4 ms·
It's also interesting because of how important it is. If people didn't believe the Earth was round or that smoking causes cancer, it would be sad and ridiculous
by mikeash 10y ago
It's also interesting because of how important it is. If people didn't believe the Earth was round or that smoking causes cancer, it would be sad and ridiculous but it wouldn't have a huge impact. Lots more lung cancer and heart disease deaths for the second one, but life goes on.
But this is one of the few issues where convincing people it's real makes a huge difference for our civilization. It's crazy (but perhaps also expected) that it's also one of the few issues where the scientific conclusion is simply not accepted by so many.
- curiousgeorgio 10y ago> this is one of the few issues where convincing people it's real makes a huge difference for our civilization Without arguing over the validity of AGW here, is there really any evidence that we could make a "huge difference" as you claim? Apart from using technology to deal with extreme climate conditions, is there anything demonstrably within the realm of human possibility that could significantly delay or reverse such climate change?
- mikeash 10y agoIt's too late to stop it, but greatly cutting CO2 emissions will make the damage much less severe. Climate change isn't a binary proposition, where we either get it or we don't. We're pretty much locked in to some degree of change at this point, but how much change we get still depends on how much more CO2 we dump into the atmosphere.
- malchow 10y ago"We're pretty much locked in to some degree" I'd say so! [1] [1] http://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/paleo/globalwarming/temperature-change.html http://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/paleo/globalwarming/temperature-cha...
- flukus 10y ago> Climate change isn't a binary proposition In some ways it kind of is. If we hit the threshold of a particularly nasty feedback mechanism then we go from little impact to severe impact quite quickly.
- curiousgeorgio 10y ago> cutting CO2 emissions will make the damage much less severe What does that actually mean? The best models of a few years ago predicted huge increases in the loss of life due to climate change by today, yet we continue to see a decrease in climate-related deaths (thanks to technology that helps people adapt to climate rather than the other way around). We've been wrong, not just in scale, but in the direction of the trend that (at least in my opinion) matters most. So if there is a warming trend, how much do you really think we can postpone or alleviate its effects by driving a Prius and using recycled shopping bags - in terms of human lives saved? Even under the completely unrealistic, hypothetical assumption that we could get every country on earth to make it priority #1, how does that affect the overall picture? Do you think, possibly, that kind of focus/priority might actually be a net loss if we sacrifice innovation that saves lives in the face of any climate change (as we do now) for a drop-in-the-bucket-scale difference in an otherwise unavoidable trend?
- mikeash 10y agoWhich models predicted a huge loss of life due to climate change by today? The technology for adapting to climate has been around for decades, so I'm skeptical that some change there has made a difference. Your mention of "recycled shopping bags" as if it had anything to do with climate change makes me suspect that you're not being entirely sincere here.
- zbyte64 10y agoYou are not wrong, simply driving a Prius won't save the world. If however we start including the actual costs to society in the cost of petro then you won't need to encourage people to drive hybrids or recycle. I am not so sure that the price of petro is negatively tied to innovation, or at least the innovations needed to mitigate global warming.
- woodandsteel 10y agoIt just occurred to me that pro-fossil fuel trolls might realize they are losing the argument that there is no anthropocentric global climate change, and instead decide fight government regulations by arguing it is out of control and so there is no point in trying to stop it.
- legolas2412 10y agoContrary to the climate change deniers, I think the models aren't aggressive enough. I have tried to read climate change predictions, and all models I saw predict CO2 concentration with reference with increases seen in history. The assumption is that history will model future correctly. However, I think that's really wrong. Right now 1.5 billion chinese are at middle income stage. What happens when they start polluting/consuming at first world levels? History hasn't seen such a migration and can't model that. What happens when 1.5 billion in South Asia and 1.5 billion in africa raise their per capita pollution? No historical data has seen effects this extreme. Changes as driving green cars/turning vegan/recycling are really good but might be far from sufficient. What's needed is complete shift to green energy right now. And even that may not be enough.
- MaysonL 10y agoStop using fossil fuels?
- zbyte64 10y agoOr at the very least stop distorting the market to favor fossil fuels over alternative energy sources.
- strommen 10y agoMitigation is the key word here. The best-case scenario is that over the next 30 years we ramp down our greenhouse emissions to zero, and the planet warms up by ~2 degrees Celsius and stays there. We're not currently on track for this, but it's still achievable (or close to it). The worst-case scenario is that we do nothing at all to solve the problem, and the planet warms up by 10+ degrees over the next century. And the temperature would continue to increase until we literally run out of fossil fuels to burn. There's a big difference between 2 and 10 degrees warming. I think modern civilization could survive the former, not so sure about the latter.
- curiousgeorgio 10y ago> and the planet warms up by ~2 degrees Celsius and stays there Everything I've read from the "experts" seems to suggest that we're experiencing a runaway trend that realistically cannot be stopped, regardless of what we do. Why should we believe 10 degrees, 2 degrees, or any of the figures mentioned are possible, probable, or frankly anything more than numbers pulled from a hat when they've been absolutely wrong, pretty much every time an "expert" has made predictions for more than about 5 years (and not just wrong by a hair, but by orders of magnitude)?
- infinite8s 10y agoDo you have any references to a scientific expert making a prediction that was off by orders of magnitude?
- antisthenes 10y agoAFAIK, we're already committed to a 2C rise by 2100 even if we stop any and all CO2 emissions today. And those models don't take into account potential feedback loops.
- nikdaheratik 10y agoBy "we" do you mean the few people reading this on the forum, or all of humanity? There are a number of actions that can be taken to keep things from getting too hot to handle. People seem to be under the mistaken assumption that AGW is a problem to be solved and then we can just go have a party of something and move on with our lives. It's more like a relay race for a world record or something. Each new technology or change gives us more time to get ahead of the problem. We may not see the end of the race no matter what, we can't even know if we're ahead really until 80-100 years from now, but we just gotta do the best we can on our leg and make things easier for the next runner when we pass off the baton. Getting as much coal (especially) and oil left in the ground as possible buys us more time before something bad happens. Advancing the tech for solar and wind or putting another non-fossil fuel power plant in place buys us more time. If we had to, we could go towards more extreme strategies like solar deflection or CO2 sequestering, but those are dicey at best. The end goal isn't a world without any problems, but some place where clean energy is everywhere and the potential for war, famine, and extreme weather is better than it otherwise would be. This isn't going to happen overnight, but then the problems that caused it started 100 years ago.