8 ms·
In the Beginning Was the Command Line (1999)
- Kadin 10y agoI actually find this version, with commentary added in 2004, somewhat more interesting than the original: http://garote.bdmonkeys.net/commandline/index.html http://garote.bdmonkeys.net/commandline/index.html The 2004 comments are now of course 12 years old, so they're not much newer than the original text, but it's interesting to have two datapoints to draw a line between (1999 and 2004) and see where the trajectory of the future seemed to be headed over that period, versus where it actually landed.
- meeper16 10y agoHow is it that the development world lost track of what a command line is and how powerful it it is? Lets stop calling it the CLI.
- dang 10y agoLots of submissions: https://hn.algolia.com/?query=In%20the%20Beginning%20Was%20the%20Command%20Line&sort=byDate&dateRange=all&type=story&storyText=false&prefix&page=0 https://hn.algolia.com/?query=In%20the%20Beginning%20Was%20t... But no major thread in a long time, it looks like: https://hn.algolia.com/?query=In%20the%20Beginning%20Was%20the%20Command%20Line%20points%3E3&sort=byDate&dateRange=all&type=story&storyText=false&prefix&page=0 https://hn.algolia.com/?query=In%20the%20Beginning%20Was%20t.... So by HN's standards this isn't a dupe: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsfaq.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsfaq.html.
- leoc 10y agoReproducing an ooold comment from elsewhere https://www.reddit.com/r/programming/comments/hwnm/unix_the_hole_hawg/ci4x8 https://www.reddit.com/r/programming/comments/hwnm/unix_the_... : The real problem with Stevenson's account is that the command line is no more the True Reality Behind Appearances than the GUI is; it's just another shadow on the cave wall. (Especially on Unix, where the shell is just another user-space program.) Eben Moglen identified the problem with the GUI (as we know it) http://www.cabinetmagazine.org/issues/1/i_moglen_1.php http://www.cabinetmagazine.org/issues/1/i_moglen_1.php more precisely: > What I saw in the Xerox PARC technology was the caveman interface, you point and you grunt. A massive winding down, regressing away from language, in order to address the technological nervousness of the user. Users wanted to be infantilized, to return to a pre-linguistic condition in the using of computers, and the Xerox PARC technology`s primary advantage was that it allowed users to address computers in a pre-linguistic way. This was to my mind a terribly socially retrograde thing to do, and I have not changed my mind about that. (Which seems a fairer comment on the Lisa or Macintosh than the [2016 edit: LRC work] at PARC, where they were trying to teach children to program http://portal.acm.org/citation.cfm?id=155364&dl=ACM&coll=portal http://portal.acm.org/citation.cfm?id=155364&dl=ACM&coll=por... .) In Doug Engelbart's words http://www.technologyreview.com/read_article.aspx?ch=infotech&sc=&id=11992&pg=4 http://www.technologyreview.com/read_article.aspx?ch=infotec... : > Here's the language they're proposing: You point to something and grunt.
- qwertyuiop924 10y agoI disagree. True, command lines are another shadow on the cave wall, but they're a sharper shadow: they show more of what's actually happening, and they give you tools to get more information about, as Stephenson would put it, "the tangled nam-shubs beneath." This is arguably not inherent to the command line, but it's definitely inerent to how GUIs work: GUIs cannot compose, are harder to script, and cannot show the kind of info CLIs can, if they wish to remain accessible (there's a reason there's no graphical method to get the inode number of a file). I think Stephenson expressed this quite well.
- pwdisswordfish 10y agoNothing stops you from putting the inode number in a copyable field in a "file properties" window. Now, of course there is basically nothing you can do with an inode number in a graphical environment, but then there is also very little you can do with it in a command line as well. Omitting this detail is not something "inerent" to graphical interfaces.
- qwertyuiop924 10y agoFair enough: for that particular detail. The point is, when UX matters, you cannot add mode switch (like command line flags), and you can't give the user all the data: their eyes would pop out. The GUI is a higher level abstraction: lack of control is the tradeoff.
- rer 10y agoWhat if the data where there but not in front of their eyes. I want there to be data there.
- rer 10y agoHow would you do GUIs to make them compose, script, and show the kind of info CLIs can?
- 10y ago
- chias 10y agoThis is wholly tangential to the thesis, but When Ronald Reagan was a radio announcer, he used to call baseball games by reading the terse descriptions that trickled in over the telegraph wire and were printed out on a paper tape. He would sit there, all by himself in a padded room with a microphone, and the paper tape would eke out of the machine and crawl over the palm of his hand printed with cryptic abbreviations. If the count went to three and two, Reagan would describe the scene as he saw it in his mind's eye: "The brawny left-hander steps out of the batter's box to wipe the sweat from his brow. The umpire steps forward to sweep the dirt from home plate." and so on. When the cryptogram on the paper tape announced a base hit, he would whack the edge of the table with a pencil, creating a little sound effect, and describe the arc of the ball as if he could actually see it. His listeners, many of whom presumably thought that Reagan was actually at the ballpark watching the game, would reconstruct the scene in their minds according to his descriptions. I'll be damned if Ronald Reagan wouldn't have made an amazing Dungeon Master.
