4 ms·
For many users, abandoning Facebook is like abandoning the web. So no matter what shit Facebook will pull they're not gonna leave, unless something better appea
by elorant 10y ago
For many users, abandoning Facebook is like abandoning the web. So no matter what shit Facebook will pull they're not gonna leave, unless something better appears.
From the other hand, this whole situation is a bit ludicrous. The journalist doesn't seem to understand how Facebook works and is directly attacking Zuckerberg like he explicitly asked to remove the picture. Come on guys, it's just an algorithm that detected nudity and decided to censor the pic. You can't write a rant like that and not understand how the damn thing works in the first place. It's poor journalism. And then you make the assumption that just because Mark has power he's using that power to manipulate the world. How the fuck is that objective reporting?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- blackoil 10y agoThe picture was removed by moderators, not algorithm. So Yes even though Zuckerberg did not delete the picture, he is responsible for acts and policies of the company.
- ivan_gammel 10y agoTechnically it's possible to have an index of all images published is some registered media and assume they are already vetted by editors of that media. Then you compare the published picture and voila - you do not have this problem at all. Of course, it adds some costs, but it's exactly what M.Zuckerberg can decide to spend money on (before delivering this service to people in Africa and other places where it's easy to abuse Facebook censor mechanisms - ask Russian opposition how Putin's media warriors take down their posts).
- elorant 10y agoIt’s not that simple. What about artistic nude for example? Would you allow a picture like the following, which could have appeared in dozens of art related magazines? https://www.saatchiart.com/art/Photography-vision/84309/2880890/view https://www.saatchiart.com/art/Photography-vision/84309/2880... I think that it’s much more safe to prohibit all nudity than nitpicking what to allow and what not. There are TBs of pictures uploaded daily on Facebook, it’s not a trivial task.
- ivan_gammel 10y agoWhat's wrong with this image? Of course it should be allowed. I see no difference with David by Michelangelo, for example. Banning all nudity is just stupid censorship that has no moral ground.
- elorant 10y agoI believe that a lot of conservative people would find a picture like that offensive. We have to keep in mind that Facebook's audience is in the billions.
- ivan_gammel 10y agoIt's not the reason for censorship. Facebook may offer parental control and display explicit content warnings to serve this audience. After all, people who find nudity offensive may limit their subscriptions to accounts which do not post it - it's not that they are forced to look at it.
- ntaenta 10y agoPeople who find nudity offensive are utterly delusional.
- dredmorbius 10y agoPeople are utterly delusional. Morality is very highly relative and contextual.
- alephnil 10y agoOr the journalist understand that it is automatic, but does not want a society where algorithms blindly determine what is allowed or not. After all "it's the algorithms" is a very convenient excuse for Facebook that allows them to be a faceless entity beyond criticism. It is Facebook that decide which algorithm they use to censor content, and they have chosen a rather prude set of policies they think will avoid offending anyone in any culture, and are very quick to remove controversial content. This is something Facebook have chosen to do, and to little degree something that is enforced on them.
- chris_wot 10y agoMan I hope something better comes along.
- dhimes 10y agoTFA said it wasn't algorithmic, that it was a response of a review team at FB