3 ms·
If they did, I'd be shocked if large tax cheats weren't tailoring their cheating specifically to the algorithm, and the only people that it caught were small ti
by pessimizer 10y ago
If they did, I'd be shocked if large tax cheats weren't tailoring their cheating specifically to the algorithm, and the only people that it caught were small timers and people who made honest mistakes.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoThis is already the case. Humans doing judgement calls are an "algorithm" too. Moreover, there are only two algorithms you can't game - one that perfectly addresses and solves explicit and implicit aspects of the problem (impossible in practice), and one that is perfectly random. Computer algorithms are much easier to improve than low-paid human clerks, so there's that too.
- im4w1l 10y ago> Moreover, there are only two algorithms you can't game - one that perfectly addresses and solves explicit and implicit aspects of the problem (impossible in practice), and one that is perfectly random. Care to explain?
- TeMPOraL 10y agoThe first one is ungameable by definition. Also practically impossible to make by the very same definition - for one, we always work with imperfect information, but moreover, humans are damn good at redefining the rules of the game on the fly. The second one follows the principle of American Army - "If we don't know what we are doing, the enemy certainly can't anticipate our future actions". A purely random selection cannot be gamed directly because it doesn't change its behavior in response to external input. However, it certainly can be meta-gamed; e.g. some people could take advantage from the very fact such algorithm is used in the first place. This circles back to the same point I made about the "perfect" algorithm - humans are just too damn good at metagaming. Still - my primary point was that a) humans are a gameable algorithm too, and b) humans are pretty low-hanging fruit as algorithms go. We can, and should, do better. [0] - http://www.allproudamericans.com/paimages/here-is-why-americans-do-well-in-war.jpg http://www.allproudamericans.com/paimages/here-is-why-americ...
- im4w1l 10y agoI completely agree that those are not gameable. The thing I wondered about was why there can't be any other ungameable algorithm.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoI believe the two cases are provided (perfect algorithm and random algorithm) exhaust the list of ungameable ones (though they're still meta-gameable).