- gumby 10y agoReagan wasn't the only one doing this; this is how radio broadcasting worked (essentially they functioned as human repeaters, and decompressors of lossy compression). I always think of this when I hear about programs that generate news stories from game statistics or financial reports (companies like Narrative Science or Automated Insights)
- macintux 10y agoMaybe this should be the real Turing test: can you fool a baseball audience by reconstructing every play of a game from its stats?
- Retric 10y agoSeems relatively easy to fake. Remember nothing has passed the actual touring test which is very open ended, but lesser versions have been beaten.
- 10y ago
- coldcode 10y agoWhat I think in the beginning was a stack of cardboard with holes in it. I remember talking with old programmers in my first job who started out programming with switches, who by that point in the early 80's were using terminals to write batch programs with one compile-run cycle per day (they usually worked on multiple apps at a time this way). You won't catch me lamenting progress.
- krylon 10y agoThe description of emacs never fails to make me smile: "emacs outshines all other editing software in approximately the same way that the noonday sun does the stars. It is not just bigger and brighter; it simply makes everything else vanish"
- Esau 10y agoI remember this essay fondly because, at the time, I was using BeOS. Seems so long ago now.
- qwertyuiop924 10y agoIBWCL is dated, true, but it's still an excellent essay, and I would argue required reading for anyone learning about programming, computing, and/or UX/UI. If nothing else, it provides an excellent understanding of what abstractions are, and what sort of tradeoffs you make by using one, while still being more or less comprenhensible to the layman, unlike Steve Yegge, who covers more programming-specific topics, although often of the same nature. Knowing this stuff is important, because in computing, abstractions are pretty much what we do. We build them, manipulate them, argue about them, consider them harmful, and continue to travel up and down the endless stack of turtles. Knowing why the endless stack of turtles exists is important and useful, and that's part of what this essay provides.
- phjesusthatguy3 10y agoI first read this essay as an ebook on my Newton (what was the 3rd party tool? Paperback?), and the title mislead me to believe I was reading Cryponomicon, so I was highly surprised when I read the actual Cryptonomicon. Man, this Android phone I'm carrying around now is such a step down from that Newton.
- GrumpyYoungMan 10y agoFrom a Slashdot interview with Neal Stephenson in 2004: "I embraced OS X as soon as it was available and have never looked back. So a lot of 'In the beginning was the command line' is now obsolete. I keep meaning to update it, but if I'm honest with myself, I have to say this is unlikely." https://slashdot.org/story/04/10/20/1518217/neal-stephenson-responds-with-wit-and-humor https://slashdot.org/story/04/10/20/1518217/neal-stephenson-...
- chippy 10y agoMany people since 2004 have "embraced" the whole Apple ecosystem of tools, hardware and software. They actually cannot look back now. It's literally almost impossible for Stephenson and many other of our contemporaries to look back and choose another way. To do so is literally more pain than is worth. To even contemplate an alternative means negating the investment in Apple. To turn your back on the investment of time, money, effort would mean the benefits of change would need to be greater (or the pain of staying would be worse). It's not going to happen: those who embrace Apple remain within Apple's bosom.
- throwanem 10y agoWhat? Did Sierra stop being Unix and nobody's mentioned it before now? Or is there something about owning a MacBook Pro that makes it impossible ever to buy a Thinkpad again? Something about owning an iPhone that makes Android unimaginable? Perhaps you'd argue that there is. In order to do so, you'd need to explain why there is a distinction to be made here between Apple and literally every other software and hardware manufacturer on the planet. That such a distinction exists constitutes an implicit prior in what you've said above. I don't agree even that that is true, let alone that it's self-evident. You have the opportunity to convince me otherwise.
- digi_owl 10y agoYes and no. Yes the core is BSD derived unix, but OSX is also a massive layer of libs on top that is proprietary to OSX. So unless the developer takes outmost care to not touch anything that makes OSX, well, OSX, its damn hard to transfer anything over to a _nix from OSX.
- zwass 10y agoThis essay set me off on an Odyssey of discovery and exploration. I learned emacs, Bash, gained an appreciation for abstractions in a mindset strongly influenced by this philosophy. If you enjoyed his essay, it is well worth reading Neal Stephenson's novels. I would start with Cryptonomicon or Snowcrash.
- mroll 10y agoI recommended Stephenson to a friend today and suggested they start with the same two :)
- hossbeast 10y agoQuoting from the end, I think that the message is very clear here: somewhere outside of and beyond our universe is an operating system, coded up over incalculable spans of time by some kind of hacker-demiurge. The cosmic operating system uses a command-line interface. It runs on something like a teletype, with lots of noise and heat; punched-out bits flutter down into its hopper like drifting stars. The demiurge sits at his teletype, pounding out one command line after another, specifying the values of fundamental constants of physics: universe -G 6.672e-11 -e 1.602e-19 -h 6.626e-34 -protonmass 1.673e-27....
- gopher2 10y agoDang. What great writing! Descriptive, interesting, inspiring. It just makes me smile and I'm glad this was shared. It seems like a classic that lots of people are familiar with, but I've never read it before.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- marmot777 10y agoI upvoted this for the title alone. Classic!