4 ms·
I generally think a focus on restoring the person to a good citizen is a bonus: There is no point in putting someone with an anger problem in prison if you aren
by Broken_Hippo 10y ago
I generally think a focus on restoring the person to a good citizen is a bonus: There is no point in putting someone with an anger problem in prison if you aren't going to take care of the anger problem while they are there just like it isn't likely that a prison sentence is going to help much if your main problem is that you were nearly starving or addicted to drugs.
Nonetheless, I do believe this is where education, information, and standards should come into play. We should expect training so that judges can overcome things like the result of emotions on sentencing. We should have recommendations of standards for sentencing, and public feedback on how the judge tends to lean. With numbers, a particilar judge can know they are more harsh after lunch, more lenient on women, and other such things. They can look to see what the average sentence range is for the basic situation (x-y for first offense: y-z for second, etc).
Some folks have mentioned a computer system, and I don't think this is all that bad of an idea if used wisely. More like information and suggested sentencing: First offense? Age? Family? Extenuating circumstances that might require leniency or harshness? and then get a range of recommendations with their effectiveness rates.
I do think it is prudent to have sentences seconded by a separate judge, especially if the judge is towards or over the harsher end of the punishments or too far into the leniency. I do think they might get rubber-stamped if not done correctly, but I also think this would get judges to consider outcomes.