4 ms·
An audit may not be a punishment, technically speaking, but neither is being predictively policed, technically. Neither is being stopped for a brief patdown bec
by danso 10y ago
An audit may not be a punishment, technically speaking, but neither is being predictively policed, technically. Neither is being stopped for a brief patdown because a suspect in an armed robbery is black and you happen to be black and within the vicinity.
The latter situation is most definitely an algorithm whether it be administered by a computer or human -- e.g. 1. is there a person in front of me. 2. Is this person male? 3. Is this person dark-skinned? 4. Is this person within X meters and inside a timeframe of Y minutes from a reported crime?
As for making judgments probabilistically; hate to break it to you, but that's already the status quo. Exhibit A: Probable cause.
And probabilistic thinking is most definitely behind sentencing guidelines. Let's take the recent and still controversial case of Brock Turner, the ex-Stanford swimmer convicted of sexual assault [0].
Aren't the following aspects of the Turner case all a manifestation of probabilities?
0. That his bail was set at $150,000, based on the likelihood of an accused (and not yet guilty) rapist of his status would break bond.
0.5 The likelihood that he did indeed sexually assault the victim and was not ignorant as to her state of consciousness or consent.
1. The recommended minimum sentence of 2 years in prison for his convicted crime.
2. The probation officer's recommendation that he be given a "moderate" county jail sentence.
3. The judge's determination that Turner, based on his lack of prior criminal record, be given 6 months in county jail.
4. The county jail's determination that Turner serve only 3 months in county jail because of good behavior.
5. The post-incarceration penalty that comes with Turner to be thought of as a Tier III sex offender, which means he has to register 4 times a year (presumably based on some statistic that that's enough polling frequency to adequately track him), for the rest of his life.
Note: I'm not implying that you agree with any of these aspects of the case. Just saying that if you're concerned about statistics and likelihood playing a part in our criminal system, then that ship has long sailed. In defense of the machines, if a machine had been the sole determiner of Turner's sentence, we'd at least be able to audit it and know how it weighted things. With the human judge, we don't have a clue as to whether the judge's personal relationship with Stanford was a factor, or even if he read the probation officer's report correctly when giving the seemingly light sentence. Hell, we don't even know how the probation officer interpreted the victim's wishes [1]
[0] http://www.daytondailynews.com/news/news/crime-law/greene-county-sheriff-no-kid-gloves-for-brock-turn/nsQCT/ http://www.daytondailynews.com/news/news/crime-law/greene-co...
[1] http://www.cbsnews.com/news/probation-official-called-brock-turner-crime-less-serious/ http://www.cbsnews.com/news/probation-official-called-brock-...
- carapace 10y agoDude you are working way too hard to do... what? What's your angle? For me, it's really simple: The day that a machine decides how long I spend in a cage we are going to have a serious problem.
- yummyfajitas 10y agoHe is trying to think rationally. Sometimes attempting to find the right answer, rather than simply the one that feels good, is in fact "hard". I'm glad some people put the effort in rather than just chasing positive feels.
- someguydave 10y agoMr. Stucchio: Mass democracy is the root of this problem. One proof is observing the way in which democratic decision-making has devolved chiefly into emotional appeals to in-group moralistic bromides. To me, the degree to which one seriously desires rational thinking as a basis for lawmaking is the degree to which one desires a reduction in the number of cooks in the kitchen.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- carapace 10y agoRationally speaking it would be irrational to ignore emotional responses when reasoning about human behavior. Rationality can lead you astray, you have to listen to your heart. Emotions can lead you astray, you have to listen to your head.
- danso 10y agoSorry, you said earlier that you were someone who understood computers well enough to know that you would never want one to replace human judgment in matters of justice. I thought you'd be interested in knowing that computation (delegated to machines for efficiency and consistency) is actually part of the justice system. The Bureau of Prisons has a department that is named, "Designation and Sentence Computation Center". Maybe they don't actually use physical computers to perform the computation (though that'd be a bit weird if they didn't), but I think that's an irrelevant implementation detail as the Supreme Court has upheld the use of an unyielding mathematical formula to determine the length of a prisoner's sentence: https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/09pdf/09-5201.pdf https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/09pdf/09-5201.pdf https://www.law.cornell.edu/supct/html/09-5201.ZD.html https://www.law.cornell.edu/supct/html/09-5201.ZD.html