4 ms·
The credit reporting system probably wouldn't work if you had to have the account holder's 'permission' to add events to it - you have to do it in this automate
by bluedino 10y ago
The credit reporting system probably wouldn't work if you had to have the account holder's 'permission' to add events to it - you have to do it in this automated way.
Although it can be a pain, the responsibility of if your credit report is accurate falls on you, the consumer. You should many of the free services to check your credit and then dispute any events that aren't correct. Most people don't have issues but you can have companies that don't report payoffs (they should be fined or something), companies that assign accounts to the wrong person/SSN, etc.
- dhimes 10y agoAlthough it can be a pain, the responsibility of if your credit report is accurate falls on you, the consumer. I can only be responsible for the things I do. If some shithead wants to give third-party information about me it better be accurate, and if its inaccuracy causes me harm it should be actionable.
- TheCoelacanth 10y agoExactly. If I spread false information about someone to their detriment, that is slander. How do credit reporting agencies get away with it?
- sokoloff 10y agoGenerally, (in the US) statements made in good faith and with reasonable belief that they are true are not going to be found slanderous.
- HarryHirsch 10y agoProbably with carefully written laws, same as why we are seeing bogus DMCA requests all the time. Most crime has to be committed "knowingly", but if you automate your DMCA takedowns they can't catch you for perjury because you don't know what your system does.
- gnopgnip 10y agoIf a creditor incorrectly reports a debt after writing to the creditor and credit reporting company you can sue them under the FCRA for actual damages or the statutory $1000 per violation.
- chrischen 10y agoI thought you only get 1 free credit report per year?
- JadeNB 10y agoOnce per year per agency, which gives you three (I think?) total reports per year.
- toomuchtodo 10y agoYou are correct. The idea is that you space them out every 4 months so you can keep tabs on your credit file for free.
- Fezzik 10y agoYou can also get free reports through (some) banks and credit cards - Bank of America now provides members an updated FICO score every month and emails a link to access it. One if my credit cards has the same service but I cannot pinpoint which one right now.
- twblalock 10y agoCiti, Discover, and American Express also provide real FICO scores (as opposed to the estimates provided by some of the other credit sites).
- 13of40 10y agoI don't know how it works today, but back when I was 20-something it was good advice to dispute anything negative on your credit report, because a lot of companies wouldn't bother responding by the deadline. I had a friend who made a defaulted mortgage disappear that way.
- mmmBacon 10y agoI've had bad/wrong info on my reports in the past and it took years to get the stuff removed. There is no transparency to the process and the process seems completely arbitrary.
- thatcat 10y agoThis sounds pretty similar to DCMA reporting. When responsibility for error correction doesn't fall on the person making the error there will be more errors, especially in an automation system because there is no incentive to sanity check. In both of these cases, the person harmed is blamed for not monitoring an a third parties automated system for errors. Users now need a way to automate the monitoring/dispute process.
- wongarsu 10y agoI don't think the fact that the process is automated is a problem (and I don't see anyone saying so). The problem is that existing algorithms are bad (like in the article where an algorithm decided two people are the same based on name and year of birth alone, when all other factors speak against it) and that complaints are not handled properly,
- toast0 10y ago[from the article] > the defendant, unsurprisingly, had the same legal first name, last name and middle initial. We were also both born in 1987. But our similarities end there: He has half a dozen convictions. He’s black. He’s currently incarcerated. And an arrest warrant indicated that he was homeless > when all other factors speak against it Given that the agency thinks they're the same person, the number of convictions is irrelevant. A credit agency has no knowledge of skin color. I'm not sure that a credit agency would know if someone was incarcerated -- their accounts could still be active and paid for by someone else. Credit agencies keep track of residence addresses, but would likely assume that he was at his last know address. I think the root of the problem is getting a criminal background check and a credit report from the same place. The quality of information is quite a bit different, but the expectation is different. For a criminal background check, I would expect false matches because the lookup is realistically based n name and date of birth only. As a result, I'd want to know additional information, such as mug shots, and current status (incarcerated, on parole, etc) to confirm if the person with the record was the person in front of me.
- wongarsu 10y ago>I'm not sure that a credit agency would know if someone was incarcerated I would assume they can get this information, considering that some reporter seemed to be able to get this information easily. Making hard decisions on wether two people are the same is hard. But that's exactly why "name and year of birth match" seems like a naive algorithm. I would expect a match probability based on the treasure trove of statistical data that these agencies possess. A person that is currently incarcerated is less likely to be the same person that is currently spending and earning money, and for which landlords request reports. Skin color is strongly correlated to place of residence: if you know (automatically or manually detected from a mugshot) that one person is black, you can get the statistical probablility that the other person is black from the neighbourhood he lives in. etc. >I think the root of the problem is getting a criminal background check and a credit report from the same place. I agree that this is also not optimal. In Europe this type of information is obtained by requiring a criminal record certificate, a certificate anyone can get from a police station to show their (lack of) criminal record.
- maxerickson 10y agoOnus or burden would be a better word there than responsibility. They are largely synonyms, but the difference in tone is useful. I mean, I don't actually owe it to a bank to ensure that some other party has accurate information about me.
- GirlsCanCode 10y agoActually, there's only one legitimate free service that was mandated by a settlement with the Government. The rest have confusingly similar names that all try to scam you. (Shamefully, the government didn't provide for a .gov domain for the legitimate access to the free service.)
- graeme 10y agoIsn't it libel to spread incorrect information about others, that is damaging, and that is certified as a true belief?
- tedunangst 10y agoOnly if you know the information is false.
- Implicated 10y agoYou're only referring to credit reports... did you read the article? This wasn't only a credit report, but a landlord profiling service that they provide that also gives your criminal history... how, do you suppose, are we to monitor _what they see_ as our criminal histories? I've had this exact same thing happen to me, about 6 years ago, when applying for an apartment lease. The landlord called me to ask about the violent offenses (robbery, assault) that came back on my background check that she was _sure_ couldn't be me. How am I supposed to monitor that? And, how would I do that _at no cost to me_?
- cortesoft 10y agoAre you saying the responsibility falls on the consumer in the factual sense or the moral sense? I mean, that it falls on the consumer in fact seem obvious, but I don't agree that it does morally. I think the person or group that makes he mistakes are morally responsible.
- cortesoft 10y agoThis wasn't a credit report, though... This was a background check service. There was no way for the consumer to proactively check it and correct errors.