5 ms·
As a culture, we really have a misguided attitude about suicide, stemming largely from the insidious just-world fallacy. It's a comfort to many of us in this fu
by jessaustin 10y ago
As a culture, we really have a misguided attitude about suicide, stemming largely from the insidious just-world fallacy. It's a comfort to many of us in this fucked-up world, to think that maybe it's not as unfair as it seems. As persistent as that warped logic is, it doesn't withstand suicide. We don't want to imagine we could ever face a truly intolerable situation, so instead we imagine a world that doesn't allow such, and we damn those whose deaths would contradict us.
- jomamaxx 10y agoThe world is as Just as we make it. Cynicism is a cancer. We damn those who gave up on trying after having been given the greatest gift that can be received. The point is life - more, better, higher, more beautiful, more intelligent, more creative. Anything that gets in the way of the unfoldment of life in the universe will be deemed bad.
- electic 10y ago"The world is as Just as we make it." - There are limits to this. There are forces far powerful than we like to admit. Systems man made. Systems that are that of nature. With all our might we can bend some of them, but sometimes we can't. Along with things that are full of happiness there are those that fall into depression, poverty, sadness, loss, regret, and suicide. Sometimes we are victims to circumstance. The man that fell from that tower that day didn't want his world to be what it was on that sad day. He didn't give up as you put it. To me he is brave.
- jomamaxx 10y agoThe man was not committing suicide, he was murdered.
- qubex 10y agoPrecisely. Thanks for summarising it so succinctly and truthfully.
- shiven 10y agoSo why the collective censorship? There is no such censoring of "murder" news.
- electic 10y agoI never said he was committing suicide, I said he was a victim of circumstance. Even if he did intentionally jump, it wasn't a bad thing our society makes it out to be. We will never know either way.
- dredmorbius 10y agoHe was doomed to die no matter what. He was doomed due to the deliberate and malevoloent actions of others. He either chose, or was unable to overcome psychological impulses, to act in a way that he took his own life. I'm looking at a definition of suicide that includes the word "voluntary", which could well be contested given the extreme threat and lack of alternative here. At the same time, I do not personally see all suicide as unwarranted, wrong, or sinful (though there are cases in which I'd strongly prefer people didn't kill themselves). The Falling Man, and the many others who similarly lept from the Twin Towers, and those who similarly take their lives in the face of desperate circumstances are what they are. In many cases the label "suicide" fits. I don't find it dishonourable. But causality and life are complicated, words express ideas, and ideas are our own mental models. If you trace events back to original causes you find numerous complications at ascribing simple terms and unambiguous labels to them. Sometimes the ambiguity is greater, sometimes lesser. Describing these particular deaths as both murder and suicide strikes me as defensible.
- jomamaxx 10y agoI obviously understand the nuanced issue regarding the fact that he technically took his own life. But given that is death was absolutely imminent within a few minutes, I really don't think this is a case of 'suicide' in any of the remotely classical scenarios. It's not 'suicide' in any reasonable sense of the term.
- jomamaxx 10y ago99% of misery is caused by humans. Most people who commit suicide are not objectively in situations of extreme difficulty. Many wealthy, successful people commit prison. Surely, negative conditions are correlated with suicide, but it's not the driver. It's a psychological/spiritual issue.
- rdtsc 10y ago> As a culture, we really have a misguided attitude about suicide A lot of it is religious. It is considered a great sin in popular religions. Even though many don't follow religion it left this ingrained idea in the culture. Also perhaps is seen as shameful. Part of the desire to censor the images was probably not purely to respect the victims, but also to hide the act, because it is shameful ("don't show this to the children" type thing) The reason it is shameful is that it is seen as the most radical act of "giving up". And that doesn't jive with the "you can overcome anything with hard work" culture. You can read this in how people talked about it -- "they were forced out" instead of "they decided to jump". Both are correct at some level. But first seems more appropriate in our culture. One other level, perhaps even unconsciously we understand there is a possibility of contagion. It has happened and actually has been observed (someone in a high school does, and then usually a string of suicided might follow, the more talk and media coverage the more suicides follow etc). Maybe at some point in that past that fear of contagion got codified as a taboo...
- gaius 10y agoA lot of it is religious. It is considered a great sin in popular religions. Well partially, but there is also that in ancient times it was considered that you would be depriving the emperor/king/state of his rightful property (or hers obv). Infact in North Korea today if you commit suicide your family will be sent to a slave labour camp for that same reason.
- sullyj3 10y agoI think that the just world fallacy is an enormous contributor to the existence of religion in the first place.
- merpnderp 10y agoI was under the impression most religions don't believe the world is just or fair and that it is people's jobs to attempt to make it more so.
- jessaustin 10y ago
- smsm42 10y agoI don't see how it works. Just world certainly does not contradict suicide. A lot of suicide is driven by either mental or physical suffering, and nobody who in not 5 year old doubts that suffering exists in the world, and a lot of it. We certainly hope it won't happen to us, but I don't think anybody denies that it does happen around us. So while I agree that american culture has misguided attitude on suicide, I don't think your explanation works.
- jessaustin 10y agoYou seem to be using a novel meaning for the term "just-world fallacy": the assumption that suffering is deserved is the whole point.
- smsm42 10y agoWell, "deserved" is very nebulous - I'm not sure there can be any fact, including suicide, that can disprove that particular instance of suffering is "deserved". You can always build a logic that this person has done something - in this life, in past life, in spiritual realm, in thoughts, whatever - that made them "deserve" whatever suffering there is. It's not a verifyiable thing as such, and thus it can't be really disproven by empirical fact. It's a question of faith, which doesn't deal with empirical facts by definition. I don't see how suicide changes anything there.