8 ms·
Robots Can’t Dance – Why the singularity is greatly exaggerated (2015)
- anotheryou 10y agorobots are far from doing art interesting to us, but what's exaggerated? "singularity" is only mentioned in the title... We would need to define interesting art too though. Robots can draw likable patterns and flowers, just not the more intellectual or personal stuff. For my personal definition of interesting art: most anyone can do it, even some robots, but only few can do it on purpose. Like the difference between accidental, surreal moments in strangers conversations and the dialog in a Kaurismäki movie.
- awesomepantsm 10y agoI dunno. Robots already can make artistic artifacts, but certainly it wouldn't really be considered "good", but I would still stay it's interesting to us. http://arstechnica.com/the-multiverse/2016/06/an-ai-wrote-this-movie-and-its-strangely-moving/ http://arstechnica.com/the-multiverse/2016/06/an-ai-wrote-th...
- rimantas 10y agoComputers now can redo paintings in van Gogh style. Can they invent van Gogh style though?…
- GarrisonPrime 10y agoIt could be that art is highly subjective from species to species. What is stimulating to a chimpanzee may not spark any emotions in a gorilla, and vice-versa. Just because 'bots may not create "human art" doesn't mean they'd be incapable of producing art at all.
- anotheryou 10y agoWe need a robot connoisseur! I think so far there is none
- pmoriarty 10y agoTo me the interesting question isn't whether what the robot is doing is "good art" or "really art", but rather whether it's really the robot doing it or whether it's actually the robot's creator(s) doing it by means of the robot. In other words, the question of agency and responsibility. Can robots be truly independent and responsible for their own actions, or are they always nothing more than extensions of their creators?
- anotheryou 10y agoI'm often scared how much of me is clearly my father... And you know how google was afraid to use deep learning for search results, because they could not understand what it actually does and how it comes up with decisions?
- pixl97 10y agoAre you truly independent or are you just nothing more than an extension of the society you live in?
- harshreality 10y agoReads like an article written 5-10 years ago, not to mention it doesn't mention neural networks (by name) even once. Forget the singularity... the article doesn't mention the singularity except in the title. This is a "computers aren't special they can never be like us" article, based on an interview with a single person who seems more focused on robotics than neural network research. It doesn't prove anything about the future of AI to give anecdotal examples of computers failing at being intelligent (nobody has claimed that they are human-level at most things, yet), and then draw conclusions from that biased data. It's more like a half-interview half-essay of a discussion with an AI skeptic who doesn't bring up any of the modern (as of 2015 when the article was published) approaches to AI, and goes on irrelevant tangents like the uncanny valley (which has to do with HCI, not the singularity or AI creativity, which are the subjects of the article).
- freyr 10y agoIn the last five years, AI/ML has gotten better at some things it was previously mediocre/good at, but what progress towards creativity or singularity has there been? None. DL is not an enabling technology for creativity.
- CuriouslyC 10y agoThis is something it amazes me more people don't see. I've read a lot of the scientific literature on human creativity (there isn't much) and it is quite clear that we don't understand it at all. Additionally, there is a transformation that takes place in our brains from information to knowledge. Our understanding of this process is also pretty weak. Both of these problems are fundamental to the creation of true, autonomous AI.
- M_Grey 10y agoBoth of those problems might be something we need to solve, or it might emerge out of the complexity of a sufficiently advanced AI system. If the latter, we might not seeing coming for exactly the reasons you've outlined as making that emergence unlikely.
- MollyR 10y agoThis reminds of a scene from I, Robot. Detective Del Spooner: Human beings have dreams. Even dogs have dreams, but not you, you are just a machine. An imitation of life. Can a robot write a symphony? Can a robot turn a... canvas into a beautiful masterpiece? Sonny: Can you? Detective Del Spooner: (Doesn't respond,looks irritated) EDIT : this a scene from the will smith movie
- forgotpwtomain 10y agoIt might make sense to clarify that you are referencing the (late and unrelated) hollywood film vs https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/I,_Robot https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/I,_Robot.
- throwanem 10y agoWhich is the annoyingly weak answer. Rather say: Spooner: No. But some humans can. Can any robot? And see how it plays out from there.
- joesb 10y agoI don't see how the fact that some human can do it can be used to justify the properties of another human. Are you rich because Bill Gates is rich? It doesn't matter if all robot can't or that some human can, because we are judging an individual. So if Spooner can't do it, yet he still thinks he has some value than the robot, then clearly it's not ability to compose symphony that matters.
