7 ms·
Time crystals might exist after all
- pcl 10y agoThe article doesn't really describe time crystals themselves in terms I could understand. Wikipedia to the rescue: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Space-time_crystal https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Space-time_crystal
- userbinator 10y agoTo those who aren't knowledgeable about the subject, it sounds as bizarre and incomprehensible as https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Time_Cube https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Time_Cube
- jerf 10y agoWhile this isn't quite what a "time crystal" is, imagine a two-dimensional universe that contains just one arrow in it. Now spin the arrow. Now plot the full state of the system, using the third dimension as time. You get a sort of spiral thing going along the dimension you used for time. This periodic structure is sort of like what they mean by "time crystal"; it's a periodic structure in the time dimension. Now, there's more to it than that. I'm not proposing this as a full explanation of what it means, just trying to get the B-class sci-fi ideas out of the way to sketch out the complicated bit of what they mean. As a crystal is a periodic atomic structure in space, a time crystal is a periodic atomic structure in time. There's more to both, of course, but that should help get the woo-woo out of the way.
- lisper 10y agoHow is a "time crystal" different from a plain old [EDIT: quantum] harmonic oscillator?
- ars 10y agoEnergy. A time crystal is at its lowest energy state. A harmonic oscillator has energy in it - if you took away the energy it would stop moving. i.e. to stop a time crystal add energy. To stop a harmonic oscillator take away energy.
- SomeStupidPoint 10y agoI believe that the idea is the time crystal remains in its ground state the entire time (especially given the work of the author on anyons).
- wyager 10y agoThe other responses have not addressed the possibility that you are referring to a quantum harmonic oscillator. If you are, that is a very good question. I believe the resolution here is that while the phase of a quantum harmonic oscillator in the ground state changes with time, the results of bracketing any hermitian operator (i.e. measuring a physical quantity) does not change throughout time. Therefore in the ground state of the quantum harmonic oscillator, the system is time translation invariant. So a quantum harmonic oscillator does not form a time crystal.
- lisper 10y agoWell, yeah, I thought it was a given that we're in quantum-land here. In classical physics the lowest energy state of a system is necessarily static.
- maxwelljoslyn 10y agoThank you for dispelling the woo-woo.
- dingbat 10y agothanks for the worthy attempt at explanation, but the b-class sci-fi feel of this remains so strong, i cannot help but associate this having to do with Sleestaks and Time Pylons
- hinkley 10y ago> Since this construct is in the lowest energy state it could in principle survive the heat death of the universe and continue forever.[5] whaaaaat? We could leave messages for inter dimensional travelers at the end of time?
- UlyssesSKrunk 10y agoYeah, but time cube isn't hard to understand. It's perfectly clear. It is the answer to everything. It is the grand unified theory. It is a box containing a consistent system of axioms capable of proving all truths about the arithmetic of the natural numbers. It is love. It is life. It is Time Cube.
- JonnieCache 10y agoTo quote scott alexander, "Mysterious “time crystals” may hold the secret to outlasting entropy. No word yet on whether you have to get all seven, or whether they are hidden in temples themed around the seven elements."
- weatherlight 10y agoIt's just bad science journalism :/ Wikipedia indeed to the rescue.
- Ericson2314 10y ago> Since this construct is in the lowest energy state it could in principle survive the heat death of the universe and continue forever. This made me very excited. The ultimate legacy.
- blackoil 10y agoInteresting, that Microsoft sponsors such a research that I can't see being used by the business for visible future. I am not a shareholder so can't make a view of this is good or not.
- ianai 10y agoIt's probably a tax write off. If it is then I'd almost prefer it to them paying taxes to be divided out to DOD
- sksnxjis 10y agoWhere T<1 is the tax rate, spending X on a write-off allows you to avoid paying X*T in tax. But you still end up with X(1-T) less money in the end.
- denim_chicken 10y agoWhat is your point???
- zo1 10y agoThe point is that they are still paying money. Calling it a "tax write-off" to the layman sounds like they're just doing it to reduce how much they pay in taxes. I.e. It sounds like tax-evasion/fraud.
- Pyxl101 10y agoHis point specifically is that tax write-offs don't reduce how much you have to pay overall. They may even increase it. They just redirect some of it to other purposes such as research instead of paying taxes.
- PeCaN 10y agoHeaven forbid a company tries to save money AND do research…
- mrtree 10y agoI read it and understood nothing.
