6 ms·
" its per capita electricity consumption is about one-quarter of, say, France or Belgium." Its in the bottom quartile worldwide I believe. Also the recommenda
by JoeAltmaier 10y ago
" its per capita electricity consumption is about one-quarter of, say, France or Belgium."
Its in the bottom quartile worldwide I believe.
Also the recommendations for the USA are way off. The "only way" to reach this goal is apparently to build lots of wind and solar. No mention whatsoever of nuclear, which is by far the more practical solution. And far less ecologically damaging.
- ZeroGravitas 10y ago> No mention whatsoever of nuclear, which is by far the more practical solution. And far less ecologically damaging. I vaguely follow developments in this area, and this seems to either outdated or simply untrue information. The people building traditional nuclear don't seem to be able to do so economically, even when they punt on insurance and eventual disposal. The people building the new nuclear which is going to eat up all the old nuclear waste don't seem to be making much progress, even in China where you'd assume they'd quite happily take a chance if this was anywhere near a viable state. Meanwhile, solar and wind are here today and prices continue to plummet. Any sensible economic or ecological assement would take into account the fact you can have solar up and running and contributing money/carbon savings on very short timescales, and do so in a distributed fashion, whereas you're talking potentially decades for nuclear which arrives all at once in a big lump.
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoThe ecological damage is not outdated info. Solar farms are essentially clear-cutting the land. No sun - no life. The ecosystem under the panels is completely disrupted. Not unlike strip-mining.
- cup 10y agoUnless its a desert area. Like most of Australia, Central Asia, North Africa etc.
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoThis again. For some reason the ecosystem of the desert is assumed to be worthless, and undeserving of preservation. This is an armchair ecologist idea that won't die. In fact the desert ecosystem is more sensitive to sunlight changes. Which makes sense when you think about it.
- jfaucett 10y agoWhich is not where the majority of solar energy is being deployed. The world leaders in solar energy production are the EU and China : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_power_by_country https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_power_by_country.
- Declanomous 10y agoChina has huge deserts. The Gobi and the Taklamakan cover a massive area of China. Edit: According to wikipedia, only 14.8% of China's land is arable. And that is for a country that is about the same size as the United States. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geography_of_China https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geography_of_China https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Deserts_of_China https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Deserts_of_China
- leojg 10y agoWhat do you propose then? Its obvious that any kind of human activity will produce some kind of alteration to the surrounding environment. Kill the whole planet with greenhouse gases or kill a small and already almost sterile area?
- wstrange 10y agoI think the OP would lean towards small scale reactors which have a minimal footprint. Measured by fatalities per k/W generated, nuclear is by far the safest form of power. The fear of nuclear is irrational.
- toomuchtodo 10y agoThe fear is irrational, but so is the cost. Nuclear always comes in over budget and with far greater construction delays than any other generation type. Even if you were to start on new reactors today, it would take a decade to complete them; a whole lot of wind and solar are going to be deployed in a decade.
- wstrange 10y agoI'd submit that those cost overruns are driven in part by the irrational fear. It has made it politically difficult to research and deploy safer and more cost-effective reactors.
- beat 10y ago"Fatalities per kw" is terrible risk management. I really wish nuclear activists would stop making crappy arguments. Risk analysis has two axis - likelihood, and impact. The maximum potential impact of solar/wind plant failure is negligible - what's it going to do, fall over on someone? Meanwhile, the maximum potential impact of virtually any civilian nuclear plant is massive - release of toxins and carcinogens over large residential areas, rendering them uninhabitable. Any respectable risk analysis requires looking at impact, not just likelihood.
- 10y ago
- jefurii 10y agoYou make it sound like solar farms are blocking off 100% of the solar radiation over the areas they cover. Have you actually seen any large solar installations? At the ones I've seen in the Mojave desert and Central Valley of California, the actual panels never cover 100% of the surface and a lot of backscatter light gets in even in the shade. I am not an ecologist but it seems like the effect would be more like having a bunch of trees in the desert. They do tend to remove the underbrush from around the panels, probably because it's easier to install/maintain that way. You could make a case for allowing more vegetation around/under the panels.
- yourapostasy 10y agoThere are numerous parking lots and parking structures, I'm gathering from your comment these are not big enough to make maintenance cost-effective compared to dedicated farms? Is anyone working on the problem of remotely-performed maintenance of multiple solar panel installations to reduce the maintenance labor footprint at each site?
- crdoconnor 10y ago>No mention whatsoever of nuclear, which is by far the more practical solution. And far less ecologically damaging. The UK's new Hinckley point power plant is both more expensive than solar/wind and puts the UK's energy generation in Chinese hands. There's a reason why Angela Merkel (relevant: probably the only physicist head of state) decided to shift to wind and solar.
- thorin 10y agoWell it might be but Theresa May still has a chance to veto it...
- icc97 10y ago> Angela Merkel (relevant: probably the only physicist head of state) That's actually fascinating. She was a physical chemist research scientist, not just undergraduate [1]. I wonder how many other scientist heads of state there have been. Margaret Thatcher was a research chemist (food scientist) [2], but that's the only other one I know of. Edit: she was the first British Prime Minister with a Science degree [3]. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Angela_Merkel [2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Margaret_Thatcher [3]: http://www.lrb.co.uk/v35/n11/david-runciman/rat-a-tat-a-tat-a-tat-a-tat
- DasIch 10y agoAngela Merkel didn't decide to shift to wind and solar. The Atomaustieg (the decision to abandon nuclear power) was made in 2000 by a coalition of the social democrats and the greens. The movement that lead to this decision goes back to the 70s, the green party actually stems from that. Merkel slowed down that process at a time where it stopped being that much of an issue and the process was put back on the initial schedule after Fukushima happened. Merkel is merely going with popular opinion on this.
- DenisM 10y agoThe problem with nuclear is that we can't trust the people running it to follow instructions without failure for decades in a row. Sooner or later a politician shows up and demands an experiment to be done, or maintenance to be postponed. Failures are rare, but the failure mode is catastrophic.
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoSodium salt / thorium reactors fail by ... stopping cold. So that's the way to go.
- mason240 10y agoWe have had 6 and half decades now of successful operation in the US.
- davedx 10y agoAre we conveniently ignoring Three Mile Island? It happened in 1979, 37 years ago. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Three_Mile_Island_accident https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Three_Mile_Island_accident
- mason240 10y agoThe only causality of TMI was the atmosphere. The following fear-mongering lead to and effective halt in the expansion of nuclear power.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- addicted 10y agoThe biggest problem with nuclear is that it's too expensive. Even after massive subsidies, it's more expensive than unsubsidized renewable alternatives would be. And the worst part for nuclear is that while solar and wind are getting significantly cheaper, nuclear is getting more expensive. Finally, the major costs for solar/wind at the moment is storage. With electric cars, and the fact that nearly every consumer company is spending money towards cheaper electricity storage, it's just a significantly better bet at the moment.
- bagacrap 10y agoHow much of that is down to climatological differences?
- jogjayr 10y agoI'm not up-to-date with nuclear. Is waste storage and disposal now a solved problem? Last I heard it had to be stored in hollowed-out mountains, walled in with concrete.
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoThorium reactors may have little waste, with a short halflife. Any modern design will work better than the decrepit plants that are responsible for so much regulation and fear.