3 ms·
I don't see how it works. Just world certainly does not contradict suicide. A lot of suicide is driven by either mental or physical suffering, and nobody who in
by smsm42 10y ago
I don't see how it works. Just world certainly does not contradict suicide. A lot of suicide is driven by either mental or physical suffering, and nobody who in not 5 year old doubts that suffering exists in the world, and a lot of it. We certainly hope it won't happen to us, but I don't think anybody denies that it does happen around us.
So while I agree that american culture has misguided attitude on suicide, I don't think your explanation works.
- jessaustin 10y agoYou seem to be using a novel meaning for the term "just-world fallacy": the assumption that suffering is deserved is the whole point.
- smsm42 10y agoWell, "deserved" is very nebulous - I'm not sure there can be any fact, including suicide, that can disprove that particular instance of suffering is "deserved". You can always build a logic that this person has done something - in this life, in past life, in spiritual realm, in thoughts, whatever - that made them "deserve" whatever suffering there is. It's not a verifyiable thing as such, and thus it can't be really disproven by empirical fact. It's a question of faith, which doesn't deal with empirical facts by definition. I don't see how suicide changes anything there.