5 ms·
Maths in a Twist [pdf]
- blintz 10y agoAfter trying the last puzzle for a while, I think I've concluded it's a torus - is that right?
- ColinWright 10y agoNope. Added in edit: I'm not going to answer any other questions or suggestions - I'd love to see the working behind the answers. Why should it be a Torus? Why should it be a Klein Bottle? Why should it be what you claim? Show me your working! FWIW, as and when I get the chance I will upvote every guess that shows its working.
- Chinjut 10y agoA Mobius strip.
- ColinWright 10y agoWorking?
- Chinjut 10y agoThis is not the best wording, but it's what I have for now: Label the top, left, bottom, and right edges of the square T, L, B, and R, respectively (so T and L are the ones which must be glued to each other, in suitable fashion). Cut the square down the \ diagonal; this produces two pieces: an L\B triangle and a T\R triangle. Mark the \ sides of these pieces as having to be ultimately glued to each other in the appropriate fashion, and now re-attach them in the way in which L and T are already indicated to be glued (in the process, flipping one of them over). Now one has the equivalent of the M diagram from before, and thus a Mobius strip.
- nobriot 10y agoI also find a Mobius strip, I made the same reasoning
- jsprogrammer 10y agoI believe the bottom of L (BL) must coincide with the left of T (LT) and the top of L (TL) must coincide with the right of T (RT); however, musn't all four points coincide in order to properly reglue the \ diagonal? Wouldn't this appear as a "crimped Möbius strip" (if it is even possible)?
- smallnamespace 10y agoAnother way to get to this, with perhaps wrong reasoning: 1. Deform the figure until the non-arrowed edges are a disc, and the arrowed edges are next to one another, so you have something like a Pac man figure where the arrowed edges are the mouth. 2. This figure clearly has 1 edge (the outer edge) but only 1 side -- to get to the 'back' side, go through the mouth Since all the matters topologically is number of edges and sides, this is identical to a Mobius strip.
- ColinWright 10y ago> Since all the matters topologically > is number of edges and sides, ... That turns out not to be the case. A torus with a hole and a sphere with a hole both have two sides and one edge. A Klein Bottle with a hole also has one side and one edge, and is not a Möbius strip. So that's not enough, and might not be right.
- smallnamespace 10y agoYeah I think a problem with this article is that hints at what you can do in topology, but it doesn't really explicitly tell you what all the rules of the game are.
- ColinWright 10y agoI guess to some extent that's the difference between an article intended for a general audience, and an actual proper course on point-set topology. There are limits to what you can cover.
- jacobolus 10y agoSpeaking of topology, check out this numberphile video from a couple days ago: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k8Rxep2Mkp8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k8Rxep2Mkp8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6Qpfv5y-7WU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6Qpfv5y-7WU Cliff Stoll is a treasure.
- panic 10y agoIt's a Mobius strip: http://i.imgur.com/1MVkbta.png http://i.imgur.com/1MVkbta.png
- ColinWright 10y agoInteresting. Are you sure a single point can be stretched out to a line? Certainly lines can be stretched or shrunk, but having a point become a line seems a bit of a stretch (if you'll pardon the pun). It's a nice argument, but is it valid ... ?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- coherentpony 10y agoIt isn't valid. If it were, the cylinder and the cone would be identical.
- panic 10y agoI'm pretty sure it's valid as long as you put the line back to a point at the end.
- coherentpony 10y agoHmmm, actually now that I think about it I'm starting to believe it.
- panic 10y agoThe idea is that the red point is being identified with the entire line, not stretched. My math is a little rusty, but I think you can make a diagram like http://i.imgur.com/PchSkyI.png http://i.imgur.com/PchSkyI.png and use the fact that Q1 and Q2 are quotient maps to define g and show it's a homeomorphism. The argument goes something like: there's a universal property on quotient spaces X with quotient map Q which says that if F(a) = F(b) for all a and b in X such that a and b are identified (a ~ b), there's a unique continuous G such that F = G ∘ Q. So let's take a and b in the top left space. We have a homeomorphism f such that a ~ b if and only if f(a) ~ f(b). Since quotients take equivalent elements to equal elements, Q2(f(a)) = Q2(f(b)). Therefore there's a unique continuous g1 such that Q2 ∘ f = g1 ∘ Q1. We can apply the the same reasoning to Q1 ∘ f^-1 to get a unique continuous g2 such that Q1 ∘ f^-1 = g2 ∘ Q2. Furthermore, g1 and g2 are inverses: g1 ∘ g2 ∘ Q2 = g1 ∘ Q1 ∘ f^-1 = Q2 ∘ f ∘ f^-1 = Q2, and Q2 is surjective. Therefore g = g1 is a homeomorphism.
- kmm 10y agoI think that can't be because a torus doesn't an edge, and the figure clearly still has one
- drostie 10y agoCorrect. If it helps, the given diagram clearly has exactly one edge and exactly one surface.
- javitury 10y agoMAYBE SPOILER For the last problem you can bend the sheet such as the two arrows point in to the same direction(up) and are in the same side, that is a rectangle. On the side of the arrows(left of the rectangle), the bottom half is an arrow pointing up and the upper half is an arrow also pointing up. Then you bend the paper such that the lower side meets the center and the wrap around the upper side around the previous bend. I got a cilinder
- CarolineW 10y agoIf I've followed you correctly, I don't think you get a cylinder.
- javitury 10y agoYou are right. In the last step, the top arrow has to be bent outwards and then joined against the bottom arrow, instead of overlapping like I previously did/imagined. The result is a figure with one surface and one edge, like the one NateyJay points out: its a mobius strip.
- JadeNB 10y agoSince it's Colin himself posting this, I guess that he linked to where he intended; but, if you're interested in this article, then you may want to look at more of "Mathematics Today", the publication in which this article appears: http://www.ima.org.uk/activities/publications/mathematics_today.cfm.html http://www.ima.org.uk/activities/publications/mathematics_to... .
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- NateyJay 10y agoBy just stretching, I also think it's a Mobius strip: http://i.imgur.com/sshZhxs.png http://i.imgur.com/sshZhxs.png The only way to get the arrows to connect right is if three of the square's corners are the same point.
- drostie 10y agoThe cutting solution is a bit more easy to follow, in my opinion... http://imgur.com/gallery/eBQq4 http://imgur.com/gallery/eBQq4
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]