6 ms·
They could start by rejecting the default assumption that nudity should be considered sexual by default. And maybe the default assumption that sexuality is bad
by pessimizer 10y ago
They could start by rejecting the default assumption that nudity should be considered sexual by default. And maybe the default assumption that sexuality is bad - I don't want them to shift to trying to detect if an image is arousing or not; but I do want whatever censorship system they feel they need to have in place to be able to distinguish between child pornography and a photograph of a child being burned by napalm. "Really fucking stupid" is an understatement.
- forgottenpass 10y agoThey could start by rejecting the default assumption that nudity should be considered sexual by default. And maybe the default assumption that sexuality is bad I agree with the suggestion, but can't help but laugh at how impractical it is. The people who would make the change are bay area progressives working in tech. And that means saying all the "right" things about sex positivity but stopping short of actually becoming sex positive.
- CaptSpify 10y agowell, yeah. that would hurt their bottom line
- xapata 10y ago> being burned by napalm I didn't see any napalm in the image. The girl had removed her burning clothes before the photograph was taken. The reason this particular image is considered acceptable is the historical context. If I were to recreate the image by hiring actors, that would probably be considered child pornography.
- jMyles 10y ago> that would probably be considered child pornography. What on earth are you talking about? Is there anything even vaguely sexual about this photograph? Did I miss something?
- xapata 10y agoI was not talking about the photograph in the article, but a hypothetical recreation. Even if a photographer were to explain such a recreation were a satire or had some artistic value, I think many people would feel uncomfortable with it. Certainly most would not want their children to pose for such a photograph. From that thought experiment, I'm deducing that it's the historical context which makes the original photograph acceptable to distribute, and not anything intrinsic to the image.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> The girl had removed her burning clothes before the photograph was taken. Removing clothes after the napalm had burned through them (which was manifestly the case here) certainly may reduce the degree to which you are being burned by napalm, but does not mean you are no longer be burned by napalm. > If I were to recreate the image by hiring actors, that would probably be considered child pornography. Be considered by whom? Pornography requires more than simple nudity.
- xapata 10y agoShe may be burning during the photograph, but that is not obvious without the extra commentary. > Pornography requires more than simple nudity. Perhaps, but I can understand Facebook removing that photograph, just in case a judge thinks differently. Child pornography does not appear to be something the FBI takes lightly.