- adjwilli 10y agoI got redirected to the http //www.thesofttic.com/ZiWblMur/win-f/gi/?SiteID=4905&conversion=11ee233b-a3f6-4b44-8d5f-9c578b58eb29 from the link. Anyone who know why or what that is? Is phys.org really infected with malware?
- cohomologo 10y agoPhysicist here with some context: The systems considered here have periodic drives (in the article, "Floquet"). This means that time-translational symmetry is already partially broken. The system is only the same after waiting times that are multiples of the period T of the drive. The time-translational symmetry breaking occurs because the state of the system is not periodic with period T as would normally happen but periodic with period 2T. In terms of frequencies, if the drive frequency is f = 1/T, then this system responds at a frequency f/2, whereas normal systems can only respond at frequencies f, 2f, 3f, ... that correspond to harmonics. Additionally, this time-translational symmetry breaking makes a stable phase of matter -- that is, you don't have to fine tune any parameters of the system to see the effect, and experimental noise won't destroy it. It also doesn't matter which initial state you prepare your experiment in. While not as exotic as a time-translational symmetry breaking without a drive to partially break the symmetry first, it is still pretty surprising that this type of phase exists at all. It is likely that spontaneous breaking of full time-translational symmetry can never be stable in the same sense.
- selimthegrim 10y agoYou're absolutely correct. There are some nice papers by Potter, Vasseur et al. and Else and Nayak which illustrate your latter point in gory mathematical detail (they derive constraints from symmetry on symmetry protected topological phases and then use math to relate that to the sort of Floquet phases you can protect using symmetries). Of course, if you're actually Dominic Else, I defer to you... e: Hah, I commented without reading the article, this is the PRL publication of the Else and Nayak paper, with an added co-author, I had read the preprint a few months ago. The other paper good to read to enlighten oneself in this context is https://arxiv.org/abs/1510.04282 https://arxiv.org/abs/1510.04282
- selimthegrim 10y agoAlso of interest: http://arxiv.org/abs/1605.03601 http://arxiv.org/abs/1605.03601
- Pyxl101 10y ago> In terms of frequencies, if the drive frequency is f = 1/T, then this system responds at a frequency f/2, whereas normal systems can only respond at frequencies f, 2f, 3f, ... that correspond to harmonics. Interesting. I heard it described once that a particle with spin of 1/2 is like a particle that you have to rotate twice (through two 360 degree rotations) before it's in the same configuration. Wikipedia actually has a visualization that seems to depict this reasonably: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spin-%C2%BD https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spin-%C2%BD Anyway, your description makes it sound like this system by responding at f/2 might have an analogous property with time. Is this at all a reasonable or correct analogy?
- mrfusion 10y agoWhy can't regular crystals survive the heat death of the universe?
- tlb 10y agoHeat death === no remaining thermodynamic free energy. The universe is all one temperature, though theories vary widely on what this temperature might be. At high temperatures crystals vaporize, absorbing heat. At low temperatures, gases sublimate onto the crystal, releasing heat. Either way, if you have crystals, the universe hasn't completed its heat death yet because you could use the crystal to do work.
- p1mrx 10y agoBy that definition, wouldn't the heat death never actually happen? Space is expanding, so there should be some particles that zip off and never collide with anything. Also, couldn't a sublimating gas disrupt a time crystal?
- dragon_ninja 10y agoThe universe will not necessarily experience heat death, so whether "regular" crystals or time crystals cannot survive something that may not happen could be irrelevant.
- n72 10y agoOh no. This is going to get picked up by one of those nutbag spiritual clickbait sites and tomorrow my girlfriend is going to tell me about an amazing discovery about crystals which can be used to power a time travel device.
- hexane360 10y agoFor only $200 I can build a perpetual motion machine based on TIME CRYSTALS! Physics said so!
- dschuetz 10y agoI always thought that making physics more complicated made physics potentially more wrong. But then I read "Microsoft Station Q" in the article. Go figure. If there is "Microsoft" on it there is a flaw in everything.
- ZenoArrow 10y ago> "I always thought that making physics more complicated made physics potentially more wrong." There's no correlation between complexity and correctness. An explanation can be too simple as well as too complex. Nature is what it is, our understanding of it evolves over time.
- joelthelion 10y agoWouldn't a simple pendulum (or an orbiting planet) qualify as a time crystal? If not, why not?