8 ms·
When Will New York City Sink?
- IANAD 10y agoI saw this in AI: https://youtu.be/-isE7cFJTzU?t=1m36s https://youtu.be/-isE7cFJTzU?t=1m36s
- shmerl 10y agoWaterworld?
- sbmassey 10y agoSome day a real rain will come and wash all the scum off the streets
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Hondor 10y agoWhy any concern about private land being flooded? Landowners who are worries about it can sell it now, before anyone else has cottoned on or if they want to take a risk, they can keep it. It's an individual decision for each land owner, and they're the ones who'll suffer the effects of their own personal choice. Doesn't seem like something for anyone to really worry about.
- haimez 10y agoYou're right, no one should worry at all about the simple matter of private land ownership in New York as the sea comes in. It's a simple matter of private property ownership, right? No complicated information economies need be considered, right? No state programs might seek to intervene and disrupt the predictable linear progression of climate change, right? Anyone that's worried surely feels silly after reading your comment sir. Thank you for your godly libertarian insights.
- BuckRogers 10y agoGeez. He didn't really take it quite as far as your rebuttal, where you proceeded to beat on the strawman you created. He said nothing about state programs intervening and all of that. He's being downvoted quite unfairly for his apparent political stance, but he did have a point. While it would never work the way he suggested, it should more often. Instead, we privatize profits and socialize losses. I think a lot of people are or should be very sick of that trend by now. That was his point.
- ZenoArrow 10y ago> "While it would never work the way he suggested, it should more often. Instead, we privatize profits and socialize losses. I think a lot of people are or should be very sick of that trend by now. That was his point." Perhaps the rebuttal was as strong as it was because flooding of land does not only affect landowners, it affects everyone who relies on that land (in one way or another). To give some examples: * People could live on the land and not own it. * People could work on the land and not own it. * People could rely on the land as part of a major transportation route and not own it. * People could rely on the land as part of the infrastructure that provides their food (e.g. a local supermarket, a farmer's market, a shipping dock, etc...) and not own it. Therefore, to restrict the concern to landowners only is shortsighted. The impacts are potentially far greater than just those felt by landowners.
- Hondor 10y ago
- rdtsc 10y agoI got to see a small scale example of a city sinking when on vacation in some islands off of North Carolina's shore. Some of those islands experience pretty aggressive erosion. Streets simply appear and disappear during tides. Large chunks of asphalt sticking out on the beach were a street used to be. Yet people still live there (well vacation mostly) even though during high tide in part they can fish from their porch. It was strange to see because that is not usually how homes and property are thought of. You buy, and hold on to it, and then sell it. There you buy and then the ocean comes and takes it, and it's gone. Most of those places were vacation homes, except for one where a little old lady was living permanently. We gave her all our groceries we had before leaving, She seemed rather grateful. I was wondering what her plans were for when erosion got to her house. I imagine asking that would upset her, so I didn't.
- mgalka 10y agoI've seen a lot of projections like this, showing areas that will someday be underwater when sea levels rise. But am I missing something? Why wouldn't people just build barriers to keep the water out? That may be prohibitively expensive for some places, but for Manhattan, I have to imagine the cost would be small compared to the alternative.
- tajen 10y agoThe author addresses it in the essay. Flooding comes in the form of storms every X years and super-high, rare tides, so barriers don't help. If storms are unfrequent enough, people keep occupying the area. In Manhattan, they've already thought about a barrier on the Hudson river, but it's prohibitively expensive, covers a few percent of the risks only, and worse, gives people the feeling that there's a solution. Plus they may solve the 2070 problem, but few things solve the 2100 problem, and nothing solves the 2200 problem: When the water is 30 feet higher, you just have to transform NYC into New Venice. Which makes me think, a change of name into "New Venice" might help people identify better with the new situation than every barrier.
