thing exists doesn't get me any farther along to understanding the intellectual framework which he wants to use in order to make the trade off between the creator's interests and those of society at large.
- jazj 19y agoCory Doctorow is a windy, pompous self-aggrandizing douchebag but I grudgingly admit that he is correct in this case.
- mynameishere 19y agoYou need a license to sell whiskey. You need a license to listen [1] to copyrighted music. Both rules hamper behavior for no reason that can be explained by a physics textbook. Rather, they exist because the restrictions are perceived to add value to society. Maybe they don't. But it's not a philosophical dispute. [1] Or, really, to use the music in a set of contractually defined ways.
- edw519 19y agoIntellectual property is neither.
- Prrometheus 19y agoIf the IP laws on the books were followed by everyone, it would be a disaster. Any sufficiently large piece of software violates patents, so our “knowledge economy” would grind to a halt. To me, the definition of a bad law is one where society prospers only because it is violated en masse.
- derefr 19y agoBut what if society would be worse off both with a law enforced less and enforced more? Do we have some sort of legal structure for a sort of "optimum statistical enforcement?" Something where someone can be "10% guilty" and pay a 10% fine, or where a certain "penalty" can only be assessed in favor of a given party N times per year, etc. etc.?