7 ms·
Thank the "low-fat/fat-free" craze for that. Associating dietary fat with body fat has been one of the worse mistakes in "nutrition" in the past decades. Now
by raverbashing 10y ago
Thank the "low-fat/fat-free" craze for that.
Associating dietary fat with body fat has been one of the worse mistakes in "nutrition" in the past decades.
Now most "low-fat" food has added carbs to deal with the loss of consistency. And even regular foods (especially in the US) have added sugar.
- jordanb 10y agoNot just added carbs, added sugars and starches, the worst kind of carbs.
- raverbashing 10y agoYes, but sugars and starches are carbohydrates (I think you mean high-glycemic index foods).
- heisenbit 10y agoNot all carbohydrates are processed equally. Complex starches are more difficult to break down in the gut and are absorbed slower often for the better. Some don't break down much like sorbitol. Most digestible carbohydrates eventually break down to glucose and fructose. The key insight here is that fructose is very different from glucose as it is processed primarily in the liver and converted to triglycerides - which is seen as a more problematic fat in the bloodstream. Since fructose does not contribute directly to blood sugar levels for a while it was recommended for diabetics to switch from glucose to fructose. Turns out the latter is not so good from an inflammation perspective, liver/body fat perspective, digestive perspective and perversely blood sugar regulation perspective. Sadly even that old fructose is ok for diabetics has not fully vanished. The medical establishment (like any establishment I guess) is slow to change. Speeding up the publication, curation and dissemination of such information may be IT's main contribution to human health.
- dogma1138 10y agoThe sugar free/carb free Atkins diet of the 90s and its modern versions isn't any better. Pretty much any diet which is free of anything should be avoided.
- benwr 10y agoHow so?
- dogma1138 10y agoHow so what? A diet that says it's ok to eat a steak but an apple is bad because it has carbs in it? There is nothing wrong with carbs, carb free diets work because it's easier to create a caloric deficiency not because you some how can eat 3000 cals of w/e and lose weight. But in the long run they aren't healthy either try being on a low carb diet and exercise at the same time let me know how it's working for you. Especially endurance run for 10km> even 5km a few times a week after a month without carbs and tell me how you feel. But nvm I see there is not point of even trying to talk with the folks in this thread everything that is remotely against low carb is being down voted to spam :) Anyhow enjoy your lives just remember to see a doctor often.
- benwr 10y agoThis is somewhat amusing, considering that that is my actual current diet and exercise regimen (for the last several months, with the added restrictions of being almost entirely vegetarian and doing some light weight training and cycling), and I feel pretty awesome. I do agree that this thread is very monoculture-y though, which makes me uncomfortable.
- dogma1138 10y agoBeing vegetarian and being "low carb" is to some extent oxymoronic, you are getting your calories from somewhere and if it is vegetarian it mostly going to be fatty acids and carbs. A few months with "light exercise" doesn't mean anything, your personal feeling is also not a quantifiable metric, if you were actually setting yourself a specific physical goal like to run say 10KM under 40min, or deadlift X lbs you would not be feeling very well without carbs. Overall what low carb diets excel at is to cut people away from "bad foods" which means it's very easy for them to be in caloric deficiency (sometimes considerably higher than what they should, you do not want to have a dietary caloric deficiency higher than 200 of your BMR (not the BRM part not total caloric expenditure), and 500 is the max for even extreme diets) but if you are already willing to not eat processed food cutting good carbs like rice, full grain, and many fruits and vegetables out of your diet is simply silly.