4 ms·
For basic things yes. For more advanced features, I can't think of any competitor. As a result office has pretty much stopped evolving the last 10 years. The o
by cm2187 10y ago
For basic things yes. For more advanced features, I can't think of any competitor.
As a result office has pretty much stopped evolving the last 10 years. The only thing they are working on is making it more cross platform / web friendly. But it's pretty much a dead ecosystem.
- geezerjay 10y ago> For basic things yes. For more advanced features, I can't think of any competitor. For features above the basic level, Microsoft Office is far from being an alternative as well. For example, try to reformat the figure numbering scheme, or add an appendix to an Microsoft Word document. Very basic stuff, and yet Microsoft Word fails to offer a sane option to do so. Microsoft's offerings are only perceived as being above adequate because people don't know better.
- Roritharr 10y agoAnd what would be better?
- ptaipale 10y agoOn one front, LaTeX. On another, e.g. Framemaker. But as an overall documentation tool MS Word is hard to beat because you can still do most things, and it is ubiquitous. In my experience, the worst problems with Word come out of company templates. Plain Word out of the box causes less surprises.
- cm2187 10y agoMost of my troubles with word have to do with most of the properties of the items on the document being invisible. You are dealing with invisible page breaks, invisible margins, invisible objects, etc. What would be really powerfull is a dual markup/WYSIWYG UI, like WPF in visual studio. Editing xml attributes on a markup is way more efficient than trying to guess on what you clicked and then going to menus and nested sub menus. But typing raw xml is not fun, you want to be able to type in the document directly. And you don't want to expose the markup to unsophisticated users. The markup should be way more defensive than a text editor. It should not allow you to place a node where that type of node is illegal. It should make autocomplete adds the mandatory features when typing a new node (like the closing tag, the mandatory attributes, etc). Otherwise we will spend our time dealing with corrupted documents. Same for powerpoint, which in my opinion has pretty much converged with word. Most decks created are not on screen presentation but rather rich visual text documents, just text document with a page orientation that fits modern screens.
- pjmlp 10y agoThis is what commercial editors for Docbook and DITA allow for, yet you don't see many keen in embracing them.
- adrianratnapala 10y agoWhat would be really powerfull is a dual markup/WYSIWYG UI, like WPF in visual studio WordPerfect had this in the '80s. It's a conventional word processor, but you could press the "Reveal Codes" function key and get a split-screen. The lower half would show all the markup. You could see and delete a tag explictly, and its matching one would also go away. Though of course, the markup was not indented. My mother, -- a secretary -- used it all the time. But when she met other secretaries who came from an MS-Word backround, they hated the very existence of the feature. I think the last few editions of WP removed it (in order to cargo cult Word?). Then they went out of business.
- ptaipale 10y agoWord has had that for a long time. In modern ribbon-interface Word versions, it's in the Home-Paragraph section, top right icon ("paragraph mark"). Additionally you can/should toggle field code display with Alt-F9. This has been in Word since, I think, Word for Windows 2.0 (circa 1992, for Windows 2.11). It might have also been in the previous DOS-based Word versions that co-existed with DOS-based WP (but since I used both, I can't always tell which features were in which).
- adrianratnapala 10y agoDo you mean those strange cryptic characters at the end of the paragraphs? That is not a lot like reveal codes, or like a markup language. Though I agree they are handy.
- ptaipale 10y agoMaybe not markup language, but the idea is to show the markup. To get a paragraph break, you still hit Return and don't try to type that end-of-paragraph marker. The field codes are more like an actual language; you can insert a field and then type the content in it.
- cnvogel 10y ago> In my experience, the worst problems with Word come out of company templates. Oh, yes, brother. Especially as they tend to be created by the people with the least experience in using (even modestly) advanced features.
- cm2187 10y agoI work for a major international corporation which official powerpoint template has hardcoded numbers on each slide, no auto-page numbering...
- geezerjay 10y ago> because you can still do most things, and it is ubiquitous. That's also true for LibreOffice or other FLOSS office projects. In fact, a copy of LibreOffice doesn't cost anyone between 100€ and 300€, or requires any subscription.
- ptaipale 10y agoStill, in the corporate world most people do not have LibreOffice, but they do have Microsoft Word. And in very many cases they can't even install software themselves, as the computer is managed by the IT/IM organisation. The cost of license is negligible in this context; the actual cost comes from managing something non-standard. Yes, you or me don't like it but it's the fact in many corporations, government organisations and even educational institutions.
- chris_wot 10y agoWhat advanced things can Office do that LibreOffice can't?
- mikekchar 10y agoI don't know for sure, but I'm willing to bet that there are sophisticated mail merge features in Office that don't exist in LibreOffice. The other major killer feature that I'm aware of in Office is the track changes feature. There are work flows that absolutely depend on that for cooperative editing and sign-off. You can do these things other ways, but once the workflow is entrenched it would be really hard to move people to something else. If you've never seen some of the insane mail merges that people do, you might think it would be trivial to implement, but alas it is not. Having said those things, it's been quite a while since I touched a word processor (5 years or so). When I last used Libre Office there were some other obscure bugs/features that made me want to throw it out the window. The main one was the way it formats multi-lingual text. If you try to write text that switches between roman and asian fonts, good luck in keeping the baseline in place. I made an attempt to convince people to change the idiotic way it is done (by shrinking the font size!) but had no luck. I'm not a fan of Office either for the record, but I can see why some people do not want to change.
- type0 10y ago> The other major killer feature that I'm aware of in Office is the track changes feature. This is by far the worst "feature", it's a plague that management enforces on its employees mainly not knowing any better or just being plain ignorant. As you said this comes down to unwillingness to change and learn something new. In most cases using plain text format like asciidoc/asciidoctor with some version control system would be enormous improvement.
- massysett 10y agoI am a government attorney by day and a hobby programmer at night. There is absoloutely no way you are going to get any significant number of office workers to use asciidoc and a VCS. It's hard to even get a lot of people trained in Word. The agency has training classes when a new version is installed--which is once every few years. People struggle with stuff like the ribbon. To use asciidoc and a VCS people would have to start from scratch training wise. Not gonna happen. I routinely format sizable documents and have to collaborate on them. Word is an abomination and I hate it. From a technical standpoint other tools are far superior. But a bunch of office workers are not going to learn anything else. It would not be worth the effort. Since MS has no incentive to improve Word I grit my teeth and accept that I will have to deal with its garbage.
- tajen 10y agoOTOH, I used to work as a govt contractor where they routinely give 1000-page software specifications with screenshots and non-unified titles. There was no safe way to save them, let alone work concurrently, so let's just say they're not the right tool at all for most routine tasks in large companies.