4 ms·
Review of A New Kind of Science by Stephen Wolfram (2002)
- SubiculumCode 10y agoFrom title thought this was an article about Trump. don't down vote me. I finally got to 100 :) update: comment referred to original title, not current.
- qwertyuiop924 10y agowow. I mean, I knew Wolfram was nuts, despite Mathematica's success. But this... this is beyond nuts. It's not just crazy, it's also immoral (not citing people who do your research, suing everybody left and right, etc.).
- intrasight 10y agoInteresting analysis of a very brilliant but very flawed personality
- m_mueller 10y agoI was really confused. The title and author in the header really looked like the title and author of that post with that formatting. Until I read the tiny link at the top. Just goes to show that minimalist HTML/CSS can be used for terrible layouts - just like an overuse of JS.
- jknoepfler 10y agoThe title should indicate that it is linking to a book review (of a now rather dated doorstop of a book). Although the linked article follows a standard journal book-review format, which makes it obvious on context what is going on, it is not obvious to someone following an HN link.
- r721 10y ago(2005)
- rdtsc 10y agoI was in the fist or second year of college and I asked for A New Kind of Science book as a gift. I believed the book, not knowing much about the history of the related fields NKS supposedly compelely revolutionized. That's how cult following starts, isn't it? But then as years rolled by I realized that stuff is too far out of the ordinary, with the claims which are too lofty. Even as far as style goes, at first phrases like "I discovered this...", "I did that.." seems impressive, excuded confidence, but then, they started to sound grating and excessively arrogant. I just couldn't stand to read it anymore. The book collected dust for a few years, then I gave it away to someone.
- braythwayt 10y agoAnd in 2012, the follow-up, "Ten Years of Monster Raving Egomania and Utter Batshit Insanity:" http://bactra.org/weblog/915.html http://bactra.org/weblog/915.html
- leephillips 10y agoHas Wolfram's "new kind of science" led to any predictions of natural phenomena in the 15 years or so since his book appeared? This is usually how we decide if a physical theory is interesting. Generating patterns that look like natural phenomena that we already know about doesn't count.
- braythwayt 10y agoThe review’s author claims that in the decade following it’s publication, neither the book nor Wolfram have made any contribution to the field.
- bendbro 10y agoThis website is quite fun. Here's another. http://bactra.org/notebooks/prigogine.html http://bactra.org/notebooks/prigogine.html
- untilHellbanned 10y agoWhy do people always mention that someone is smart? It's a non-informative sentence. How many times do you hear that someone is dumb? I'll take my community college educated mother over this "child prodigy" on the vast majority of subjects, so he must not be that great.
- kragen 10y agoOn the contrary, 99.99% of the population is really dumb. (I'd like to think I'm part of the other 0.01%, but the low prior probability of that situation suggests that I don't have enough evidence to justify that conclusion.) Wolfram is not part of that 99.99%. He's part of the 0.01%. But he's squandered his talent on self-indulgent and self-destructive projects instead of contributing to the intellectual and cultural advancement of humanity. It turns out that human nature is such that being really smart doesn't give you a high probability of being right about things, especially when the truth is not favorable to you, just a slightly better one.
- untilHellbanned 10y agoYou missed my point. If he is smart and yet not right as you say, doesn't that make him dumb?
- ScottBurson 10y agoArrogance makes smart people idiots.
- qwertyuiop924 10y agoIn short, high amounts of intelligence, while comparatively rare, is not necessarily a trait you should optimize for.
- kragen 10y agoI feel that your attempt at summarizing my comment falls far short of the mark in many ways; not only was that not the entire meaning of my comment, it is not only its main point, and in fact it is not even among the things my comment said. In fact, it is mysterious to me how you could read that into what I wrote, to the point that it tempts me to question your sanity.
- hackinthebochs 10y agoAren't we done flogging this guy yet?
- qwertyuiop924 10y agoThe beatings will continue until Wolfram stops. Just kidding. If we beat on this guy anymore, he'll die, and turn into a horse.
- starchild3001 10y agoNot sure why we're still discussing this book. It's old, and it's been thoroughly debunked many times. One of few ~1000 page books from which I've learned nothing.
- starchild3001 10y ago> This book was more valuable when it was a tree. 'nuff said.