5 ms·
The sugar free/carb free Atkins diet of the 90s and its modern versions isn't any better. Pretty much any diet which is free of anything should be avoided.
by dogma1138 10y ago
The sugar free/carb free Atkins diet of the 90s and its modern versions isn't any better.
Pretty much any diet which is free of anything should be avoided.
- benwr 10y agoHow so?
- dogma1138 10y agoHow so what? A diet that says it's ok to eat a steak but an apple is bad because it has carbs in it? There is nothing wrong with carbs, carb free diets work because it's easier to create a caloric deficiency not because you some how can eat 3000 cals of w/e and lose weight. But in the long run they aren't healthy either try being on a low carb diet and exercise at the same time let me know how it's working for you. Especially endurance run for 10km> even 5km a few times a week after a month without carbs and tell me how you feel. But nvm I see there is not point of even trying to talk with the folks in this thread everything that is remotely against low carb is being down voted to spam :) Anyhow enjoy your lives just remember to see a doctor often.
- benwr 10y agoThis is somewhat amusing, considering that that is my actual current diet and exercise regimen (for the last several months, with the added restrictions of being almost entirely vegetarian and doing some light weight training and cycling), and I feel pretty awesome. I do agree that this thread is very monoculture-y though, which makes me uncomfortable.
- dogma1138 10y agoBeing vegetarian and being "low carb" is to some extent oxymoronic, you are getting your calories from somewhere and if it is vegetarian it mostly going to be fatty acids and carbs. A few months with "light exercise" doesn't mean anything, your personal feeling is also not a quantifiable metric, if you were actually setting yourself a specific physical goal like to run say 10KM under 40min, or deadlift X lbs you would not be feeling very well without carbs. Overall what low carb diets excel at is to cut people away from "bad foods" which means it's very easy for them to be in caloric deficiency (sometimes considerably higher than what they should, you do not want to have a dietary caloric deficiency higher than 200 of your BMR (not the BRM part not total caloric expenditure), and 500 is the max for even extreme diets) but if you are already willing to not eat processed food cutting good carbs like rice, full grain, and many fruits and vegetables out of your diet is simply silly.
- toasterlovin 10y agoYou can be vegetarian and eat a low carb diet. It's not as easy as eating meat and eating a low carb diet, but it's eminently achievable. Eggs, cheese, nuts, avocados, and oils will probably comprise most of your diet.
- benwr 10y agoBeans and vegetables too! But yes, this is mostly right.
- oldmanjay 10y agoRice is the food version of styrofoam popcorn packing. Its main quality is that it's cheap stomach filler. You can do better for yourself by using leaves instead.
- soneca 10y agoProfessional athletes are using low carb diets (http://www.latimes.com/food/la-fo-calcook-side-20130622-story.html http://www.latimes.com/food/la-fo-calcook-side-20130622-stor...) And there is no real conclusions for long runners either (http://bjsm.bmj.com/content/early/2014/05/26/bjsports-2014-093824.extract http://bjsm.bmj.com/content/early/2014/05/26/bjsports-2014-0...)
- raverbashing 10y agolow carb != zero carb Zero carb (or if too reduced) is really not sustainable And you're right, eating an apple is ok.
- simik 10y agohttps://reddit.com/r/zerocarb https://reddit.com/r/zerocarb - plenty of people sustaining zero carb for years.
- Jedd 10y ago> ... carb free diets work because it's easier to create a caloric deficiency not because you some how can eat 3000 cals of w/e and lose weight. There is much missing / wrong with your logic and assertions - but this one is particularly telling. Are you genuinely asserting that low-carb diets work because ultimately they involve less calorie consumption than a 'conventional' (carb-heavy) diet? If so, this seems entirely wrong to me - low-carb diets typically involve the consumption of a greater volume of energy (calories) compared to what your BMR would suggest you need to not gain weight. This is, as noted elsewhere, also ignoring the benefit of low-carb diets to your GL/GI rollercoaster.
