2 ms·
> I hear from mediaeval HEMAists that it's not really quite the same as mediaeval combat As soon as anything becomes a sport it deviates from how it works in r
by dspillett 10y ago
> I hear from mediaeval HEMAists that it's not really quite the same as mediaeval combat
As soon as anything becomes a sport it deviates from how it works in real life. It has to, especially when the thing is combat based because killing someone in the name of sport simply isn't cricket.
I'm a member of a group that practices medieval sword, dagger, and unarmed techniques - with a view to being martially sound and historically accurate (within the limits of not actually maiming each other - there are things we know how to do that we would never try on a live training partner or in a tournament). Other groups have a different set of priorities: re-enactors tend to be very detailed about the look of the uniforms, equipment, and formations, but are much from lax/free with the actual combat techniques; people doing it for sport obviously can't be entirely accurate both for safety and audience entertainment reasons; and so on.
> I wouldn't know, not specialising in that period myself.
Even those that do don't 100% know how people back then trained and fought because the surviving manuscripts are not complete and even if they were would not contain all the information a modern audience would need as there was a certain amount of play combat kids would have been exposed to very early that didn't need to be taught - no one writing the training down thought that some of those details would ever need writing down. As with many historical studies, working out how the masters intended their work to be trained out is often therefor an exercise in reading between the lines (filling in the gaps with morsels of information from other sources and sometimes just from what we know about how the human body and the materials in the weapons and clothes/armour physically work) and of course this leads to multiple differing interpretations. This isn't just an issue when looking as far back as medieval periods: there are a few parts of the original Fairbairn/Sykes techniques from WWII (modified versions of which are still in use today by many forces), including the areas that were deliberately simple overall so they could be taught quickly to new intakes of soldiers who were sometimes completely inexperienced at fighting, where people can't entirely find agreement about how to translate the written instructions to useful physical techniques.
- gvurrdon 10y agoI'm a member of a group that practices medieval sword, dagger, and unarmed techniques - with a view to being martially sound and historically accurate My background is similar, though it's not mediaeval (nothing earlier than the late 17th century).
- pavel_lishin 10y ago> Even those that do don't 100% know how people back then trained and fought because the surviving manuscripts are not complete and even if they were would not contain all the information a modern audience would need My wife and I did HEMA for a bit, and as I understand it, most of the knowledge in longsword combat comes from Liechtenauer, who - and he was not unique in this - would write down his training techniques, but almost as a riddle, to ensure that it would not be enough to just read his book and apply it - you'd have to actually have to pay him, or his students, to come and teach you.