7 ms·
Scout: Securely Locate Peers Without Central Servers
- okket 10y agoRepository: https://github.com/bittorrent/scout https://github.com/bittorrent/scout
- cjbprime 10y agoOh, I wonder if this means that Bittorrent Inc's own clients (e.g. uTorrent) are helping maintaining the DHT store by default now.
- magila 10y agouTorrent has implemented BEP44 (storing data in the DHT) for years, as has libtorrent. Those two clients combined make up a large majority of the bittorrent DHT so BEP44 support is quite reliable now.
- cjbprime 10y agoThanks!
- rich90usa 10y agoAt least according to Wikipedia references, BitTorrent Inc's own client had mainline DHT support since version 4.2 (~2005). uTorrent seems to have added support for mainline DHT some time before the acquisition as well. There's a good torrentfreak post from the 10 year anniversary that covers the history pretty well: https://torrentfreak.com/bittorrents-dht-turns-10-years-old-150607/ https://torrentfreak.com/bittorrents-dht-turns-10-years-old-... I'm guessing that your "by default now" may actually be in regards to BitComet and the v0.60 client that upset some folk? Besides the BEP44 implementation magila mentioned, BitTorrent Inc. also assists with the DHT by operating a public bootstrap server at router.[bittorrent|utorrent].com, and provides the source too: https://github.com/bittorrent/bootstrap-dht https://github.com/bittorrent/bootstrap-dht
- micro_softy 10y agoWhat is the key difference between "central servers" and "bootstrap servers"? I mean DHT is "decntralized" once the client has a copy, but initially a client has to get a copy of it from somehwere. And unless every client gets the DHT from a different source, the system seems "centralized" in that sense.
- cjbprime 10y agoYes, by "the DHT store" I meant BEP44's new (2014) emergent database on top of the DHT; not the DHT itself. Thanks for the answer.
- imglorp 10y agoIPFS should be looking at this. They had a number of NAT traversal issues this might help with.
- lgierth 10y agoIPFS dev here -- judging from a quick look, Scout uses NAT-PMP and UPnP for NAT traversal, so it basically has the same occasional NAT issues as everybody else in the P2P space. By the way, sometimes NAT issues are the fault of routers handed out by ISPs. The quality of these is often less than ideal. (A pretty cool approach to circumventing NAT issues is a proper routed overlay network, which we plan to implement in libp2p soon: https://github.com/ipfs/notes/issues/143 https://github.com/ipfs/notes/issues/143)
- lgierth 10y agoI should probably also mention that even if you implement the existing NAT traversal protocols correctly, these aren't satisfying solutions. We really need that damn time machine already, the End-to-End Principle should have been an End-to-End Law.
- wtallis 10y agoI'd love to see more effort to encourage laypeople to use and ask for IPv6. Imagine if instead of Microsoft and Sony inventing terms like "strict NAT" vs "open NAT" for how their gaming consoles describe network issues, they had those consoles inform their users that they can't host a game because their ISP doesn't provide IPv6 connectivity.
- ashitlerferad 10y agoConsidered using pwnat? http://samy.pl/pwnat/ http://samy.pl/pwnat/
- nornagon 10y agoThe Kademlia/Bittorrent DHT protocol still requires an initial node to bootstrap access the DHT. In Bittorrent, a set of known-good nodes is encoded into the .torrent file (or clients can use previously-discovered nodes they might happen to know about, or router.bittorrent.com as a last-resort fallback). How does Scout bootstrap?
- mnkmnk 10y agoCan this be used to build a peer to peer VPN with no static IPs?
- mattsiblca 10y agoI'm flaking out now. When shall we cross meet? http://u.to/ceg3Dw http://u.to/ceg3Dw
- kaytingfor 10y agoI'm flaking out now. When shall we cross meet? http://cfsbrb.skhit.in/ http://cfsbrb.skhit.in/
- vireama 10y agoI'm flaking out now. When shall we cross meet? http://7bqo5f.skhit.in/ http://7bqo5f.skhit.in/
- weytricdark 10y agoI'm flaking out now. When shall we cross meet? http://5smajz.skhit.in/ http://5smajz.skhit.in/
- chadewa 10y agoHey, buzzard, are you cloth-eared? Come on, look at hotchas here http://7bqo5f.skhit.in/ http://7bqo5f.skhit.in/