- dogma1138 10y ago>If so, this seems entirely wrong to me - low-carb diets typically involve the consumption of a greater volume of energy (calories) compared to what your BMR would suggest you need to not gain weight. Eh no, now you are getting into the realm of physics, what happens often are 2 things. Some foods have overstated caloric values this is quite common. Your body doesn't metabolizes some foods at the same rate, especially true when you adjust your diet considerably and your body isn't used to produce enzymes in the required amounts, as well as other environmental factors like fiber content (lower fiber count would mean lower caloric value while higher fiber count would increase the caloric value even tho fibers themselves have no intrinsic caloric value on their own) and gut biome. If you think you can eat say 500-1000 cals over your daily allowance with any diet and not gain weight, man you have really really been sold hard on this.
- Jedd 10y agoI feel you are intentionally conflating / confusing the discussion. For example: > If you think you can eat say 500-1000 cals over your daily allowance with any diet and not gain weight, man you have really really been sold hard on this. No one's saying this - at least, the article isn't, and nor am I. I will say that you can easily eat 500-1000 cals over your daily allowance with a particular diet (notably low-carb) and not gain weight - and that's what you seemed to be arguing against earlier. I've got 3 years of carefully recorded data that demonstrates this is the case -- but I'm just one of a huge number of people who have proven this out over the years. So I'm not clear what point you're trying to make.
- toasterlovin 10y agoA couple of points: 1) The low-carb hypothesis is that there is a fundamental physiological reason that highly refined carbs cause weight gain. It goes something like this: highly refined carbs get stored by your body as fat. Because they get stored as far, they are unavailable to be used for energy. Because they are unavailable to be used as energy, you get hungry (this is your body signaling that it needs energy). So you eat more carbs. Wash, rinse, repeat. Do you have a specific claim as to how this hypothesis is incorrect? 2) It is a complete non-issue that it's hard to compete in long distance running races while on a low-carb diet, especially for people who are obese. Running has an incredibly high injury rate (on the order of 20-90% of runners get injured per year, Google "running injury rate"). It's about the worst way imaginable for an obese person to be active.
- chillwaves 10y agoCan you post some kind of evidence to support what you are saying? Because I have done keto (under 30g net carb a day until your body enters ketosis) while doing an exercise routine and after the first week or two to adjust, found no problems with energy levels. The downvotes come because you are making assertions that have no medical support.
- wpietri 10y agoI strongly disagree with this: > Pretty much any diet which is free of anything should be avoided. For the couple of years, I've been trying various elimination diets so that I can see what effects particular foods and food groups have on me. Even if I had ended up with exactly the same diet, it would have been worth doing, as I learned a lot about my body and my relationship with food. As it happens, though, I want to keep some pretty big changes. After doing my 3rd Whole30 [1], a paleo-esque 30-day elimination diet, I'm just finishing a week where I returned to eating refined carbohydrates. My conclusion: as much as I enjoy those foods, they make me feel terrible. My mood and energy were much less even. They put big demands on my self control, and make me prone to binging. I sleep less well. Starting tomorrow, I'm going to spend a few months without refined carbohydrates again (sugar, flour, juices). I'll probably drop dairy again too. I don't know that I'd recommend my particular choices for anybody else, but I strongly encourage curious people to experiment with elimination diets. If nothing else you get the sort of exercise in self-control that religious people get from Lent, which I think is valuable on its own. But I learned a ton along the way, and wish I had done this years ago. [1] http://whole30.com/ http://whole30.com/
- dogma1138 10y agoGood for you, want to try it without a link to a commercial diet?
- wpietri 10y agoIt started out non-commercial, and all their recommendations are available on their site. I've never given them any money, and you are welcome to do the same.
- benlambert 10y agoPersonal experimentation is great. Try and see instead of following bad science and dogma.
- sago 10y agoYou know that discussion that comes up when people confuse Climate and Weather? Similar thing here. Dietary recommendations are population level tools for improving health. Individuals can benefit from taking an engineering approach and figuring out what improves problems they are having. Which is not to say follow every faddy diet, but just get used to experimenting gradually with your meal planning. And whatever you find, does not invalidate population studies, any more than snow in your city invalidates global temperature rises.