- blue1 10y agoThe funny thing is that Venice, I mean the original one in Italy, seems also totally uninterested in this problem. After decades of discussion they have finally built these mobile barriers between the sea and the lagoon, which are supposed to protect the city from the periodic high tides ("acqua alta"). But apparently no one is thinking what will happen when the sea level will rise.
- gaadd33 10y agoWhy is it possible for the Netherlands to prevent flooding and reclaim land but not for New York City? Is there some inherent difference in geography?
- blahi 10y agoTokyo has solved this problem already. Random article I found, perhaps not the best. http://newlaunches.com/archives/a-tour-of-tokyos-alien-like-underground-temple-drains.php http://newlaunches.com/archives/a-tour-of-tokyos-alien-like-...
- fennecfoxen 10y ago> Jacob responded with a declaration that “our urban planning is irrelevant” and decried “shortsightedness of decision-making.” As an example, he cited the Hudson Yards development, just one of many waterfront megaprojects that the city has continued to enthusiastically promote, even after Sandy. He thinks that the government should instead rework its policies to relocate assets away from the water. I think Jacob commits the opposite error, failing to discount the future. If Manhattan real estate is worth "hundreds of billions of dollars" as an asset, then it's worth tens of billions of dollars a year as a value-stream. If we're talking something like Hurricane Sandy causing $33 billion in property damage in New York, that's maybe one year of the property market's value. That's a quite small "weather tax" in the grand scheme of things, and if we're talking a multi-century trend, well, it might come time to contemplate taking down the skyscraper after a few hundred years, assuming the world hasn't perished in a global thermonuclear war where Manhattan was the first target and assuming that the city still prospers. And remember that Manhattan is an island literally named "many hills". The Financial District is low-lying but only because it's artificial land. Midtown would be pretty solidly unaffected for a good little while.
- nordsieck 10y ago> If we're talking something like Hurricane Sandy causing $33 billion in property damage in New York, that's maybe one year of the property market's value. That's a quite small "weather tax" in the grand scheme of things, That's fine in theory. And if the US could get rid of federal flood insurance and not spend any government money fixing up New York when the next storm does damage, then it might be a fine state of affairs. But I don't know anyone who seriously thinks those are politically achievable, much less desirable goals.
- yummyfajitas 10y agoAlso, because we've lost the ability to build things in the US, we've forgotten that low lying land is a solvable problem. In fact, we already solved that problem in FiDi back before we gave up the social technology of building things. (Just look at our inability to build subways - something we were capable of 100 years ago and which desperately poor India and China do today.) When push comes to shove, we can just pay the Dutch or Singaporeans a lot of money to fix things for us.
- realusername 10y agoSomehow related to this article, I recommend reading the interesting SF novel "Depth" by Lev Ac Rosen (https://www.amazon.co.uk/Depth-Lev-AC-Rosen-ebook/dp/B00XGXAJXG https://www.amazon.co.uk/Depth-Lev-AC-Rosen-ebook/dp/B00XGXA...). The novel takes place in a future where New York is underwater and life is now arranged on the skyscrapers that are high enough to step outside. The isolation of the city, culturally and physically from the mainland affected a lot the city and this aspect is highly detailed in the novel.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- f_allwein 10y agointeresting talk on the global implications of climate change and rising sea levels: http://www.paragkhanna.com/home/2016/7/29/will-climate-change-force-human-migration http://www.paragkhanna.com/home/2016/7/29/will-climate-chang...
- spodek 10y agoAs usual, nothing about prevention. > “One way or another, we get educated, and it’s much cheaper to listen once in a while to engineers and scientists.” Global temperatures and the sea level are rising because of human behavior. If we want different results, we have to behave differently. Engineers and scientists know engineering and science but not so much leading people to change their behavior. It's easy to blame others: "Listen to me! If you don't you'll be sorry!" isn't effective. Also, what fraction of engineers and scientists have, say, flown in a plane or something similarly polluting in the past twelve months? If you want to change behavior, you need to learn and practice leadership skills and apply them to yourself as well as others. The science is clear. More is nice and I agree we should keep pursuing it, but the best way to decrease the effects of global warming is to change our behavior. (This is why I moved from science to leadership.) This article's writing about flood-proof architecture and other rearranging-deck-chairs-on-the-Titanic behavior is necessary since it's too late to stop a lot of change, but it's not too late to stop the change that we -- you and I -- are contributing to now. As much as I wish past generations had changed their behaviors so we wouldn't see these problems today, future generations will wish we had changed our behavior today. Even if you don't have kids or grandkids, I would think caring about human society in general and empathy and compassion for future generations would be enough to focus on changing our behavior proactively, not just reactively fixing problems others bequeathed to us.
