4 ms·
So are UIs of Reddit, Facebook, Craigslist, Amazon, ... a bad, usable UI that people are used to > an academic good UI, that nobody understands/uses. Ranting a
by okket 10y ago
So are UIs of Reddit, Facebook, Craigslist, Amazon, ... a bad, usable UI that people are used to > an academic good UI, that nobody understands/uses.
Ranting about bad UIs reminds me a bit of ranting about tabloids. They are obviously bad, and nobody reads them if asked, but that does not change the fact that they are very popular.
(Please don't use bad UIs as a template if you start fresh, minimalistic is OK)
- fwn 10y agoBut other than Reddit, Facebook or Amazon, Twitter does seem to have a growth problem. I'm not a user and I don't think that I have strong feelings about their service but if forced to visit their page I'm confused most of the time. A bad UI that can't be excused by success ist just a plain, bad UI.
- chucky_z 10y agoMaybe I'm the reverse case, but I really, really like Twitter's UI. Especially their newly redone mobile UI. While Facebook is now completely unusable on my phone, and Reddit is very close (an example of too-much-JS-gone-wrong), going on Twitter is a blast of minty fresh air at my fingertips.
- Grue3 10y agoTwitter has way worse UI than Reddit or Amazon. It's flashy and barely functional, as opposed to crude but extremely functional. Whereas reddit pages load instantly, any Twitter page is a 10 megabytes-sized blob of Javascript that slows your browser to a crawl.
- Stratoscope 10y agoReddit is working hard to catch up to Twitter. Have you tried their new mobile site? It's the worst user experience I've encountered in quite a while. When I go to any page on the site, I get a blank page with an alien in the middle. Quite some time later, the content actually loads. If I tap a link and then go back, it goes through this all over again - and then it doesn't go back to the same scroll position but some arbitrary place. Finally I found a menu option that let me get the desktop Reddit site. I kept trying Chrome's "Request desktop site" but it didn't work. Turned out I had to use a setting in the Reddit mobile site's own menu for this. The desktop site is a huge improvement, but with major flaws of its own. The font sizing on mobile is fairly ridiculous - huge page titles and minuscule comment/etc. links - but at least the pages load fast and it behaves like a normal website. What in the world are they thinking with this new mobile site? If they only fixed up the font sizing in the desktop site it would be perfectly usable on mobile - and much better than their mobile version.
- ansible 10y agoYeah, I'm not too happy with the new mobile version of Reddit. I still use the compact view [1] on my phone, which works fine for everything except moderation. On my tablet I just use the desktop view. [1] http://reddit.com/.compact http://reddit.com/.compact
- TeMPOraL 10y agoI really hope those changes Reddit does are because they're evil and want to track us and spy on us with shit ton of JavaScript. The alternative to that is too horrible to consider - that they may have no fucking clue what they're doing, and like everyone else they're just cargo-culting the current web industry bullshit "standard practices".
- the_other 10y agoI find Reddit so utterly unusable that I don't even have an account. Visiting a Reddit page, all I see is confusing tumble of interface: I can't distinguish content from controls, one level of reply from another, useful content is drowned out by "me too" and "snark". The mobile interface uses text sizing that is too small to read on my device (with my eyesight).
- vacri 10y agoAn 'academically good UI' should be easy to understand. Sure, that doesn't mean people will use it, but the ability of users to understand the UI is pretty fundamental - if they can't understand it, the UI is not 'academically good'. Some places like Craigslist choose to maintain their rougher UI, since a slick UI will scare off some users.
- DanBC 10y ago> a bad, usable UI But Twitter's UI is barely usable. It's not possible to search my past tweets, or someone else's past tweets, for one example. That alone turns twitter from being a useful tool to share information into being a trivial app to share ephemeral nonsense.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- pdw 10y agoWhat's wrong with Twitter's search page? To me it seems to do everything one might want. https://twitter.com/search-advanced https://twitter.com/search-advanced