- Synaesthesia 10y agoThe creative faculty is much more than just composing symphonies though, the simple act of speaking, is a creative process. Every time you speak your utterances can be arbitrarily long, and unique - have probably never been expressed, in that particular order. So that's something all humans can do.
- pixl97 10y ago
- hxegon 10y agoStrikes me as weird to ask a robotics expert about an artificial intelligence question.
- tnecniv 10y agoRobotics is a very diverse field with a lot of different problems. There's plenty of people in it who do hardcore AI. A lot of the time, the results developed by roboticist can be used more generally, they just picked robotics as their application domain. Robotics also has some different constraints that can make problems interesting -- namely computation time and safety requirements.
- hxegon 10y agoI agree about robotics being a diverse field, but from his history it didn't sound like he had any serious AI experience. I can't think that if he did, the article wouldn't cite it right?
- TeMPOraL 10y agoIt's probably what you do when you need something for an article that would sell good to the public. General population doesn't understand that intelligence doesn't need a physical body to be useful, or dangerous.
- imgabe 10y agoWhat? Robots have been dancing since the mid-80s at least: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7xyz42OBQOQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7xyz42OBQOQ
- tim333 10y agoCall that dancing? Now this is dancing https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=51vQo-imc4Q&feature=youtu.be&t=35s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=51vQo-imc4Q&feature=youtu.be...
- ThomPete 10y agoIt is so sad that this very important discussion keep getting sidetracked by strawmen. Anyone who can't explain how they at one side have no problem believing in evolution which took us from non-biological material into biological creatures who can think and create computers, but somehow have a problem believing evolution could continue via technology I have no interest listening to. The reality is we don't know what happens but we do know that we are seeing more and more complexity in technology which via ex. the internet is following it's own network effects and is showing increasing capabilities of intelligent behavior. Whether machines will be self-aware and push us toward the singularity or this increasing intelligence just become a danger by it's sheer computational power is mostly academic. The fact is that the Singularity _can_ happen and we would be wise to think about how to deal with this.
- rsl7 10y agoFine, let's say the singularity could happen. How do you know what form it will take and thus how to prepare for it? We don't have any evidence or examples of artificial human intelligence or something beyond us. Everything we humans build falls apart, there is nothing remotely resembling self-perpetuation of any sort. Where is the evidence that tech can do this? This singularity talk sounds, at best, like imagining flying ships in the 14th century. It might happen. But we have a long, long way to go and we have no idea how it will work.
- ThomPete 10y agoWhat evidence was there of humans before they were around? We can see there is emerging complexity, we can see there is increasing ability to solve more and more complex tasks, we can see that machines can learn, we can see that they are able to work together in ever larger networks and across all devices, we can see that it's happening at an accelerating rate and we kind of know what exponential curves do, I don't see anything but evidence that this is a likely future scenario. And unless you are saying it requires an intelligent designer to create intelligence which would make you religious I have a hard time understanding exactly what you are objecting to? What we do know is that it's going to happen through technology and that's where we have the most ability to actually attempt to do something to steer this in the right direction.
- Pica_soO 10y agoI don't know.. every other day when you open hacker news, suddenly something out of science fiction or fantasy raises its head, blinks back into the light and dances out in the street. Sometimes company get disrupted, that where there predecessors ruptores not a year ago. I'm actually a little bit scared of the singularity, in particularly the pressure it puts on humanity to speed up (with ampethamines, trainings (begining in kindergarten) and soon to come implants). So i would cheer on anyone having proof its not happening - if it where not for the fact, that failing and falling back into linear acceleration, would mean a catastrophe for a world of 7 billion either. If i have a choice between the likes of ISIS piling heads in the streets and skynet piling heads in the streets, i rather choose skynet- at least there is a little chance for humanity.
- wavefunction 10y agoI would dance with a robot, and then the Singularity could be greatly under-appreciated.
- D-Coder 10y ago"Do airplanes fly?" They don't flap their wings or have feathers or eat bugs. But they do something similar to birds, and useful, so we call it "flying." "Do submarines swim?" They don't propel themselves with their tails, or extract oxygen from the water with their gills. But they travel underwater, so... one could use that word. "Do computers think?" They definitely won't "think" the same way humans do. But some day they will generate results that look more or less like thinking, at least in some useful areas, so...
- pjdorrell 10y agoSome the examples given in the article are about creativity in relation to art forms intended for human consumption. If I try to program a robot to create art that humans will appreciate, my robot has the disadvantage of not having immediate access to a human response to the art in question, because my robot isn't a human. Whereas a human artist painting a picture can immediately and continuously judge the artistic quality of his or her efforts so far.