- kijin 10y agoCall me a pessimist, but I don't think people will "change behavior" just because somebody told them to. They won't change even if they begin to suffer for it. Homes in parts of Southern Florida are already getting flooded on a regular basis, even in clear weather. Are those homeowners burning less gas because of it? Not really. The high oil prices of the early 2010s did little to curb CO2 production worldwide. People really don't want to change unless they're too poor to afford fossil fuels, and making everyone poor is probably not a good solution, either. Calling for abstinence doesn't work in energy consumption any more than it does in sex education. To hope otherwise is wishful thinking. More depressing is the fact that even if a lot of us drastically reduced our carbon footprint right now, what's going to happen is going to happen anyway. The amount of CO2 that's already in the atmosphere is enough to cause catastrophe over the next few decades. So I think the scientific and engineering prowess of the world would be better spent trying to help people cope with the consequences of global warming than trying to persuade them to change their habits. This Titanic is going down no matter how hard you try to steer it away from that iceberg. Stop wasting time trying to argue with people who think the ship is okay. Use that time to build more lifeboats instead, because we barely have any time to do even that. Use nuclear power to sequester massive amounts of CO2 someplace deep. Bulld walls around major coastal cities. Relocate people in vulnerable areas to higher ground. Start planting crops that tolerate heat better, and move current crops further north -- there's gonna be a lot of newly arable land in Canada and Russia. Use desalination and new agricultural techniques to fight against drought. Put more research into malaria prevention, or better yet, exterminate mosquitoes altogether. (A very large portion of projected loss of life associated with global warming is due to 1. drought and 2. increased mosquito activity.)
- susan_hall 10y agoA lot of the articles that focus on rising oceans, and how they might effect the USA, seem to confuse the general issue of global warming with the specific issue of Florida. The situation in Florida might be hopeless, but why should that effect how we talk about other USA urban centers? This article is an example. It talks about New York as if the situation in New York is as hopeless as the situation in Florida. It's important to remember that much of the USA coastline can be defended the same way that the Dutch defend their coastline: build a lot of dykes around any urban area that is of high value. This strategy would work just fine for much of the northern eastern coast of the USA. The big exception is Florida. Because much of southern Florida sits on porous limestone, it is useless to build dykes for Florida. The ocean would simply go under the dyke. Figuring out how we might save Florida is a very difficult issue, and it might be impossible. But figuring out how to save New York is straight forward. The techniques that the Dutch developed 500 years ago would work just fine for New York today. Yes, it would be very expensive, but the payments can be stretched out over 100 years -- the projects can be implemented gradually, as the oceans rise gradually. A staggering $1 trillion price tag is a trivial $10 billion a year, over 100 years. One could reasonably argue that we can't build a dyke for the whole east coast. That is probably true. Some farmland will be sacrificed, some fishing villages will be sacrificed. But can we build enough dykes to protect New York? Obviously. If the Dutch could do this in the 1500s, why can't we do it now?
- Hondor 10y agoPromoting ways to protect ourselves from global warming instead of preventing dilutes the popular rhetoric of "reduce emissions now or we're doomed!" If there's enough publicity given to your kind of idea, then people might relax and not worry enough. Without them worrying enough, they might not do anything to prevent it. That kind of makes you wonder why try to prevent it anyway. So to answer "why can't we do it now?" We can. We just don't want to talk about it yet because sheeples.