- CyberDildonics 10y agoPeople basically evolved without any sugar (fructose) except what they could get in fruit (which was limited and contained fiber). With the sugar islands it became available to people though expensive and volatile in price. With high fructose corn syrup etc. it became a consistent priced commodity with little to no volatility.
- dogma1138 10y agoEh, fruits are the core diet of primates, infact most primates wait for the fruits to start ferment which increases their caloric value while actually reduces the fiber count. Humans have evolved eating sugar just fine, fruits and fermentation were used before we learned to walk, and other sources of sugar including honey were also commonly consumed. You can easily look at the diets of "modern" hunter gatherers and see just how "low carb" it is. Don't get me wrong eating too much sugar (glucose/fructose/sucrose) isn't good for you, but sugar isn't the only carb out there. Until the 1900's starch fed the world, it still does, some how what is succesfully feeding the 5.5-6bln poor people of the world is no longer good for you.
- jsmthrowaway 10y ago> Until the 1900's starch fed the world, it still does, some how what is succesfully feeding the 5.5-6bln poor people of the world is no longer good for you. What are you even talking about? We have a public health epidemic of obesity, especially among the "poor people of the world." They are literally the most affected group by low-cost availability of processed foods. This is undisputed and self-evident. Of course it is worth it to revisit our recommendations and practices given what it looks like when we look out the damned window. You think someone just decided well, starch has had a good run, time to move on based on no scientific basis? Your commentary in this thread is actively harmful in its complete substitution of science and understanding for your own personal gut feeling. You sure are saying a lot and ignoring the requests for citations.
- dogma1138 10y ago>Your commentary in this thread is actively harmful in its complete substitution of science and understanding for your own personal gut feeling. You sure are saying a lot and ignoring the requests for citations. The only thing that harmfull in this thread is the viral groupthink, you are more than capable of doing your own research. The Journal of Human Evolution is a good place to start, PMC also has some good sources on dietary and nutritional habits throughout human evolution. Reading the works of evolutionary and molecular biologists like Hillard Kaplan, Marlene Zuk and Jennie Miller would also do you good. But sure keep spreading your "scientific" fact, just ignore the studies and research and cherry pick your evidence like that initial NHS study that was disavowed by the NHS itself because it was utterly flawed as the data about the greatness of the low carb and paleo diets eventually came out of 6 people since everyone else dropped the study which also lacked a control group. Or the 2nd UK study that again had issues with high dropout rates and still somehow managed to get published even tho the dropout rate effectively attached a huge selection bias to the study. But hey you and your gang are more than welcomed to downvote actual evidence even statements like the fact that our ancestors processed plants ;) https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2973873/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2973873/ Overall if you actually care about GI and carbs the research authored and coauthored by Jennie Miller is a great source of information, unlike people like Loren Cordain she's actually accredited to making the claims she makes, and it's ironic that one of the biggest proponents of the low GI diet is for the most part against low carb diets in general. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/?term=Brand-Miller%20J%5BAuthor%5D&cauthor=true&cauthor_uid=26591850 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/?term=Brand-Miller%20J%5...
- CarlaWonders 10y agoQuite honestly, nothing beats a good caloric deficit. Especially if that caloric deficit is from a strong Paleo Diet like the one I have been using. http://how2loseweightnow.com/2016/09/11/paleo-reboot-diet-best-paleo-diet/ http://how2loseweightnow.com/2016/09/11/paleo-reboot-diet-be... What everyone should do, is instead of searching for weight loss tips to go at google and find his daily caloric maintenance, then start eating 500 calories below that with a Paleo Diet and combine all that with a respectable workout program. The fat WILL melt off.
- CarlaWonders 10y agoQuite honestly, nothing beats a good caloric deficit. Especially if that caloric deficit is from a strong Paleo Diet like the one I have been using. http://how2loseweightnow.com/2016/09/11/paleo-reboot-diet-best-paleo-diet/ http://how2loseweightnow.com/2016/09/11/paleo-reboot-diet-be... What everyone should do, is instead of searching for weight loss tips to go at google and find his daily caloric maintenance, then start eating 500 calories below that with a Paleo Diet and combine all that with a respectable workout program. The fat WILL melt off.